Daly Bread: Why the PNM’s internal affairs are a matter of public interest

I have examined the surprise announcement that the People’s National Movement (PNM) convention and internal election scheduled for November 17 had been cancelled and the further announcement swiftly, but ambiguously, walking back the cancellation decision.

My view remains that any apparent suppression of democracy within the PNM is a matter of public interest.

Camille Robinson-Regis, MP for Arouca/Maloney and Minister of Housing and Urban Development, centre.

There are, of course, strident PNM voices saying: “Stay out of PNM business.”

Interestingly, however, Minister Camille Robinson-Regis MP, a senior party figure, in the course of an attempt to smooth over the embarrassment of the two announcements, conceded that “the PNM is of great importance to Trinidad and Tobago and, therefore, (re-quoting the renowned CLR James) the internal life of the party cannot be separated from its public responsibilities.”

(See Trinidad Express of Friday, 25 October 2024, “In defence of PNM democracy”.)

I hope that the rest of the PNM hierarchy “gets the memo” that current events within the PNM are not merely PNM business, and here is another memo:

Prime Minister Keith Rowley.
Photo: US Department of State. Public domain.

Comment on the relationship of the purportedly cancelled PNM convention and internal election to the obvious leadership struggle to succeed the current Prime Minister as political leader of the PNM, a Pandora’s Box which he has himself opened, will not go away.

Displays of anger in denouncing those who do comment on the state of “the internal life” of the PNM are useless.

I have already put forward a reason why democracy in the PNM is important, namely that some of the PNM’s current ghastly ministerial failures need to face the democratic reckoning of the PNM membership.

Not surprisingly, National Security Minister Fitzgerald Hinds reportedly tasted rejection last Wednesday. Minister Robinson-Regis described the decision to cancel the convention as “a strategic decision”.

Minister of National Security Fitzgerald Hinds.
(Copyright TTPS)

For whose benefit is it strategic — the ghastly failures?

I re-emphasise that, in the public interest, the PNM needs to offer several fresh candidates, particularly because our choices as an electorate are likely to be limited by the staleness and previous rejections of the cling-on leadership of the now openly split Opposition United National Congress (UNC).

There is current early speculation that one likely outcome of the cumulative effect of the circumstances self-inflicting the split UNC is that it may lose some of the seats the party currently holds and that PNM may win a three-fifths majority of the 41 seats to be contested (a special majority vote victory).

Opposition leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar.
Photo: UNC

That speculation is subject to provisos. Can the PNM hold on to the two Tobago seats in the national House of Representatives, having been trounced in the last Tobago House of Assembly elections?

Another proviso is whether the PNM will be harmed by regular supporters staying home in disgust at the deplorable public safety situation.

The PNM leadership has resolutely refused to take any responsibility and has responded to the terrified public with condescension, insult, and lack of anger management.

(From left) Attorney general Reginald Armour SC, Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley and Minister of Energy and Energy Industries Stuart Young SC.
Photo: Office of the Parliament 2024

Will a default vote phenomenon adversely affect the PNM and mitigate the effects of the current lack of palatable Opposition, which might otherwise lead to the PNM achieving a special majority vote victory?

The danger of special or super-majority victories in national elections is currently a prevailing theme among political commentators. A notable example is the late President Hugo Chavez of Venezuela, who was able to become a constitutional dictator and establish such status as characteristic of that presidency.

Similarly, Viktor Orban, the current prime minister of Hungary (since 2013), was able to turn Hungary into “an electoral autocracy”.

Hugo Chávez in Porto Alegre, Brazil on 26 January 2003.
Photo by Agência Brasil, used under licence.

Chavez and Orban each had enough votes to cross super-majority thresholds and to set aside other constitutional check and balance mechanisms.

See “The Constitutional Path to Dictatorship in Venezuela” – Diego A Zambrano, 20 March 2019, Stanford University Law School” and “The Game Theory of Democracy” – Amanda Taub, New York Times, 29 October 29, referencing the work of Adam Przeworski, Polish-born political scientist, now an Emeritus Professor of Politics at New York University.

Meanwhile, in Mexico last week, the ruling party used its super-majority in Congress to pass a law banning legal challenges to constitutional changes.

Is this where we will land up as a result of the stagnation of the UNC and the closed-door manoeuvres of the PNM?

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: The fix that failed—PNM collapse started with Rowley’s sneaky succession moves

In October last year, almost immediately after a strong intimation in Parliament from then People’s National Movement (PNM) prime minister Read more

Kamla names Cabinet; Tancoo gets Finance, Sturge is Defence Minister, and Watts inherits Sport

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar selected her Cabinet today to serve Trinidad and Tobago, five days after her United National Congress Read more

Kamla dedicates term to T&T’s “forgotten people”; vows to improve citizens’ lives in six months

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar began her term in office with a message of love and optimism today, as she took Read more

PNM names ‘Penny’ as opposition leader; Rowley revokes posts of Imbert and Gadsby-Dolly

The People’s National Movement (PNM) has appointed Arima MP Pennelope Beckles as its opposition leader. Beckles, 64, was endorsed by Read more

Rowley, Young resign PNM posts; party seeks opposition leader, chair and vice-chair

Former prime minister Dr Keith Rowley vowed to resign as political leader of the People’s National Movement (PNM), just two Read more

Dear Editor: Much can be accomplished, once UNC doesn’t alienate any segment of T&T’s population!

Congratulations to the people of Trinidad and Tobago on a relatively peaceful and safe electoral process. Now that the ‘carnival Read more

Check Also

Vaneisa: Walking the talk; my ears are ringing with campaign promises—literally!

Perhaps the most surprising element of the general elections was the low voter turnout. According …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.