St Louis: PNM’s post-election confession betrays T&T’s cyclical governance issues

When in government, the People’s National Movement (PNM) speaks with the certainty of authority—decisions are made, policies defended, and dissent dismissed as misinformed or politically motivated.

The tone is top-down, and messaging emphasises competence, legacy and control. Consultation becomes performance, not practice.

Then Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley (seated) and his successor and Port of Spain North/ St Ann’s West MP Stuart Young.
Photo: OPM.

But in opposition—or after electoral defeat—a different voice emerges. Colm Imbert’s recent remarks at a PNM rally in Diego Martin reveal that shift with startling clarity.

Imbert, a senior figure and vice chairman of the party, admitted that the PNM’s loss in the 28 April general election was due to “stupid mistakes, poor communication, and a lack of democratic decision-making”.

These are not small admissions. They suggest that while in power, the party operated with insularity, making decisions without consultation and failing to connect with the people it claimed to represent.

Former Prime Minister and PNM political leader Dr Keith Rowley.

His statement that “stick break in our ears” is more than a colloquial lament; it’s an acknowledgement that the party stopped listening. Power had become a monologue. The population, sidelined and unheard.

Imbert’s blunt admission is not merely a reflection on internal missteps; it’s a quiet confession that those very errors may have compromised the governance of the country.

Decisions were made in isolation, voices were sidelined, and leadership grew disconnected from the people.

Diego Martin West candidate Hans des Vignes on nomination day.
Photo: PNM.

These weren’t just political flaws; they were failures that may have disrupted national focus, weakened institutional trust and left citizens questioning whether leadership was truly serving the country or simply managing the party.

The contrast is sharp. In government, the PNM projects an image of knowing best—governing “ten times better than anyone else”, as Imbert still insists. But in opposition, the party speaks of humility, of reconnecting, of listening.

Imbert’s call for the new leader, Pennelope Beckles, to “communicate with the people” and “connect with the population”, underscores this reactive posture. Dialogue returns only when silence becomes politically costly.

Opposition leader Pennelope Beckles (left) with PNM chair Dr Nyan Gadsby-Dolly and vice-chair Colm Imbert.
(via PNM.)

His reference to Kamala Harris’ memoir adds another layer, highlighting how ego and internal sabotage can derail progress. It suggests that within the PNM, leadership choices may have been shaped more by ambition than by service.

The phrase “lack of democratic decision-making” doesn’t just point to poor strategy; it suggests that voices were silenced, dissent was discouraged, and loyalty to leadership may have been enforced through intimidation rather than earned through respect.

It wasn’t just that the party stopped listening—it’s that many may have been afraid to speak.

Then Prime Minister Stuart Young (left) and La Horquetta/ Talparo MP Foster Cummings during the 2025 general election campaign.
(via PNM.)

The Newsday article, written by Sean Douglas, captures this moment with clarity. It does not editorialise; it simply presents Imbert’s words, allowing the contrast to speak for itself.

This article, then, becomes a mirror. It reflects a party that, while in power, treats the population as something to control—not something to understand.

But in defeat, the people are rediscovered; as if their value only becomes visible when it’s politically useful.

PNM political leader Pennelope Beckles poses with young supporters after her appointment as Opposition leader.
(via PNM.)

The tragedy is not just the timing of this recognition—it’s the pattern. And it’s not unique to the PNM. Across administrations, the voices of the people are often rediscovered only after power is lost.

When leadership listens only after demitting office, it reflects that they were never truly listening; they took the people for granted, governed with disdain and mistook silence for submission.

More from Wired868
Dear Editor: Demonising Independent senators is a dangerous attack on T&T’s democracy

I am not a politician. I’m certainly not a senator. I am just a citizen who pays attention. So, when Read more

A Tribute to The Mighty Sparrow: The Birdie sings no more!

Today, Trinidad and Tobago, and indeed the Caribbean, bids farewell to a true cultural giant. With the passing of Dr Read more

Dr Harris: There is evidence-based policymaking, and then there is T&T—are we betting against ourselves?

There is an old adage that says: “a wise man learns from the mistakes of others, while a fool learns Read more

Dear Editor: How long will T&T allow TTPS to insult our intelligence over non-use of bodycams?

“[…] It is nothing short of amazing how this current political directorate can go from conceptualization of 30 ‘police post’ Read more

Dear Editor: Neglect under PNM, betrayal under UNC—workers still on 2010 and 2013 salaries

Thirteen years have passed since health care workers, Lake Asphalt employees and other workers last received a salary adjustment. In Read more

Devant Maharaj: ‘The last non-UNC ballot was counted; now the PM’s mask is off…’

“[…] To the ‘UNC family’ she offers the old tired hymn: lagoons, cane fields, salt and rice, ponds and springs—the Read more

Check Also

Look Loy: T&T football’s swirling down the drain pipe—no matter what apologists and enablers say

“[…] Never mind the ‘media specialists’, apologists and enablers (paid and unpaid by TTFA) who …

One comment

  1. Many governments that have been office for along time fall into that trap. And I would hope that is what all governments who have lost an election would do – a postmortem, self analysis and self reflection. Then they must plot a path forward that focuses on the people and that would propel them back into office. That’s politics.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.