Daly Bread: The whole door gone—T&T failing on crime and still ignoring pan potential

For obvious reasons, this is an appropriate time to point out that the vision for the panyard model did not just reach; and also to remind readers of how long I have been advocating for the panyard model, which I met already established on the ground.

A little over 17 years ago, in a column published in February 2007 entitled Potential Peacemakers, I wrote what is quoted in the next four paragraphs concerning the panyard model.

Pannists from the Supernova Steel Orchestra.
Photo: Supernova

“[…] The panyard is akin to a home. Its hierarchical structure is akin to a family.  Elders in their seventies and eighties mix with four generations below them. All members of the family come together for a common beneficial purpose.

“The discipline of pan playing is so deep that it is almost unfathomable. It is not discipline bought with money reward because most pan players make little money. The only foundation of the discipline established in panyards can be love for music and pride in the tradition that is carried on through generations.

“Why has the tradition survived in a disposable oriented culture? How come the young men in pan are panmen and not gunmen? What is it in pan that diverts attention from the fatal lure of the gun?

The Harvard Harps take flight.
Photo: Akeem Charles

“We may not be able fully to answer these questions. What is urgent now is the design and implementation of a proposal, perhaps the Lloyd Best version, to take the panyard model into the schools to draw many more young people into music.

“It is imperative at the same time to take into the pan yard model the harmonium and tabla so that each primary school orchestra is a blend of pan and Patasar.

“I am thinking of year-round music festivals, with and without competition, rank gained from music, with the payment of a stipend to each child who meets the attendance and proficiency requirements of the orchestra.

“I am thinking that the children will learn to read music, to play calypso, bollywood, popular and light classical music on pan and other instruments to which they will be drawn.”

The North Coast Pan Serenaders perform on 2023 World Steelpan Day.

I add that I wrote specifically about the Birdsong model (2012) and the St Margaret’s panyard teaching model (2015) and I emphasized “the peace dividend of music instead of guns”, stating the case that “pan is an instrument of peace, a productive labour intensive, potentially sustainable occupation involving youngsters on the margin”.

From my observation of the panyard model, it requires of participants long hours of dedication, discipline and accomplishment. It easily meets three of the requirements set out in an editorial in the Trinidad Express newspaper last Wednesday, namely “status, purpose, brotherhood”.

The status gained by accomplishment as a pan musician includes a critical lift in self-esteem.

Fonclaire Steel Orchestra pannists perform in San Fernando during steelpan month in August 2023.
Photo: Pan Trinbago

Money earning opportunities will greatly increase if, as advocated, a cultural tourism and promotion policy was designed and implemented—particularly to take advantage of the rapturous reception that I have seen pan concerts receive abroad.

Unfortunately, a photo-op is not a policy. The lack of implementation of credible policies to advance the panyard model has cost us dearly in some panyard communities. Moreover, violent crime now threatens the viability of visits to the yards.

As a result of last weekend’s 14 murder spree, the Trinidad All Stars family were grieving for two of their own.

Massy Trinidad All Stars at the 2017 Panorama competition.

I was in that yard a month ago to celebrate the achievements of the students of the All Stars Academy at the presentation of certificates and to take in, as the announcement indicated, “the display of their hard work and commitment to their musical development”.

On that occasion I was delighted to see Bukka Rennie, whose excellent book on the birth of the steelpan and the history of All Stars I will be soon reviewing.

Against the current background, I share the sarcastic observation of a friend of mine. He was appalled by the latest utterances of Police Commissioner Erla Christopher, after the 14 weekend murders.

Commissioner of Police Erla Harewood-Christopher (far left) talks with coast guard officials during a joint patrol.
Photo: TTPS

The Commissioner’s utterances included that the police “have not lost a handle on crime”.

My friend’s observation was: “How she could say they have not lost a handle on crime. The whole door gone. The handle gone with the door.”

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: States of emergency rationales

Our small country is currently living under a state of emergency.  If, as authorised by the House of Representatives on Read more

Daly Bread: Beware inferences of zealots—clear difference in exits of CJs Archie and Sharma

Last Sunday, I asked the question how effective has the expiring State of Emergency been and what next? At the Read more

Daly Bread: On Boodoosigh’s quizzical appointment, and Tancoo’s soothing but ambitious Budget

Mr Justice Ronnie Boodoosingh is worthy of holding the office of Chief Justice to which he was appointed on Wednesday Read more

Daly Bread: Gopaul v Seepaul—T&T needs effective consequence management

Recently, the Attorney General, Senator John Jeremie SC, announced that the State had decided to discontinue an appeal against a Read more

Daly Bread: Two Miles of ‘Roy’ Regis and DJ Pelau

Co-incidentally with the event described below, drawing talent from the diaspora has been in the news. The Government has passed Read more

Daly Bread: Ambiguity, sovereignty and policy palsy—pondering US’ naval play and NGC’s withdrawal

Last week, in light of the current United States naval presence in Caribbean waters, I posed a question about sovereignty, Read more

Check Also

Daly Bread: States of emergency rationales

Our small country is currently living under a state of emergency.  If, as authorised by …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.