Discussion: Was the TTFA right to overrule technical committee and select Lawrence?


The technical committee of the Trinidad and Tobago Football Association (TTFA) declared, via an internal vote, that W Connection technical director Stuart Charles-Fevrier was the best candidate to lead the Soca Warriors for the remainder of the Russia 2018 World Cup qualifying campaign and beyond.

Former Central FC and San Juan Jabloteh coach Terry Fenwick was considered the second best candidate.

Photo: Former Everton assistant manager and new Trinidad and Tobago National Senior Team head coach Dennis Lawrence. (Copyright Everton FC)
Photo: Former Everton assistant manager and new Trinidad and Tobago National Senior Team head coach Dennis Lawrence.
(Copyright Everton FC)

However, the TTFA’s board of directors opted instead for former Everton assistant manager and World Cup 2006 defender Dennis Lawrence, who was, arguably, the technical committee’s third choice.

The board was allegedly concerned about Fevrier’s closeness to TTFA president and W Connection co-owner David John-Williams as well as whether the outspoken Fenwick, a former England World Cup defender, would be a suitable employee for the local football body.

The current TTFA board of directors comprises: David John-Williams (president), Joanne Salazar, Ewing Davis and Allan Warner (vice-presidents), Samuel Saunders (Central FA), Sherwyn Dyer (Eastern Counties Football Union), Karanjabari Williams (Northern FA), Richard Quan Chan (Southern FA), Anthony Moore (Tobago FA), Joseph Taylor (Trinidad and Tobago Football Referees Association), Sharon O’Brien (Women’s League Football), Wayne Cunningham (Eastern FA) and Dexter Skeene (TT Pro League).

The TTFA technical committee consists of: Dexter Skeene (chairman), Dr Alvin Henderson (vice-chairman), Bertille St Clair (former World Youth Cup coach), Errol Lovell (former national goalkeeper), Jinelle James (ex-national player and current administrator) and Muhammad Isa (technical director).

Photo: Former Trinidad and Tobago national coach Ron La Forest (left) makes a point to Pro League CEO Dexter Skeene. (Courtesy Allan V. Crane/Wired868.com)
Photo: Former Trinidad and Tobago national coach Ron La Forest (left) makes a point to Pro League CEO Dexter Skeene.
(Courtesy Allan V. Crane/Wired868.com)

So should the TTFA board be commended for its initiative and bravado in voting against John-Williams’ vice-presidents and the technical committee in selecting Lawrence? Or did the directors overstep their mark by ignoring the advice of a committee specifically set up to rule on such matters?

Should the technical committee be satisfied that their advice was considered, even though it was ultimately disregarded? Or should the members of that committee feel slighted and ponder their own futures due to the board’s final decision?

Does Lawrence’s top flight experience as an assistant coach make him the safest pair of hands? Or does the fact that he has been selected over experienced head coaches suggest that overseas achievements always trumps local achievements—regardless of scale?

Give us your views below:

More from Wired868
Sealy gets debut double, as T&T trounce St Kitts and Nevis 6-2 before sell-out crowd

A double from debutante Dante Sealy, a goal on return from Levi Garcia and another from veteran Kevin Molino, and Read more

Dear Editor: Caribbean FAs, like TTFA, can never get sustained success from Fifa grants

“[…] Dependency on global and regional football authorities, and government funds disempowers football leaders in these associations. Leaders often find Read more

Dear Editor: T&T owes it to our talented youth to rebuild our football programme

“[…] As coach Dwight Yorke noted following the Unity Cup, many of our local-based players are not yet ready for Read more

Dear Editor: Mulraine is right; TTFA must invest in talent identification

“[…] Instead of relying on one-off screening sessions, the TTFA should establish a structured scouting network that monitors players across Read more

Mulraine: Screening sessions to select national youth teams is lazy, inefficient and outdated

“[…] Anyone who has gone through this process knows the folly of trying to select the ‘best’ 20 players out Read more

Dear Editor: TTFA miscommunication denied East U-15 boys of national shot

“[…] Two days ago, it came to my attention, via the TTFA Facebook page, that screening for U15 boys were Read more

Check Also

Sealy gets debut double, as T&T trounce St Kitts and Nevis 6-2 before sell-out crowd

A double from debutante Dante Sealy, a goal on return from Levi Garcia and another …

195 comments

  1. Just to add insight to Sean Powders comments. When Graham Rix was coach at Chelsea and Gullit was manager, he basically picked the team. He coached the players everyday and advised Gullit on fitness, performance attitude etc. Usually in EPl etc the manager is exactly that. He manages all aspects of the club and doesn’t necessarily spend as much time with players as the coaches. This is where Tallest would have developed his coaching skills. However, a great co pilot doesn’t necessarily make a great pilot. A manager has ultimate responsibility and usually makes the final decisions. This could be where Tallest may lack experience. Finally, as we found with Rix, who was a fantastic, knowledgeable coach, Trini players are different to EPL players. Rix tried to do things at Central that worked with Zola, Lampard, Terry, di Matteo, Makele etc. Just didn’t work with Trini players, yet Fenwick got results with that same group. This is why the technical committee is supposed to give their recommendations based on wide criteria not just badges. The board, who are not required to have the same depth of football knowledge, are supposed to rely heavily on the TC. That’s the whole point.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.