T2021 W/C: A reflection on selection, concussion and Romario’s extraordinary exhibition

For a selector, concussion is an occupational hazard. All the more, as Ken ‘Jaiks’ Jaikaransingh has already noted above, if you are a West Indian selector.

Let me remind you of a truth every Trini sports fan knows: in T&T for certain, probably in the West Indies as a whole, we does win, dem does lose.

When you get the call to be a selector, you take the job, you do your level best and then, the first time the team loses—sometimes even before that—you get your concussion. (That’s really a sanitised portmanteau word, forged out of the union of a common noun and a past participle).

I bring it up here in the context of the spate of verbal abuse directed at Roger Harper’s selection panel over the perceived errors, both of commission and of omission, made by them last week. The good gentlemen—after consultation with the captain, provided for in the CWI selection policy, and consultation with the squad, not in the policy but as revealed by Harper in the media conference—included the Jekyll-and-Hyde pacer Oshane Thomas in the 15 and left out Romario Shepherd.

“They even try with Uton Dowe,” Relator sings in ‘Gavaskar’, “but ah sure that they sorry they bring him now.”

After Sunday’s exhibition, (an ESPN headline called it a ‘stunning all-round show’), ah sure that they sorry they leave him out!

Shepherd’s knock did go on as long as Andre Russell’s unforgettable 40-ball century against TKR at the Queen’s Park Oval in 2018. But for sheer ferocity, it was easily its equal.

And yet, I could not disagree more with the two gentlemen who recently contended on this blog that the selectors did Shepherd an injustice by overlooking him.

According to them, ‘the recall of the 36-year-old fast bowler (…) in preference to the much younger 26-year-old Shepherd (…) is another choice that can be questioned’.

Perhaps. And easily explained. Form plus experience beats form plus inexperience any day.

Rampaul’s (…) 17 wickets for the Trinbago Knight Riders in the ongoing CPL, they argue further, are not that much better than Shepherd, who has 14 to date. And Shepherd ‘is also by miles much more capable than Rampaul as a lower-order batsman and a far more agile fielder’.

Two quick points: closer examination of the wickets shows that the 36-year-old has repeatedly dismissed batsmen in the Powerplay. It may not in fact indicate superior quality but it certainly suggests it.

And given the ‘composition and balance of the squad’—Roger that!—it’s not so much a capable lower-order batsman that we are likely to need; it’s a dependable one to hold up an end.

What are the comparative ratings on that score?

My final point on this issue is this: one swallow does not a summer make. But in the history of West Indies cricket, truly perceptive selectors have more than once taken one swallow and lit up many of our summers thereafter.

With his irresistible power-hitting, Shepherd has made a strong case.

So, were I a selector, after Sunday’s performance, Shepherd would be included in my reserves, whether or not former Test captain Jason Holder adds injury to the selector’s insult and decides not to make the trip.

The rules allow us to take as many reserves as we wish, I think, so long as we are prepared to pay their way. Taking an enormously promising 26-year-old to the 2021 World Cup when the next edition is in 2022 makes a lot of cricketing—and financial!—sense to me.

Let me reiterate here that the bulk of the final 15 chosen have earned their place. And I agree with New Zealand’s Simon Doull who, with admirable diplomacy, commented that ‘there are one or two puzzling choices in there’.

I have long harboured doubts about Harper’s competence (‘I need to see Pooran play red ball cricket before he makes the Test team’?). But, in my view, the inclusion of Ravi Rampaul and Roston Chase says unequivocally that, if not the lead selector, at least the panel knows the difference between form, temporary, and class, permanent.

The panel’s views and mine diverge widely on four points. But I leave severely alone the completely indefensible decision to include a 42-year-old opener who is demonstrably but a shadow of his former self. (In both his innings since his selection, he again failed to make a favourable impression, getting 35 off 18 and 5 off 4 on the weekend.)

I leave equally untouched the related follow-the-science issue of the measurement of fitness—the immobile Rahkeem Cornwall is fit but Shimron Hetmyer who hurtles around the boundary and repeatedly puts his body on the line is not?

I shall, therefore, keeping the focus narrowly on the World Cup squad, deal only with the omission of Holder (J), the choice of Oshane Thomas and Andre Fletcher and, finally, the inclusion in the reserves of Darren Bravo. who, like me, is a Trinidadian.

Fletcher’s record in CPL 2021 only reinforces the abiding impression that he is simply not up to the required standard. In the second game against TKR, he made 81 not out off 55 balls; that apart, six of his eleven scores have been in single figures.

He also looks very vulnerable (read: like a complete dunce) against spin. And he has continued to drop easy catches, even with the gloves on.

Thomas too has nothing to write home about in the CPL unless bad news comes under that heading. He is not particularly gifted with the bat and, in seven matches, he has captured six wickets at an average of 23.

I can find no listing for how fast he has bowled, which is reportedly what has impressed the selection panel. You have to be crazy or incompetent or something to name such a player among your best 15. We have already established that the panel is competent and I see no compelling evidence—Holder’s omission?—that their sanity is in question.

Maybe Prime Minister of Barbados Mia Mottley does. She has thrown her not insubstantial weight behind the Barbados Royals captain, who is among the four reserves.

Commenting on the issue in a written public statement, she affirmed that the selection panel’s decision ‘defies all understanding’.

Some time ago, when Gayle was still making runs, Sir Clive Lloyd, the region’s most successful captain ever, suggested to us that Holder was God’s cricketing gift to the region. The talented Barbadian eventually became the ICC’s top-ranked all-rounder. Not just for a week or for a month but for an extended period.

Harper and his panel have just told us that Holder is not among the top 15 players in the region in T20 cricket.

I have been roundly critical of Jason Holder. But, like PM Mottley, I have a little difficulty swallowing that.

These gentlemen deserve every ounce of their concussion.

Especially when they tell us in the same breath that DM Bravo is.

More from Wired868

Kraigg steps down as Test captain; Hope replaces Powell as T20I skipper

West Indies opener Kraigg Brathwaite has stepped down as Test captain and is expected to play in the upcoming home Read more

CWI: Dr Rowley is a giant amongst men and a true champion of West Indies cricket

“[…] For all he has done—not just for cricket, but for the advancement of our Caribbean civilization—Dr Keith Rowley ought Read more

Early Bird: Do insular selectors pick and choose Test players they want for WI?

As many as 15 of the 74 players selected to play for West Indies in Tests since 2000 never got Read more

Sammy could be asset to WI Test ambitions, IF he can woo Windies’ white ball stars

I support Melbourne Cricket Club president Mark Neita’s view that the best white ball players should play Test cricket for Read more

Best: Miles off the mark? Does T&T need Bascombe’s talent spotter when we have QPCC?

When the Champions Trophy tournament begins in Pakistan today, West Indies will not be among the eight competing teams. But Read more

Dear Editor: Don’t blame WI players for franchise cricket clash; it’s ICC’s fault!

“[…] The issue with players from the West Indies and any non-Big 3 cricket nation (India, Australia and England) having Read more

Earl Best

Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970’s.
He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.