“The public consternation caused by the Government’s decision also calls our value system into question. As all Caribbean people can attest, anywhere you travel in the world, you are guaranteed lodging in the home of some friend or family. Hospitality is as Caribbean as sun, sea and sand.
“Furthermore, for a people for whom religion is part and parcel of our everyday existence, we seem to have a convenient faith.”
The following Letter to the Editor, which examines the Trinidad and Tobago Government’s recent decision to offer a six-month stay to Dominican citizens from the perspective of Community (CARICOM) law, was submitted to Wired868 by attorney-at-law Ria Mohammed-Davidson:
“Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free…”
This quotation comes from the sonnet “The New Colossus” penned in 1883 by Emma Lazarus and has been immortalized at the base of the Statute of Liberty. Undoubtedly, Lazarus’ appeal to a common humanity is an underlying theme of the decision of the Government of Trinidad and Tobago to offer a six-month stay to residents of Dominica in the wake of the devastation wrought by Hurricane Maria.
The visceral responses which this decision has provoked betray an unfortunate lack of awareness of the full panoply of rights contained in the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas, particularly the right to free movement under Article 45. This right was further concretised in the 2007 Heads of Government decision which granted to all CARICOM nationals an automatic, six-month stay upon arrival in any Member State.
The right of free movement was the central focus of the seminal decision of the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) in Shanique Myrie v Barbados where Ms Myrie, a Jamaican national, successfully sued Barbados after she was denied entry by immigration officials, subjected to a body cavity search and detained overnight in unsanitary conditions.
In Myrie, the CCJ not only granted judicial imprimatur to the right of automatic, hassle-free six-month entry but also detailed the narrow exceptions thereto, such as where a person will become a charge on public funds or a threat to public morals, public safety or public health. The Myrie principles on free movement were later affirmed by the CCJ in Maurice Tomlinson v Belize and Trinidad and Tobago.
It stands to reason that someone who has lost all his/her material possessions in a hurricane and seeks to enter Trinidad and Tobago will be hard-pressed to show that (s)he is not likely to become a charge on public funds. Presumably, therefore, all the Government has done is to adopt a relaxed approach to the application of that exception for Dominican residents now seeking to enter our country.
The exception does not appear to have been removed entirely as the Government’s offer was expressed as being open to Dominicans who have family, friends or acquaintances in Trinidad and Tobago. This qualification is seemingly geared at ensuring that someone will undertake to provide for them during their stay, thereby preventing them from becoming a burden on the State.
In the absence of any specific indication that the second exception expressed in Myrie has been removed or relaxed, one is left to assume that it remains intact.
The public consternation caused by the Government’s decision also calls our value system into question. As all Caribbean people can attest, anywhere you travel in the world, you are guaranteed lodging in the home of some friend or family. Hospitality is as Caribbean as sun, sea and sand.
Furthermore, for a people for whom religion is part and parcel of our everyday existence, we seem to have a convenient faith. Surely the Christian virtues of love and charity, the Hindu tenets of dharma, dana and karma and the Muslim principle of zakat call upon us to assist our Dominican neighbours in their time of need.
Religion aside, we also seem to have forgotten that, except for the First Peoples, we have all come to these shores because of some displacement, involuntary or otherwise. The naysayers to the Government’s plan would do well to remember that “Today it’s me, tomorrow it might be you.”
It seems that the winds of change ushered by the 2017 hurricane season can serve not only as a stark reminder of our peculiar vulnerability to climate change but also as a catalyst for a regional conversation about immigration. In this debate, it is beyond question that the right of hassle-free entry and an automatic six-month stay for all CARICOM nationals entering a Member State is a fundamental principle of Community law.
Come what may, we would do well to remember the rights we all enjoy as CARICOM nationals, hurricane or no hurricane, promise or no promise.
Warning: Undefined variable $userid in /www/wired868_759/public/wp-content/plugins/user-photo/user-photo.php on line 114
This not a political issue, please!!! Humanity is being replaced by selfishness and lack of real empathy. As a people known for their hospitality and warmth, we are allowing ‘externalities’ to dictate how we behave towards each other. Rethink! Refocus!
I am not able to measure but is there really significant oposition to welcoming Dominicans or is a tiny minority being very loud?
After all that was said if I was a Dominican I would go to another Island or stay in mine and die with my dignity
I duly see no wrong in it, as one can learn a alternative language as I am currently attempting and divulge in another culture whilst giving board to neighbour in need but what I do see is a nation taking a stance on the ills of our government who was very much AWOL when we needed them. IF YOUR VIEWS DIFFER MESSAGE ME AND WE COULD HAVE A DISCUSSION.
Buddy I hope you realize Dominica and the Dominican Republic are two different places. Dominicans speak English just like us.
How can politics stop us from helping people in need though? Giving a hand to a hurricane ravaged island isn’t like voting for PNM. It is just showing you have a heart.
Chica I didn’t know that, thanks
Chica Emery they always calling people dotish but don’t the difference between the two countries just sad
Jillian aint you funny, but if y’all read i have no problems against a influx of foreigners
What is 6months???Who can possibly spend 6 months here and be well enough to go back with everything they need to carry them through???? do they have any body building up they house for them???if so why de ass they can’t stay and help to build up they own house?????
Please don’t make this political, please help if you can. If you don’t want to help then shut up and sit down.
My heart is heavy, I’m very sad reading some of the comments from Trinidadians concerning we Trinis (government included) helping Dominicans. How can someone disapprove of us doing what we can to help our brothers and sisters in Dominica? How can you turn this into political bickering? How can you compare what happened in Dominica to a few homes being flooded out here in Trinidad. My GOD, do we trinis have a heart? We may one day want help ourselves. I’m so disappointed I can’t put it into words.
Chica you must feel like that after all you are an outsider too….???
Serious thing tho.
You know I just harassing you….but under all seriousness our island cannot sustain more immigrants. With immigrants comes alot of social problems and we in T&T who cannot manage a slight drizzle of rain certainly can’t implement or impose immigration laws and policy. What I am disappointed in is the fact that alot of people who voicing and posting about bring in the Dominicans are not even willing to open up their house not pot. That said and done what I wanna say is if 75% of our public make some sort of contribution, it could be financial or supplies towards all the islands affected my those hurricanes it would go along way. I am waiting patiently for somebody to ask what I contributed…I don’t always post pics of my charitable donations but I have some pro-political friends from both the UNC and PNM who would ask the question.
I disagree Ravi, we can take in a few Dominicans and still send supplies to the people who remain in Dominica plus we can send more of our army troops to help. Even if we as a nation is struggling we should still help and help some more. Just my opinion.
Do you really think those Dominicans want to leave their island? I am sure they would prefer to get the resources to rebuild their lives rather than to come here.
please please –from d bottom of my heart to yours please tell me –what did u do when the entire south trinidad was flooded and these people could not come out of their houses to buy water –what did u do –please dont lie
I did nothing, I too was flooded out. I lost a lot of stuff too, it took me some time with some help to clean up my apartment. That’s the truth.
Now it’s your move. Tell me
Even tho I lost stuff and don’t have much to give I will still give. Yuh understand me
If you yourself can’t afford to give then ok no problem but don’t discourage others from giving.
I think we need more people to come forward and donate supplies but the question about relaxing our immigration laws for me is a big NO.
Ravi news flash…T & T dont need to relax our immigration laws…We have lots of Dominicans living and doing jobs Trinis refuse to do!….listen for the accent at Hardwares..Groceries and Stores even food outlets…Dominica is only 75,000 in population…