Noble: The problem with Dr Paul Richards’ grilling of Police Commissioner

“The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting.” Milan Kundera, a Czech and French novelist, in The Book of Laughter and Forgetting (1979).

The book discusses how people tolerate the torture and suffering over which they have no control. These lessons apply to us as we navigate our surreal world.

Calm down, fellah…

We live in a world where bizarre, almost unbelievable, events mark our existence. Going back into history to regain control and perspective is always helpful.

On 1 February 2024, a viral clip from a Parliamentary committee on National Security caught the nation’s attention.

The questioning by Independent Senator Dr Paul Richards appeared to put the Police Commissioner in a poor light. Viewing the entire proceedings rather than depending on the short clip is necessary.

Most of our population now gets their news through social media outlets. Some journalists and trolls—“content creators”—operate a propaganda machine to bully and harass their objects. Unfortunately, anger, fear, and outrage (genuine or manufactured) are the currency of social media platforms.

(From left to right) Senior Superintendent Rishi Singh, acting Deputy Commissioner of Police Ramnarine Samaroo, Commissioner of Police Erla Christopher, and Senior Superintendent Curt Simon face questions from a JSC on National Security in Parliament on 31 January 2024.
Photo: Office of the Parliament 2024

Viewing the entire proceedings brought to mind a warning from former Senator Verna St Rose-Greaves. She was the first to ring a bell about what Jack Warner later called a “Cabal”.

In a 2012 Guardian interview with Dr Sheila Rampersad, she warned: “I listen to what is being said—and don’t be fooled: these are no off-the-cuff statements. They want the place to mash up. I’m seeing people pushing for fire.

“They want this place to explode, and I hope the country (is) smarter than that because there will be no winners… if a crisis should arise, it would provide them with the opportunity, and this is why I am pushing for her to stand up.

Opposition Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar was Trinidad and Tobago’s first female prime minister.
(Copyright Office of the Parliament 2023)

“Female leadership is not easy. I think the time has come for us to say and do something about it. This is not about a person alone; it is about a country. We cannot continue like this. It’s as if power is an aphrodisiac to many of these men.”

On 16 April 2023, Newsday reported that Dr Roodal Moonilal would consult with other members of the Joint Select Committee (JSC) on National Security to call for a meeting with Police Commissioner Erla Harewood-Christopher to inquire about police officers switching off body cameras.

(The JSC has eight members: 5 PNM, 2 UNC, and 1 Independent).

UNC MP Roodal Moonilal speaks at a JSC meeting for National Security on 31 January 2024.
Photo: Office of the Parliament 2024

This is not the first time that MP Moonilal questioned the use of body cameras by the Police Service.

“Where we are right now, where people are being killed in circumstances where there are legitimate questions about the conduct of police officers, a bodycam will not only tell you the police was wrong, a bodycam will also tell you the police was right.”

Body cameras have a long torturous history, stretching from July 2020 when Mr Gary Griffith claimed to have purchased 1,000 cameras initially. Another 1,500 were ordered in March 2021.

An officer of the Phoenix Police Department sports a body camera.

These body-cams were to be issued to front-line officers, including all officers in the since-disbanded Special Operations Response Team (SORT), the Inter-Agency Task Force (IATF), Guard and Emergency Branch (GEB), and task forces.

In July 2020, then-Commissioner Griffith asserted: “The reason I want to push for body cameras more than anyone is for when my police officers are wrongfully accused by the lady in the towel who makes the accusation because we do know they have bionic eyes that see through walls and around corners.”

Yet, only 180 were ever reported to be operational.

Then Commissioner of Police Gary Griffith directs traffic on a Sunday morning after the Wet Fete “Jamnation” at O2 Park, Chaguaramas on 24 February 2019.
(Copyright Allan V Crane/ CA-images/ Wired868)

None were in use when the Andrea Bharatt suspects died in custody in July 2021. The Police Complaints Authority found that while in custody the suspects, Joel Balcon and Andrew Morris, were “the subject of torture”, with two of the individuals being the subjects of acts of violence that led to their deaths.

ASP Mark Hernandez, who headed SORT then, was charged with misbehaviour in public office.

In June 2020, Griffith claimed: “Over 100 police vehicles are equipped with cameras that give real-time video footage sped back to the Operational Command Centre.”

Then TTPS Gold Commander Erla Christopher (right) gestures to the monitor at the Command Centre in Tobago, as law enforcement officers prepared for the 2021 THA election.
Photo: TTPS

By July 2022, Griffith rubbished a statement by Commissioner McDonald Jacob that the system lacked technological infrastructure:

“This is not a system where you have to have video feedback to a command centre. No other police service in the world has that. Such a project would essentially be a waste of taxpayers’ money.”

OMG! Are we living in the real world? Does the esteemed Committee member think the present Commissioner is the problem?

Then Commissioner of Police Gary Griffith (left) poses with former New York City mayor Rudy Giuliani.
Giuliani, according to a biography of Tesla founder Elon Musk, had the rare “distinction” of being too sleazy for even the controversial businessman.

Then, there was the vexed problem of promotions. A JSC member was part of a legal team that contested a related matter and was actively pursuing other cases against the Commissioner. She did not recuse herself.

What are the rules that govern such conduct in our Parliament? The Chair aborted the questioning, citing that the matter was sub judice.

Did the JSC members consider why as many as 900 constables were due for promotion?

UNC Senator and attorney Jayanti Lutchmedial continues to serve on the JSC for National security, despite being involved in several lawsuits against the TTPS.
Photo: Office of the Parliament 2024

The answer is in another lawsuit. In December 2023, 109 police officers sued the Promotions Advisory Board, which is supposed to sit every three months. Some officers have been on the list since 2009!

Why did the JSC not want to understand why this process only began in March 2023?

The problem with wrong scores was at the heart of the 2021 Court proceedings involving the JSC member. Unfortunately, the same difficulty—how the scores can be bungled—was again a subject in the present debacle.

Commissioner of Police Erla Christopher competes the formality of promotion for a fellow officer on 23 December 2022.
(Copyright TTPS)

It was instructive to watch the handling of the responsible officer and compare it to that meted out to the Commissioner. The esteemed JSC questioner appeared ignorant of that history.

He, not MP Moonilal, was the one taking the strike combatively. His ramjaying has prompted some to question whether it was misogynistic. The bar has been raised for this woman, like Professor Claudine Gay, and has baked any imperfection into a fundamental flaw.

Commissioner Harewood-Christopher has said the only way to stop the surging murders and crime was to hit gang leaders in their pockets by dismantling their financial empires.

Image: Marvel Comic’s Crime Kingpin.

This conclusion is not different from that of her predecessor, Mr Griffith. Yet, the propaganda machine focuses on her statement about prayer and slams her urging to acknowledge the supernatural angle.

By September 2023, she noted a zero percent increase in the murder rate compared to a 10 percent increase for the same period the previous year. A JSC member brazenly scolded her for noting that success.

In January 2024, some further progress was made. Consider this nuanced exchange about crime targets and the headline employed.

Commissioner of Police Erla Harewood-Christopher.
Photo: TTPS

The Police Service is targeting gangs, but will the Commissioner be encouraged or remain a target? The propaganda machine has turned the bureaucratic finer points into a political bomb.

This is not to excuse Commissioner Harewood–Christopher’s lack of preparation for the meeting. She must know that such hearings are designed to create sound bites for the news reports.

The questioners are not coming to the meeting to seek solutions but to set prosecutorial traps. Look at the verbatim report of the exchange between the Senator and the Commissioner over the television show:

Independent Senator Dr Paul Richards is vice-chair of the JSC on National Security.
Photo: Office of the Parliament 2024

Richards: Is there a particular mandate for the Beyond the Tape show? And I ask the question in the context that, very often, I hear utterances in that show that are in stark contradiction to what the police leadership is saying and it is very surprising to me.

So the police leadership says one thing about gangs, the show is saying ‘we giving the gangs a bligh’.

Is there a mandate for that show? And does the show take instruction and policy and public dissemination from the police leadership because every often I have heard contradictory information from the police leadership and from what I see on that show and I don’t know which one to believe.

Snr Supt Roger Alexander on Beyond The Tape.

Christopher: The show should be a replica of the thoughts and sentiments of the executive of the organisation.

Richards: Is that happening?

Christopher: There may be times when the presenter is a bit adverse to the thoughts of the organisation.

Richards: The presenter representing the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service on a national broadcast, very popular show, in uniform and you are telling us that he is adverse to what the leadership is saying? That is a shocking revelation.

Commissioner of Police Erla Harewood-Christopher (left) and Senior Superintendent Curt Simon appear before a JSC on National Security on 31 January 2024.
Photo: Office of the Parliament 2024

The Commissioner needed to project empathy and not get stuck trying to be lawyerly in her responses. Preparation for such hearings usually should include ‘mock’ interviews and a review of footage of previous successful or disastrous hearings. Seemingly, no such preparation took place.

The nature of our policing trouble remains unresolved. There is no argument about that.

But we have “useful idiots”—naive persons who can be manipulated to advance a cause or political agenda—at work in Parliament. Woe is we!

More from Wired868
Noble: Messy Massy and Mr Warner

During the massive rebranding exercise, Tony Deyal wryly commented: “Neal and Massy announced it was Massy and proved to be Read more

Dear Editor: Senator Richards must prove allegations against Alexander, or apologise!

“[…] Dr Paul Richards is not only an independent senator, but also a very experienced journalist. He ought to know Read more

Noble: The Gangster and the Gentleman—an East Port of Spain bandit tale

MENDOZA: I am a brigand. I live by robbing the rich. TANNER: (promptly) I am a gentleman. I live by Read more

Noble: When money became a problem—how T&T wasted three “oil booms”

In September 1973, we, as a nation, were blessed with a bonanza from new offshore discoveries and a sharp rise Read more

Noble: How educational inequity is incompatible with a just society

“[…] This feeling of always being uneducated influenced me when I became prime minister. There were always about 6,000 children Read more

Daly Bread: Criminals ducking the lack of political will

A New Year traditionally renews feelings of hope. Realism may dash hope so commentators feel pressured not to write gloomily Read more

About Noble Philip

Noble Philip, a retired business executive, is trying to interpret Jesus’ relationships with the poor and rich among us. A Seeker, not a Saint.

Check Also

Noble: Killing our young—T&T youth’s mental health challenges are everyone’s problem!

This week, we witnessed the funeral of Ezekiel Paria, who was shot while riding a …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.