Vaneisa: Intelligent cricketers good; re-educated Caribbean societies better

EPL Infrafred Sauna

Two aspects of the situation in West Indies cricket have to be addressed in tandem with each other. The first is for the future: rebuilding capacity all round, and the second is figuring out how to get current performances back to a respectable level.

The former is the gargantuan task of creating a new culture that enables the kind of steady, sustainable development that will provide a cadre of young people with the skills that are obviously lacking, to help them manage in the later stages of their lives.

West Indies players walk off the field after their seven wicket loss to Scotland in a crucial World Cup Qualifier in Harare on 1 July 2023.
(Copyright ICC/ Getty)

The chair of the Caricom-instigated cricket sub-committee, Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley, took the opportunity while turning the sod for a TT$40.6m velodrome in Palo Seco—the southern part of Trinidad—to say his regional colleagues agree that at the community level, cricket had fallen away.

His intention, he said, was to encourage the return of club cricket by seeking approval for “not insignifi­cant grants” to support this initiative, because he feels that strong national teams would be the foundation for ­rebuilding.

The Prime Minister makes a good point, but it misses a bigger point—one that I feel does not get to the heart of the matter with regard to the failings.

If we were to look at the senior level, the players who are being selected are not without talent. They all have some ability of merit; what makes them perform like blooper kings on one day or stars on another is their mental weakness.

With few, if any, exceptions, they lack the capacity to think critically, to analyse, and worse, the stamina to hold a course. Simply put, they do not play intelligently.

West Indies head coach Daren Sammy (centre, foreground) speaks to his team during the Cricket World Cup Qualifying tournament in Harare, Zimbabwe.
(Copyright ICC/ Getty)

It is not a cricket failing—it is at the heart of the malaise that has seeped into the fabric of regional societies.

So, while the prime ministerial committee might have charged itself with changing cricket, as leaders of the region, they have to focus simultaneously on recalibrating Caribbean civilisation.

It seems to me that any genuine ­attempt to build a culture of intelligent cricket for the future has to step away from the cricket itself and go to the root of what has been dramatically reducing West Indian capacity.

Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley (right) poses with West Indies cricket legend Sir Viv Richards.
(via Dr Keith Rowley’s Facebook page)

I am not saying that we should ignore the value of clubs and academies and so on—those are the elements for the second part of the project. I am saying we need to get past the practice of blaming coaches and selectors and think hard about why their guidance has consistently been ignored.

I am urging us to acknowledge that our education systems throughout the region are causing more damage than good, especially to disadvantaged young people, who form the greater mass.

Until we acknowledge the institutional failings, until we try to understand the impact of those failures on thousands of lives, mostly males, we cannot hope to stem the tide of barbarity that is washing over us all.

Image: The lighter side of education.
(Copyright Mark Anderson)

I am no expert on educational methods, but I do not think you need to be one to see the damage that has been done, especially in the area of literacy.

It is not a problem confined to the Caribbean. Last November, The Economist carried an article titled “Why are boys doing badly at school?—Peer pressure, poor schooling and biology may all contribute”.

The article showed the trends, comparing the performances between boys and girls: “The gulf is widest in reading: in almost all countries that collect sufficient data girls are better readers than boys at ten years old.”

Wired868 Write Start winners Shara Balkaran (second from left) and Aastha Kumar (second from right) pose with Minister of Education Dr Nyan Gadsby-Dolly (centre), event patron Sean Powder (far right) and Wired868 managing director Lasana Liburd at the Queen’s Park Oval on 15 December 2021.
Photo: Karla Ramoo/ bmobile

It elicited a huge stream of comments that mostly demonstrated how complex the issue is, and how widespread it is globally.

As I have suggested previously, from early, reading and writing, art and music—the humanities—have been pegged as sissy subjects. Boys get to Fifth Standard in primary school barely knowing how to express themselves using the written word.

The SEA exams perpetuate that because they teach no love for learning and no critical thinking (which is often penalised)—only the dreadful inculcation of learning by rote. It is the antithesis of preparation for life.

West Indies opener Shai Hope takes evasive action.
(Copyright Daniel Prentice/ Wired868)

At secondary school, where ­pubescent hormones are kicking in and thoughts of sexuality begin to rage, there is a desire to assert oneself. Let’s say you’re in an environment where you want to preen, would you be willing to show your poor level of literacy?

As we have seen, at this vulnerable stage, boys are easily recruited as badass, macho fodder, by men who suffer the same weaknesses.

I have talked to many, many, young men, who were secretly ashamed that they could not read, and so scoffed at the idea of school and learning—rejecting the areas of their weakness and seeking to align themselves with communities that elevated brawn and bravado over brain.

San Juan North Secondary students savour the moment after their school’s 2016 National Intercol final win over Presentation College (San Fernando) at the Mannie Ramjohn Stadium in Marabella on 2 December 2016.
Photo: Sean Morrison/ Wired868

Most of them live lives of pure ketch-arse, even if they turn to crime.

Underneath the veneer is a perpetual feeling that they are not good enough, that they must keep the fact that they can barely read or write or spell as secrets, and they often resent the ones who can, targeting them for their misguided rage.

It’s not just about literacy; it’s about functional illiteracy as well. Social media has demonstrated that many people read without understanding, and can barely process ideas. This is the area where we are in the gravest danger.

To be continued.

More from Wired868
Vaneisa: Mia Mottley, West Indies cricket and the public good

Last Tuesday, Mia Mottley, prime minister of Barbados, delivered the 22nd annual Sir Frank Worrell Memorial lecture at the Cave Read more

Noble: T&T’s Education system still broken after 60 years—and all we hear is “Yada! Yada! Yada!”

In the long-running comedy series, Seinfeld, the phrase “yada, yada, yada” became popularised. Marcy, a character, used the expression to Read more

Vaneisa: “We curse off the WI cricketers for being us”—a case of us and them

We can divide the discussions into two. The internal, what’s happening inside the body of West Indies cricket, its circuitry; Read more

Noble: From Dr Williams’ education dream to nightmarish inequalities; what went wrong?

In August 1962, the first Common Entrance group entered secondary schools and heard Prime Minister Dr Eric Williams say: “... Read more

Demming: Pan should be part of education curriculum, to maximise its value

“Pan is in good hands,” they said—after experiencing the energy and exuberance of the Junior Panorama finals at the Queen’s Read more

Vaneisa: Caricom, cricket and culture—the conclusion of decades of decline

It was a pleasant surprise to find myself so eager to watch the First Test match between the West Indies Read more

About Vaneisa Baksh

Vaneisa Baksh is a columnist with the Trinidad Express, an editor and a cricket historian. She is the author of a biography of Sir Frank Worrell.

Check Also

Daly Bread: Education triple whammy

Two weeks ago, I described conditions in the education system as destructive. I identified what …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.