Home / View Point / Martin Daly / Daly Bread: In ‘wth’ country; Paria Fuel, the President and the Chief Justice

Daly Bread: In ‘wth’ country; Paria Fuel, the President and the Chief Justice

What the hell? Can one set out to sell a State asset by mistake?

‘Wth’ is a milder version of the social media acronym used to express surprise or disgust. It was my response to the Minister of Energy’s implausible media release on Monday last related to the failure of Petrotrin.

It is an equally appropriate response to the revelation of the respective concerns of two High Court judges about security arrangements for the Judiciary and the process for appointments soon to be made to the Court of Appeal and a lack of internal dialogue.

Photo: Petrotrin chairman Wilfred Espinet (left).
(Copyright Trinidad Newsday)

On Sunday last, the Chairman of the successor companies to Petrotrin stated an intention to sell Paria Fuel Trading Company Limited (Paria Fuel)—the entity supposed to obtain a supply of fuel to meet our country’s day to day needs following the shut down of the Petrotrin refinery.

The Chairman stated that there was no need for the Paria entity. There followed his extraordinary statement that: “Paria was not a determination to be a business. Paria was a reaction to the fact that you needed to have ongoing supplies. What we did was to form Paria quickly.”

Some troubling questions immediately arose: Was there no definitive plan to obtain fuel supplies to replace those previously provided by the Petrotrin refinery? Wth? Do you form a company for that vital purpose by reaction or vaps? What fuel supply security, if any, do we have?

While pondering upon these questions, the Minister issued his release the next day contradicting the Chairman’s statement—right hand slapping left hand.

The Minister’s statement asserts that the Parent Company of Paria Fuel, had been ‘directed to withdraw and retract any advertisement or Request for Proposals (RFP) that may have been inadvertently issued for the sale of Paria Fuel Trading Company Limited’.

The reference to an ‘inadvertent’ issue of RFP is pure kicksin’. It is in the light of that I ask: How the hell can one set out to sell a State asset by mistake?

Photo: PNM chairman and Minister of Energy and Energy Affairs Franklin Khan (right) and Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi.
(Copyright Power 102FM)

To add to the shambles, the Prime Minister at the post Cabinet media conference on Thursday reportedly said that the door on a sale of Paria remains open—apparently if such a proposal comes as part of a bid for the refinery which is for sale. Does anyone in the Government really know what they are trying to do?

Turning now to the continuing dark clouds over the Judiciary, the judges’ letters were followed closely by statements from the President of the Republic that she is troubled and grieved by divisions in the Judiciary.

The President’s statement suggests that the concern of the two judges may be genuine and substantial. Readers will also recall that I recently pointed out how judges of the Court of Appeal were putting distance between themselves and the Chief Justice.

Remarkably the President’s statement—said to be part of a television interview scheduled for broadcast later today—implies that institutional descent has been steep.

“One can only hope, however you go, you will eventually reach bottom,” said the President. “One can only hope that we don’t reach there; and after that, we can only hope that we rise.”

With respect, the President is not a mere bystander in matters concerning the Judiciary. As she acknowledges, she was part of it for twenty years. One wonders why she left before the mandatory retirement age. One may also legitimately inquire whether the matters about which she is troubled were manifest to her while she was there and contributed to her early departure.

Photo: President Paula-Mae Weekes (right) is applauded by Prime Minister Keith Rowley (centre) as Chief Justice Ivor Archie looks on.
(Courtesy Office of the President)

She is now uniquely placed to advise and warn against inappropriate appointments to the Judicial and Legal Service Commission or to the Bench when she is asked to make them.

The President is also uniquely placed to advise and warn the Prime Minister—in the course of their regular meetings keeping her informed of the state of the country—about the dangers of an unstable Judiciary and the urgent need for him to make a decision on the Law Association’s recommendation that he trigger section 137 proceedings in respect of the Chief Justice.

Can we expect her leadership to be far firmer than mere forlorn expressions of hope?

About Martin Daly

Martin Daly
Martin G Daly SC is a prominent attorney-at-law. He is a former Independent Senator and past president of the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago. He is chairman of the Pat Bishop Foundation and a steelpan music enthusiast.

Check Also

Daly Bread: Delusions, deceivers and duds; how ‘Marlene mess’ exposes long-standing state deficiencies

Events that rock us into further consternation about the state of our country and whether …

3 comments

  1. I have lost hope in the PM coming to his senses. To paraphrase Israel Khan, the PM appears to be similarly suffering from a case of “toxins”.

    Simultaneously, the ‘Pension for Life’ President is seemingly content to rest on her laurels – amplified by the good life, one might say.

    Just yesterday I was in a conversation with a friend, and I postulated that there has to be procurement legislation – proposed, drafted, debated and assented – before the President can get her liquid paper to change a ‘b’ to an ‘a’ in Justice Pemberton’s instrument of appointment to the JLSC.

  2. they know exactly what they intend to do, meanwhile confuse the population and in the midst of that things would be concluded, how many of you knew that so many planes were ordered

  3. The ‘chupidness’ does not end. The chairman advertises the sale of a state asset. The line minister say no but then the PM say yes it’s really for sale.
    The real story about this government’s intention is slowly unravelling.