From West Indies to Windies: Oh, how have the mighty fallen! Ten theories of decline

EPL Properties Ltd

“As far as I can tell there are not many other people working effectively to [restore the soul of West Indies cricket and point the way forward] as the political directorate is missing in action and the current board charged with responsibility for our cricket is a waste of time and unsuitable for that purpose.”

The following is the text of a speech delivered by Charles Wilkin on the occasion of the launch of the latest book by Professor Hilary Beckles towards the end of last year. The book carries the title “Cricket Without a Cause—Fall and Rise of the Mighty West Indian Test Cricketers” and Wilkin was, in the lead-up to 2007, the Chairman of Cricket World Cup St Kitts and Nevis Ltd.

Wired868 is of the view that, at a time when the Windies have, for the first time in our cricketing history, been forced to qualify—albeit successfully—for Cricket World Cup in England and Wales next year, it is appropriate to remind our readers of the road we have travelled since the West Indies lost the 1983 World Cup final to India after having captured the first two in England in 1975 and 1979.

Photo: The West Indies cricket team celebrates one of many successes under then captain Clive Lloyd.

I am honoured to have been invited to comment on the latest of many significant contributions to the region and its cricket of Professor Sir Hilary Beckles by way of his book being launched here tonight. Professor Beckles is eminently qualified to chronicle the current woeful state of West Indies cricket and its prior glories.

Firstly, he is a lover of the game and of West Indies cricket and a dedicated regionalist. Then, of course, he is a distinguished and world renowned writer and historian and understands as well as any the importance of cricket in the history and culture of the region.

KFC Munch Pack

It is significant also that he is an influential thought leader, who tells it like it is. And he has had varied perspectives in the middle of the fray for many years. His signal contribution to West Indies cricket was forging the links between West Indies cricket and The UWI in the founding of the Centre for Cricket Research at The UWI and the design and motivation of the Sagicor High Performance Cricket Academy, both in Barbados. His unrelenting efforts in that regard are well catalogued in chapter 12 of the book.

I share his distress at the dismantlement of the Academy. I commend him also for his commitment generally to excellence and productivity in our Caribbean societies, which talk but do not sufficiently practise those qualities. The book is written in the very passionate, direct, thought-provoking, hard-hitting and outspoken style that we have become accustomed to from the Professor.

Who can blame him for showing such intense feelings on so moving and controversial a subject?

Photo: UWI Vice-Chancellor Hilary Beckles.
(Copyright Caribbean News Service)

I am pleased to see the unequivocal assertion by Professor Beckles in the name of the book and throughout that Test cricket is the quintessence of the game; the rest, as I am sure he will agree, is noise and entertainment. Test cricket to me is Sparrow. The rest is what in St Kitts is called “wuk up” or “nursery rhyme” music.

The name of the book also reflects the underlying and undeniable premise that the rise of West Indies cricket was rooted in a cause which has disastrously been lost in what Professor Beckles describes as “the greatest sporting catastrophe in modern history.” He envisions, however, with commendable optimism the restoration of the soul of West Indies cricket and points the way forward. As far as I can tell there are not many other people working effectively to that end as the political directorate is missing in action and the current board charged with responsibility for our cricket is a waste of time and unsuitable for that purpose.

The book describes four risings of West Indies cricket, the first being the era of the Three Ws, Ramadhin and Valentine. The second is the era of Sobers, Gibbs, Wes Hall and Kanhai and the third that of Lloyd and Richards, Greenidge and Haynes and the fast bowlers too many to mention here. The Fourth Rising is yet to come. The Professor is confident it will.

I found that his very optimistic arguments make interesting reading and urge you to have a read even if you have given up on West Indies cricket or, like me, are close to doing so. This is a tale in much detail, supported with statistics, of two centuries with vastly differing results.

Photo: Legendary West Indies fast bowler Curtly Ambrose (left) discomfits an opposing batsman during a Test match.

In the 20th Century, after a period of initiation before the Second World War, the Test team quickly established itself as often the best and always the most attractive team in world cricket. Then came the glory days and absolute dominance of the 1980’s which lasted until 1995. The writer gives the Test results of the 1980’s—44 wins and only eight losses, making the team in his words “as dominant a team as has ever played any international sport.”

Just before the 21st Century began, the tide changed. Professor Beckles gives with lament the gory results. Following the recent losses to New Zealand (after the publication of the book) the position is 33 wins and 94 losses in Test matches since 2000. If you take out the wins and losses against Bangladesh and Zimbabwe, that makes only 18 wins and 92 losses.

Allow me the licence to quote three additional sets of updated figures. Our win:loss ratio over England remains in the positive column at 55 won and 48 lost. Even that proud record which saw us unbeaten by England from 1969 to 2000 (so glowingly and pleasurably described by Professor Beckles) will soon go. And the overall win:loss record updated last week is 168 won, 187 lost.

Also after this week’s update, we remain in eighth position on the ICC Test Team Table but now have the same ranking of 72 as does Bangladesh. Less than three years ago, our ranking was 76 and theirs 47. In other words, they are about to overtake us in Test match status, as they have already done in ODIs—unless, of course, the recipes for revival of West Indies cricket set out in the book kick in super-quickly.

Photo: West Indies’ Chadwick Walton (top) collides with Pakistan’s Ahmed Shehzad while attempting a run during a T20I match at the Queen’s Park Oval in Port-of-Spain, Trinidad on 30 March, 2017.
(Copyright AFP 2017/ Jewel Samad)

I was asked to highlight one chapter of my choice. I have selected chapter 1 because it is the chapter likely to stir up the most arguments. Let me interject here, however, that my favourite chapter is chapter 2, which is brilliantly written even if it makes sad reading. The reminder of the quotes from Sir Garry Sobers is moving. Let me say happily that Sir Garry is—and always will be—my idol as the greatest sportsman ever.

Now for my comments on Chapter 1 headed “Ten Theories of Decline.” These theories have been commonly expounded and argued ad infinitum in every nook and cranny of our islands. They are well assimilated and described in the chapter. Professor Beckles begins with an expression of confidence that, with reform, the West Indies can arrest the decline. He attributes this confidence to the collective capacity of Caribbean people to adapt to changed circumstances. I too recognise that collective capacity but I have no confidence in the politicians or in CWI to leverage it. I think that the blame the Professor puts on economic conditions and globalisation is exaggerated.

In the early days of the free fall, the West Indies bid for the ICC Cricket World Cup 2007 and Governments spent hundreds of millions of dollars on cricket infrastructure. While I admit that more than infrastructure is needed to develop the game, globalisation and a favourite target of Professor Beckles, the IMF, did not prevent Governments from finding the money. Forgive me if I get a little insular and say that St Kitts became an international cricket venue in 2006 because of the World Cup and that has proven to be a very wise investment.

West Indies Captain Brian Lara (centre) walks off the field after being run out against England during the Super-Eight ICC World Cup cricket match at the Kensington Oval in Bridgetown, Barbados on 21 April, 2007.
Lara scored 18 runs in his final international cricket match.
(Copyright AFP 2017/Adrian Dennis)

I had the honour of leading the St Kitts LOC from bid to tournament. We surprised quite a few people in the region with the strength of our bid and with our performance otherwise. Forgive me also if, in the same vein, I remind you that, for 45 years after West Indies played its first Test match, there was discrimination against the Leeward and Windward Islands. When the discrimination ended, players from the Leewards were at the forefront of the invincible teams.

Editor’s note: Part Two will be carried on Sunday 25 March.

More from Wired868
“Greatest honour of my career”, “Dream come true”—Hope and Powell named WI white-ball captains

Wicketkeeper/batter Shai Hope and batting allrounder Rovman Powell will lead the West Indies cricket team in the One-Day International (ODI) Read more

Lara takes “performance mentor” job to “improve game sense” of Windies players

West Indies cricket legend Brian Lara was unveiled today as the Cricket West Indies’ (CWI) new performance mentor with a Read more

Test cricket for white-ball players, fitness consensus, center wicket practice: the CWI’s 34-point Report on T20 W/Cup exit

“[…] It is not in the best interests of West Indies Cricket that our best players play in every global Read more

Dear Editor: Captaining or coaching WI is an impossible job, because the real “bunglers” stay hidden

“[…] No matter how poorly the [West Indies] teams play, there are no consequences for the regional boards because they Read more

Vaneisa: Sir Wes Hall, why we should care about the grand old man

Biographies, autobiographies and memoirs about Caribbean people unwittingly carry the burden of history. So much has gone unrecorded, and academic Read more

CWI gives Academy coach, Coley, interim WI post for Zimbabwe, S/Africa tours

The Cricket West Indies (CWI) today appointed CWI Academy head coach Andre Coley as interim head coach of the West Read more

About Editor

Check Also

Dear Editor: Time to reset soul of Caribbean civilisation; gov’ts must confront our colonial legacy

“[…] Despite the refusal of European governments to engage the issue, the moral landscape across …


  1. Warning: Undefined variable $userid in /www/wired868_759/public/wp-content/plugins/user-photo/user-photo.php on line 114
  2. As many theories abound concernimg our turn from calypso to collapso, I think the one with the most credence is this one: many efforts were made to try to blunt our deadly pace attack and one finally succeeded. What effort was that, you might ask? It is one involving the ticking hands of the clock…
    Because of the long run-up needed to deliver pace like fire, it meant a WI pace bowler could take as much as five minutes to bowl a single over. When it was realised that, when fielding, WI rarely got through 90 overs for a day’s play, the punishments for slow over rates started becoming more severe for the bowling side. Having to focus more on not incurring hefty team and captain fees than on crease to crease missiles, the previously invincible bowling attack weakened. And the team itself weakened. By the time most of the true pacers disappeared by 1992-1993, the WI became beatable again and two years later we saw that come to pass.

    And we’ve never adapted since!

  3. Scotty Ranking

    There is a talk in some quarters that the 1983 loss was a necessary evil done for the ICC’s benefit as a major sponsor had threatened to pull out of future arrangements if this team (from an area of the world in which that sponsor had no market share) won this cup for a third time running. Can anyone elaborate on this conspiracy theory?

  4. Everybody has a plan. Wait your turn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.