Home / View Point / Guest Columns / Man, mosquito and money: Raffique on Zika war and State spending

Man, mosquito and money: Raffique on Zika war and State spending

Dr Sherene Kalloo launched a broadside yesterday against Health Minister Terrence Deyalsingh and his almost jokey war against the Zika virus, pre-empting a column I had already half-written, titled “Man vs Mosquito.”

Photo: Mosquitos carrying the Zika virus are causing a global stir. (Copyright Abc.net.au)
Photo: Mosquitos carrying the Zika virus are causing a global stir.
(Copyright Abc.net.au)

Dr Kalloo argued that Minister Deyalsingh’s declaration of war against Zika and the Aedes Egypti mosquito by deploying soldiers, as hard-hit Brazil has done, as being a failed strategy.

It has not worked in Brazil and it will not work here.

I concur.

What we need is not to inform citizens about the breeding habits of the mosquito and how they can minimise the threat; they know all of that, having been so informed by public health officers who comb residential communities a few times a year, and by media campaigns that have been conducted for years.

We need to lock up nasty people who keep their premises in awful conditions, literally providing nurseries for not just mosquitoes, but also vermin like rats, cockroaches and flies, even as their neighbours spend time and money to keep their surroundings clean.

Unless and until the authorities take drastic measures, they are as guilty as the culprits of facilitating the possible spread of Zika, not to add the never-ending Dengue and Chickungunya viruses.

Photo: Health Minister Terrence Deyalsingh.
Photo: Health Minister Terrence Deyalsingh.

Since mosquitoes rarely fly farther that a few hundred feet from their spawning ground, it takes only one stinker on a street to endanger the health and lives of his neighbours, and by extension, the nation.

Besides existing laws against having unkempt premises, there laws that compel owners of vacant plots in residential areas to keep them clean or face fines or even forfeit their properties to the State.

There are laws, too, that prohibit people from keeping derelict vehicles, discarded tyres and other insect—and vermin—spawning waste on their premises, or dumping them in public places.

But who enforces the laws?

The regional corporations are empowered to take action in all instances cited above, but they seem to be political eunuchs. Their chairpersons adorn themselves with faux-gold cow-chains around their necks and host or attend every drink-up in their districts, but do nothing else.

If Minister Deyalsingh insists on deploying troops to fight mosquitoes, he might well be setting up our soldiers for a letdown. Because unless they are authorised to lock up all offenders, there would be an embarrassing mismatch in which burly, fully-armed soldiers lose the war against tiny, pesky mosquitoes!

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago soldiers on the move. (Copyright Baltimore Examiner)
Photo: Trinidad and Tobago soldiers on the move.
(Copyright Baltimore Examiner)

I move on to other government interventions that bother me.

Why is $90 million being spent during this “guava season” on the Brian Lara Stadium?

That structure was a Patrick Manning misadventure in the first place. This small country already has five stadia, one of which meets full international standards—the Hasely Crawford.

It also has the Queen’s Park Oval (privately owned), and several other first class cricket facilities—at the UWI, Couva, Guaracara and elsewhere.

On a per capita basis, we have more sporting stadia and facilities than any other country. Jamaica and its phalanx of world class sporting stars must envy us.

So there was no need for the extremely costly, Tarouba complex.

Having already consumed approximately one billion dollars, another $90 million has been allocated to complete it. This at a time when Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley has called on the population to exercise discretion in spending money.

Faced with a depressed economy and uncertain times, consumers are advised to buy what they need, not what they want.

Photo: Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley gestures to supporters at Balisier House after the election results on September 7. (Courtesy Allan V Crane/Wired868)
Photo: Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley gestures to supporters at Balisier House after the election results on September 7.
(Courtesy Allan V Crane/Wired868)

Question that Dr Rowley and his ministers must answer is: Do we need the Lara Stadium now?

The answer must be an emphatic “No!”

Sure, we must complete it at some time. The previous Government ought to have done so when the oil dollars flowed but they refused, purely for political reasons. Now, however, is hardly the time to spend $100 million on something we do not need.

Secure it and defer its completion until after the economy is seen as stable.

Then there is Noel Garcia’s announcement that, by next month, close to $400 million in restoration works will resume at the Red House.

Unlike the unnecessary Lara stadium, the Red House is an historical building that most citizens will want to see restored. Preliminary works began some 20 years ago, at which time revenues were buoyant.

For undisclosed reasons—citizens are never kept informed—there has been little progress when the dollars flowed.

Why pour $400 million into that project now? It does not make sense.

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago's Red House.
Photo: Trinidad and Tobago’s Red House.

Dr Rowley must know that he still enjoys much goodwill among the populace, and people have heeded his call for them to be prudent in their spending, as is evidenced by their curtailment in Carnival spending. Even the PNM fete had to be cancelled.

But citizens expect Government to lead by example.

You cannot have us tighten our belts until we can hardly breathe while you slacken spending on projects that are not priorities.

AboutRaffique Shah

Raffique Shah
Raffique Shah is a columnist for over three decades, founder of the T&T International Marathon, co-founder of the ULF with Basdeo Panday and George Weekes, a former sugar cane farmers union leader and an ex-Siparia MP. He trained at the UK’s Royal Military Academy Sandhurst and was arrested, court-martialled, sentenced and eventually freed on appeal after leading 300 troops in a mutiny at Teteron Barracks during the Black Power revolution of 1970.

Check Also

Criticism vs Critique Pt 2: Hassanali takes a stab at the fuel subsidy debate

I am no hypocrite. So before someone, having read what I have so far written, …

19 comments

  1. One does not always have to do something, one only has to look as if one is doing something.The horrible disaster that is maintained through continuous lawlessness cannot be remedied with a band aid.

  2. Keith: “In a time of a possible health crisis, hmmn, should I open a hospital or a Stadium?
    Oh, that’s it, I’ll open a Stadium. Even though it is not needed, will have high maintenance costs, and be a big white elephant, I will show them PNM logic.”

    • Keith: “…and while the unemployment rate rises; rise in food prices, cars, taxi fares, books, with a 15 million cut in the school feeding programme despite a greater need for it now, let me spend $400 million to make the Red House look nice, so that my financiers will have a better looking Port of Spain…..oooh, and let me spend less in Agriculture, so that we will have to import more produce with depleting foreign exchange. Now that is PNM logic”

      • The PNM has neglected to appoint a new Cocoa and Coffee Board. As such, the cocoa farmers cannot sell their produce and the crops are rotting. Alternative markets could not have been accessed due to the short time frame. This is a loss to farmers and of potential foreign exchange as the local cocoa has been highly sought by foreign businesses. Great is the PNM..they are great indeed.

  3. They should sell it to some private investors and spend the money instead on parks and public spaces for young children and adults. Trinidad is too small to become a concrete jungle. Invest in good management of the parks and it might help the nation’s health – and its cardio/obesity/health issues. Kids need safe places to play.

  4. No government can please everybody with its spending habits. I share his concerns about these mega projects at this time. On the surface, I agree they seem unnecessary. Having said that however, the construction industry remains a key one during a recession as long as local labour is being used…
    On another note… Between joint patrols with the police and mosquito population control efforts, the army is suddenly becoming very busy. And man like Shaun Lynch say dey is only shine boots and guns…no respect! Lol.

  5. I agree with Shah re need for more rigorous enforcement of laws prohibiting behaviours that will make mosquito infestation more likely.