Daly Bread: The Government and the Media; distracting the watchdog of our minds

Marshall McLuhan, Canadian educator and philosopher, published work in 1964 which became fundamental to understanding the media in the electronic age—even though electronic communication, as we know it, had not yet been invented.  He created the famous phrases ‘global village’ and ‘the medium is the message’.

McLuhan posited, in summary, that ‘the message which a medium conveys can only be understood if the medium and the environment in which the medium is used are analyzed together’. He also asserted that ‘the content of a medium is like a juicy piece of meat carried by a burglar to distract the watchdog of the mind’.

Photo: The Architect in a scene from the Matrix Reloaded.

The use of media in politics to distract the watchdog of our minds is now routine and dangerous. We are frequently either misled or subject to ferocious attempts to distract us from the core of an issue. The distracting information may vary in reach.

When the distraction is international, the whole interconnected world that constitutes the global village is prey to the distorted information. One significant example of a distortion spread throughout the global village was the now discredited message that the Iraq war against Saddam Hussein was justified because Iraq had ‘weapons of mass destruction’.

In the now visibly chaotic state of Trinidad and Tobago, we are constantly set up in order to distract the watchdog of our minds from due diligence over the exercise of constitutional power and the management of the interests of the public. Here are three recent examples.

In August last year, when the now notorious merit list relating to the appointment of a commissioner of police was never sent by the President to the Parliament, as required by the Constitution, we were fed bits and pieces of information while the constitutional process was being undermined. But the Government was not ready to say frontally in the Parliament that it did not want Gary Griffith.  

Photo: Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley delivers an address to the nation on Thursday 25 November 2021.

Subsequently, but only when it must have decided that it was a politically expedient time to do so, it openly rejected Griffith—much later than it should have done so in Parliament had the constitutional process been followed without subversion.

Eight months later, there is still no substantive commissioner of police and we are murder and fraud-ridden. Following the fraudulent land transactions and the grabbing of state lands complained of by former minister of agriculture Clarence Rambharat when he left the Cabinet last month, a statement was made in accordance with the practice whereby the statement is the substance.

By the statement is the substance, I mean the regular issue of statements that a minister, a committee of ministers or an independent committee will look into a controversial matter and report to Cabinet, but nothing of substance is intended to be done–or is done–beyond the statement, receipt of the report and, sometimes, its publication.  

That is the miasmic governance that we tolerate as dysfunction multiplies.

The land fraud statement was simply a repackage announcing the formation of a land authority which, suspiciously, is to be headed by the same former minister Rambharat—an assignment at odds with the reasons the former minister gave for leaving the Government.

Photo: Clarence Rambharat on the campaign trail in the lead-up to the 2020 general elections.
(via PNM)

Two weeks ago, the Ministry of Education indulged in another favourite tactic of distraction. After twisting and turning in its messages when there was confusion about which of two students had rightfully earned the gold medal for first place based on the results of the Secondary Education Assessment (SEA) examinations, it lashed out at the media.

The practice of the Ministry to use results that were preliminary only was exposed.  This permits the minister—PNM and UNC alike—to grab a photo-opportunity with the ‘winning’ student.  

When caught by what the finalised results showed about placings and an unsustainable decision to alter the placings, the Ministry was eventually forced to express regret, which it qualified by blaming the media for ‘exacerbating the anguish’ of the students involved.

The latest statement without substance is the appointment of a committee comprising 22 persons to consider school violence. It is to present, as a first step, ‘a draft national disciplinary matrix to a Ministerial team’—reportedly in two weeks.

They think we chupidee or what?

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: Auditing conduct in public office; more self-control needed

An indication given in a weekly column to deal with an identified topic “next week” is one that is difficult Read more

Noble: Lack of integrity scares me—does Mr Harford think crooks wouldn’t jook him?

“Look for three things in a person: intelligence, energy and integrity. If they don’t have the last one, don’t even Read more

Daly Bread: Caring about Ballai and Pierre

I begin this week with a thank you to those in the airport who welcomed me home on the Saturday Read more

Daly Bread: Celebration of life—toast to Dumas, de la Bastide and Brown

It is 22 years to the day that my very first column appeared in the Sunday Express newspaper. It has Read more

Daly Bread: Practiced detachment from the killings

Last week’s column was forced to return to what I assert is the government’s unwillingness to take any responsibility for Read more

Daly Bread: Government extends blame game while crime rampages on

For some weeks this column had been focused on the good, the bad and the ugly of Carnival and its Read more

Check Also

Daly Bread: Auditing conduct in public office; more self-control needed

An indication given in a weekly column to deal with an identified topic “next week” …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.