CWI axes selectors Harper, Bascombe; head coach Simmons to lead pro-tem panel

EPL Infrafred Sauna

Appointed as lead selector for two years in mid-October 2019, Roger Harper got a two-month extension until the end of the current year. But that’s it!

Cricket West Indies today announced that neither the former off-spinner nor Miles Bascombe, the second member of the three-member panel, will have his contract renewed.

Photo: Former West Indies chief selector Roger Harper.

Phil Simmons, the third member of the Harper selection threesome in his capacity as head coach, remains on the new pro-tem panel, which includes Test captain Kraigg Brathwaite and white ball skipper Kieron Pollard. The selection process, CWI says, is to be supervised by Director of Cricket, Jimmy Adams.

In a statement, Harper thanked CWI ‘for the opportunity to serve West Indies cricket in the role of lead selector’ and wished the organisation ‘the very best for the future’.

He also took the opportunity to thank Bascombe ‘for his professionalism and teamwork’ as well as ‘all those whose efforts and cooperation helped me to perform my role efficiently’.

Also thanking ‘Roger and Miles for their work and dedicated services to West Indies cricket in the last two years’, Adams put the emphasis elsewhere, never mentioning professionalism, efficiency or success.

“Selecting West Indies teams for international competition is a very challenging assignment,” he added, “and both gentlemen performed their roles with transparency and dignity.”

Photo: (From left) CWI director of cricket Jimmy Adams, selectors Miles Bascombe and Roger Harper, and CWI vice-president Dr Kishore Swallow.
(via CWI Media)

During Harper’s two-year stewardship, WI won a total of 30 of the 76 games played, five of 16 Tests, 11 of 21 ODIs and 14 of 39 T20Is. With the 581/2-year-old at the helm, Jason Holder was replaced as Test captain by Brathwaite and as white ball skipper by Pollard without major controversy.

Harper’s panel’s selections for the recently concluded World Cup in the UAE and Oman, however, provoked much negative reaction. The inclusion of 42-year-old Chris Gayle was a highly criticised element as well as the exclusion of former captain Holder from the 15-member squad and the inclusion of the out-of-form Darren Bravo in the reserves on the 19.

There had also been much dissatisfaction expressed with the selectors’ decision to go with players on the wrong side of 30 such as Dwayne Bravo, Lendl Simmons and Ravi Rampaul instead of younger players like Sherfane Rutherford, Romario Shepherd and Dominic Drakes, for example.

When Pollard’s team was dismissed for 55 in the opening encounter against England and then went on to lose four of its quota of five matches, narrowly beating Bangladesh, on Wired868, Tony McWatt and Reds Perreira called for the selectors to be immediately dismissed along with the captain and the coach.

Photo: West Indies cricket coach Phil Simmons.

A couple of other high-profile commentators added their voices to the chorus of calls for changes to be made, including to the selection panel

But CWI president Ricky Skerritt declared that there would be no knee-jerk reaction to the pathetic showing by the regional team. And CEO Johnny Grave noted that the board had little interest in tinkering with personnel but was putting the focus on reforming the systems so that ‘we are producing players and preparing players on that world stage’.

But presumably after due reflection, the board has deemed it unwise to continue with Harper and Bascombe and will begin the search for a new lead selector next month.

Ireland are due to arrive in the month for a three-match ODI series starting on 8 January and, a one-off T20 game at Sabina Park reliably reported to be billed as a send-off for the long-serving Gayle.

So instead of Harper and his panel, it will be Simmons and his new-look panel who will now be doing the honours–at least for the next engagement.

More from Wired868
Dear editor: Why not Bravo for Dowrich? ICC should normalise CWI!

“[…] The last straw is in [the CWI’s] media release of Shane Dowrich’s retirement announcement, indicating that a replacement won’t Read more

Discarded Darren bides his time, DJ Bravo throws WI selectors under the bus

At 34, Darren Bravo probably did not have his eyes on a place in the West Indies squad for the Read more

Benjamin: Why WI never got the best out of Sunil Narine

By his own admission a man of few words, Sunil Narine once found enough of them to point accusing fingers Read more

Orwell’s take on Maxwell’s incredible no-foot batting, Cummins’ wotlissness and West Indian purblindness

The spirit of George Orwell lay heavy over Mumbai’s Wankhede Stadium on Tuesday evening after favourites Australia got past underdogs Read more

Challenging Dr Rowley—after Colm doesn’t cough up cash for cricket clubs

Budget Day. As usual, many citizens are waiting to hear what goodies are coming their way this year. Most are Read more

Early Bird: Told ya! GAW put karmic classic cutarse on complacent TKR

Calmer than you imagine any Trinbago cricket fan would be, Bobby smirked his way through our entire fo’daymorning Republic Day Read more

About Earl Best

Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970's. He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.

Check Also

Dear editor: Why not Bravo for Dowrich? ICC should normalise CWI!

“[…] The last straw is in [the CWI’s] media release of Shane Dowrich’s retirement announcement, …


  1. Harp Her should have gone long before now

  2. Ok. It’s much needed action. Let us see how this goes.
    I maintain that the problems with WI cricket have been many years in the making and therefore fixes will not occur overnight. Too many of our ‘best’ cricketers have come through the system with flawed techniques, which are being cruelly exposed on the international stage.
    Strategies to address this must be ongoing, with particular emphasis on the youth levels.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.