T2021 W/C: Is West Indian mindlessness a mere figment of Mark Nicholas’ imagination?

EPL Properties Ltd

Tuesday morning in the Caribbean. South Africa are on the verge of victory in the second of the West Indies five Super 12 games in the 2021 World Cup.

England’s Mark Nicholas is saluting the pair at the wicket, whose 83-run partnership will soon steer the Proteas to their crushing 8-wkt win.

Photo: South Africa batsmen Rassie van der Dussen (left) and Reeza Hendricks run between the wickets during T20 World Cup action against the West Indies at the Dubai International Stadium on 26 October 2021.

Rassie van der Dussen, he notes, has not made his runs at a rate of knots; they have come at less than a-run-a-ball. But he has, Nicholas points out, ‘been able to hit it when they’re needed (…) He’s got an excellent cricket brain.’

Rewind to 2016. The West Indians have qualified for the knockout round. Notwithstanding that, Nicholas declares that they are not in contention for the title.

Why? ‘They have no brains.’

KFC Munch Pack

He apologised, of course. But don’t be fooled. That apology was not for the racist diss but for saying the quiet part out loud.

I have not the slightest doubt that Nicholas believes—at the very least, believed!—that Daren Sammy’s 2016 West Indians ‘have no brains’.

Photo: English cricket commentator Mark Nicholas.

After Saturday’s embarrassingly feckless showing against England, the temptation to agree was strong indeed. And now, after the 8-wkt cutarse Temba Bavuma’s de Kock-less side put on us yesterday, it’s hard for you not to ask yourself this question, which, of course, unwittingly concedes Nicholas’ point: are Pollard’s 2021 Caribbean Cavaliers any better?

However framed, it is a question that begs to be asked.

As soon as bidding starts, Pollard, Dwayne Bravo, Andre Russell and Evin Lewis are snapped up by T20 franchises all over the world. So how did a batting line-up comprising four of the world’s premier T20 performers plus a player with 14,000-plus T20 runs to his credit and two, in Nicholas Pooran and Shimron Hetmyer, of the format’s super-exciting if not yet quite accomplished middle-order batsmen contrive to capitulate so ignominiously for T20I’s third-lowest score of 55?

On Saturday, not one of those six could better Gayle’s 13-ball top score of 13! (The irony! The man who top-scored was the man who many people, including, unforgettably, Sir Curtly Ambrose, said should not be in the XI!)

Photo: Veteran West Indies batsman Chris Gayle.
(via CWI Media)

And on Tuesday, when Gayle scored one less, only two of the six got more than he did.

Lendl Simmons also got 16. (The irony! Wasn’t the complaint that the WI batsmen don’t take singles? Simmons got 16 of them and now everyone is complaining! In Calypso History Month, cue Sparrow’s ‘The Old Man and the Donkey’.) The truth is that the TKR opener required 34 balls for his 16, leading one commenter to note that it was not very smart of Kagiso Rabada to get him out.

“I think the West Indians might be happy,” Shane Watson, on commentary, remarked wryly, “that Lendl Simmons is out.”

So the $64,000 question that WI cannot avoid is this: what ails Pollard’s troops?

I don’t know if Pollard knows the answer. Certainly, when Nicholas put the question to him in the post-match interview, he responded without answering.

Photo: West Indies captain Kieron Pollard (left) heads to the stands after being dismissed by England spinner Adil Rashid during T20 World Cup action at the Dubai International Stadium on 23 October 2021.

I don’t pretend to know the answer either. But I think I know where help can come from.

The ex-cricketers in the commentary box provide, I submit, more than a hint. In the pre-match presentation, Ian Bishop, who is cricket’s Pope, volunteered that the West Indies are ‘traditionally a six-hitting team’. However, his urbi et orbi sermon offered neither compliment nor criticism of the attribute.

Daren Sammy, who led the West Indies to the 2012 and 2016 titles, said that today, he expected ‘to see a different West Indies mentality’. But with four overs left and the score still a less-than-challenging 118 for 3, Sammy insisted that ‘we (not WI, we!) are a boundary-hitting, a six-hitting team’.

He expected, he said, the batsmen to get at least four more sixes before the end of the innings; that would leave 20 balls to get whatever else was needed to take the score up to—and hopefully beyond—par.

That, he noted, is what they would have been saying in the dressing-room. He never quite said so but I was left with the impression that he meant in 2012, in 2016 and in 2021!

Photo: West Indies batsman Evin Lewis in action against South Africa during the T20 World Cup on 26 October 2021.
(via CWI Media)

Pommie Mbangwa interjected—I almost said ‘objected’—with a pertinent question.

“Is that not,” he asked, “putting all your eggs in one basket?”.

“No,” came Sammy’s instant response, “it’s not.”

Test cricket and T20 cricket, I need no reminder, are worlds apart. Pollard, the incredibly successful short format player who now leads the two West Indies white ball teams, has never even been in a Test squad, let alone on a starting XI.

But I think it might be useful to share two attitudes to six hitting from two people who, like today’s teams, live in completely different worlds, the West Indies and South Africa of the 1950s.

The first is the late Sir Everton DeCourcy Weekes, whose 4,455 Test runs contained two sixes, one of them benefiting from an overthrow. To the end of his days, he preached that, if you keep the ball on the ground, you eliminate one of the five most common methods of dismissal, caught.

Photo: Sir Everton Weekes in action for West Indies against England.
(Copyright Skysports)

The second is Lewis D’Oliveira, perhaps better known as the father of Basil but no mean cricketer himself.

In Basil D’Oliveira Cricket and Conspiracy: The Untold Story, Peter Oborne writes this:

One of Lewis D’Oliveira’s points of contention with his son concerned the sixes Basil liked to hit. He viewed them as vulgar shots, acts of mere animal abandon. He believed balls should be stroked along the ground. Hitting the ball in the air, he held, gave the bowler a chance.

Basil never took the slightest notice of his father’s injunction, and continued to hit the ball for six at every opportunity. Eventually, in despair, the old man offered his son a new cricket bat as a reward if he could score a century which did not include the profanity of a six. The bat remained unclaimed. (my emphasis)

If I had my way, all 19 members of the West Indian travelling party whom WI expect to defend the title so hard-won in 2016 would be required to read that paragraph aloud to the other 18 at least once before they take the field against Bangladesh on Friday.

Photo: West Indies all-rounder Andre Russell in attacking mode.
(Copyright CWI Media)

And, in Calypso History Month, to listen to what Stalin told us in Nothing Come Easy’ way back in the last century:

So when a black man have something/He got to start thinking:/To get it ent easy./He got to practise economy./From getting licks from the slavemaster/To become the landowner/Is a terrible journey/Packed with plenty brutality.

Yuh got to make yuh mind that yuh able/To get up early and jam with the Devil/Because ah done tell yuh arready/Black man doh get nutten easy.

Ask Quinton de Kock…

More from Wired868
Caribbean-first! CPL announces Republic Bank as new title sponsor—Trinidad gets 10 games

The Caribbean Premier League (CPL) and Republic Bank Ltd (RBL) are forging a new cricketing partnership, with Republic Bank today Read more

Dr Shallow and Bassarath elected as CWI president and vice-president

Dr Kishore Shallow and Azim Bassarath have been elected to the posts of president and vice-president respectively, of Cricket West Read more

Windies recall Gabriel for ODIs; Pooran, McCoy are in but no Hetmyer for S/Africa tour

Veteran Trinidad and Tobago Red Force pacer Shannon Gabriel was recalled to the West Indies One-Day International (ODI) team today, Read more

“Greatest honour of my career”, “Dream come true”—Hope and Powell named WI white-ball captains

Wicketkeeper/batter Shai Hope and batting allrounder Rovman Powell will lead the West Indies cricket team in the One-Day International (ODI) Read more

Lara takes “performance mentor” job to “improve game sense” of Windies players

West Indies cricket legend Brian Lara was unveiled today as the Cricket West Indies’ (CWI) new performance mentor with a Read more

Test cricket for white-ball players, fitness consensus, center wicket practice: the CWI’s 34-point Report on T20 W/Cup exit

“[…] It is not in the best interests of West Indies Cricket that our best players play in every global Read more

About Earl Best

Earl Best
Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970's. He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.

Check Also

Caribbean-first! CPL announces Republic Bank as new title sponsor—Trinidad gets 10 games

The Caribbean Premier League (CPL) and Republic Bank Ltd (RBL) are forging a new cricketing …


  1. I can’t believe the writer had the audacity to mention Gayle’s top score of 13 and highlight his score in the second match as well. This is sad.
    I would rather an upcoming player being given that opportunity than see the great Gayle being a shadow of his best.
    What is a satisfactory score for a batsman in Ttwenty cricket?

    If Rampaul made 13 then that is a plus.

    • Earl Best

      Audacity, Jomo?

      I think your dictionary might just be missing the first S page which features words beginning with sar-.
      Have a look see and let me know.

  2. Mark Nicholas always finds a reason to criticise the WI team which he grudgingly praise if they win.
    I agree that he is a racist of the highest order and cannot understand why he continues to be a commentator
    when the ICC purports to support anti-racism.

  3. Earl Best

    Still requesting anonymity, my former student has this to offer in response to today’s column:

    I fear the self-image of our players does not allow them to stop in mid-wicket and change their way of playing the game.

    Maybe that is what Lendl tried today and you saw the result: 16 runs from 35 balls.

    That has to be practised; you cannot prepare one way and execute another. That does not happen in sports and is made even more difficult in such a fast-paced game as cricket.

    Also, I fear the shorter boundaries in the WI mislead us in our analysis of our preparation; there is probably no transfer to the actual venues.

    Finally, I think we are focusing on the batting because the results are obvious. But I am also suspicious of our bowling attack. Why is no one talking about that?

    • Earl Best

      And he has now added this:

      It has been said time and time again that our style is to hit sixes. To try to change this midway in the tournament may now prove almost impossible. There is not enough time to reinforce the change.

      Let me share a story from The Champion’s Mind by Jim Afremow:

      The Frog and The Centipede

      A frog meets a centipede and, after watching it for a while, says, “It’s unbelievable! How can you walk so fast and coordinate all those legs of yours? I only have four and I still find it difficult.”

      At this, the centipede stops, thinks about it, and finds himself unable to leave again.

      The moral of the story is obviously that overthinking leads to underperforming.

      Not many can make the required adjustment quickly enough. Lara would have been able to because of his experience and maturity developed from playing the long game and his understanding of mental techniques and strategies in addition to one of the key characteristics of the West Indian cricketer, “bad mind”. that aggressive desire to dominate the bowling no matter how good it may be.

      This is what the world loved about our play. The thing is this present bunch has not learned to temper this aggression and think critically.

  4. In every one of these contests (if you could describe them as) so far we have been a distant 3rd (to be generous). Our batting skills/shot selection have been terrible. If this is the format our style of cricket is best suited to and we can’t mount a serious challenge, our cricket is in even greater peril than we are willing to imagine.
    At the moment I am not seeing where a credible win is going to come from (that includes Bangladesh and Afghanistan).

  5. Lasana Liburd

    Personally I cringe at the suggestion that West Indians play ‘mindless cricket’. Even if it comes from a West Indian.
    I don’t think any athlete gets to near the pinnacle of his or profession while being ‘mindless’ in any way.
    I’d accept ‘flawed game plan’, a ‘rush of blood’, maybe ‘misplaced bravado’… Mindless cuts too deep, especially when referring to a top class athlete.

    • Earl Best

      It is not the word that we should deplore; it’s the phenomenon.

      Just as a rose by any other name would smell as sweet, a pile of faeces stinks no less than if you styled it s***.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.