‘PM threw police under the bus!’ Griffith fires back at ‘disappointing’ Rowley over Bayside party

EPL Properties Ltd

“[…] If the GORTT wishes to have enforcement of the regulations on private property and inside persons homes, they need to amend the legislation or provide new legislation that would allow the police clear and unambiguous authority to do what the prime minister has insinuated should be done.

“The prime minister, as the most experienced politician in the government, should know that the amendments to the law cannot be done through press conferences…”

Photo: Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley.
(via PNM)

The following media statement from the Trinidad and Tobago Police Service is in response to yesterday’s press conference, hosted by Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley, in which he appeared to criticise the police’s failure to take decisive action while dealing with a pool party at Bayside Towers in Cocorite:

Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley: “[…] It is not for me to tell the police commissioner how to interpret the law, but as prime minister I can say the law must apply to everyone—regardless of race, creed, class or social standing—so as to protect us in Trinidad and Tobago from those who are not prepared to listen…”

Minister of National Security Stuart Young: “[…] The TTPS can intervene and make arrests in any circumstance that it deems a threat to public safety, regardless of if it occurs in public or private settings…”

Commissioner of Police Gary Griffith: “[The] PM [is] alluding for (sic) police to breach constitutional rights of persons by arresting them for acts committed when there was no law enacted to do so. I am committed to uphold the law and not break it by arresting persons illegally as proposed…”

The Trinidad and Tobago Police Service (TTPS) notes with some degree of disappointment the comments of the honourable prime minister yesterday where he alluded to and/or insinuated that the TTPS failed to do its job as it related to the matter involving a party held poolside at Bayside Towers in Cocorite.

In effect, the TTPS was thrown under the proverbial bus.

The TTPS stands ready and committed to enforce all laws passed by the government, however we must be wary of simply responding to public or political pressure especially as it relates to potentially abusing the rights of individuals and/or acting illegally in a quest to satisfy public or political pressure. The simple question before the TTPS is can we enter private property without a warrant and charge persons for committing violations of the Public Health Ordinance simply because they number more than five?

We have sought and received several legal opinions on this and are indeed comfortable with our current interpretation of the law and therefore our response to the matter at hand.

The law as currently constructed does not diminish a person’s constitutional rights as a whole and in particular, their rights to enjoy property. This makes for a difficult judgement call on the part of the TTPS.

Photo: Commissioner of Police Gary Griffith (right) has a word with ACP Michael Pierre.
(via Stabroeknews)

For instance, if 20 owners of property at Bayside Towers, or any other gated community, were at the common area pool relaxing, is it being suggested we should enter the compound and arrest them all for violating the Covid-19 regulations simply because they number more than five?

The TTPS recalls that the number established by the Ordinance at the time of the general election was 10 yet we heard no outrage at that time when all political  parties were pushing the limits of the law. And in those instances there was no question of private versus public space. We did then what we did in Bayside—caution persons!

Is the issue with this Bayside matter the number of people, or the fact it was a party, or the fact it was on social media, or the fact that they are perceived as rich?

As the TTPS, we respond to breaches of the Public Health Ordinance. We don’t respond to perceptions of race, creed, or class.

The average citizen can only enter Bayside if invited. Someone invited those people there. Bayside Residential Association has it within their rules to control these issues among themselves. They are the communal owners of that property.

Photo: Young persons enjoy themselves at a Bayside Towers pool party on 6 September 2020.

In this particular case, it was the very neighbours inside Bayside that called to complain, and TTPS responded. By the time we arrived we saw nothing in terms of numbers or activities consistent with what was shared on social media.

We accept that this pandemic dictates that things cannot proceed as normal as one person’s silly actions can have a damaging effect on the entire population. Having said that, the TTPS must balance the competing interests of the Public Health Ordinance and the constitutional rights of citizens. We try to do so evenly.

Since the beginning of the ‘lockdown’, we have consistently taken the approach to warn and persuade ahead of arrest. The suggestion that somehow persons at one location have gotten privileges that others haven’t gotten is ridiculous, misinformed, and dangerous, and only inflames an already delicate situation.

The solution to this matter lies in the hands of the Government of Trinidad and Tobago and not the Police. If the GORTT wishes to have enforcement of the regulations on private property and inside persons homes, they need to amend the legislation or provide new legislation that would allow the police clear and unambiguous authority to do what the prime minister has insinuated should be done.

Photo: Commissioner of Police Gary Griffith (centre) accompanies lawmen on a TTPS exercise.
(via TTPS)

The prime minister, as the most experienced politician in the government, should know that the amendments to the law cannot be done through press conferences. The PM should know that any changes to the constitutional rights of citizens should be done through Parliament. His Attorney General should so advise him of this.

If we respond to incidents like the one at Bayside and simply start arresting people there would be hundreds of lawsuits against the state for wrongful arrest, since no law would have been amended to reflect this.

This approach to law enforcement, reminiscent of the illegal arrests of the 2011 State of Emergency, is obscene—and if pursued, will cost the state millions of dollars in damages and legal costs after successful suits.

If the PM was genuine in his claims that no one is above the law and all should be dealt with equally, he would not put the TTPS to be the fall guy by giving us the power to arrest those from humble resources who swim in public spaces, but prevents us from taking action on those who commit similar acts in the haven of luxurious pools in private property which we have been given no power to arrest such fortunate individuals.

More from Wired868
Noble: Playing chess with The Dragon; Dr Rowley’s gas gamble

“For any developing economy dependent on a single export commodity, powerful economic and political forces, both domestic and external, qualify Read more

Dear Editor: Police work is a “wicked problem”; Dr Rowley should change tack to address crime

“[…] Dr Keith Rowley, police work is what is known as a “wicked problem”. Rittel & Webber (1973) identified the Read more

Vaneisa: Foggy days of fatigue and other post-Covid symptoms

I’ve come to believe that what I had thought to be a vicious bout of both acid reflux and one Read more

Dear Editor: If feters are doing as they please, why are we mandated to wear masks?

“[…] Over the last week we have held the Jam Naked Fete and the Stink & Dutty Fete, which seemed Read more

Demming: We need to fix the system, not subvert it to suit our friends

The perception that if you are within the inner circle of the government, you can get anything you want was Read more

MSJ: Workers and poor people can’t afford to pay more for transport, withdraw fuel hike

“[…] Minister Colm Imbert said that the $1 increase is so that the burden of adjustment can be equally shared Read more

About Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor
Want to share your thoughts with Wired868? Email us at editor@wired868.com. Please keep your letter between 300 to 600 words and be sure to read it over first for typos and punctuation. We don't publish anonymously unless there is a good reason, such as an obvious threat of harassment or job loss.

Check Also

Daly Bread: Answers required for accountability in DPP imbroglio

Persons in public life frequently exercise power without accountability. As President Paula-Mae Weekes was recently …


  1. There were people who felt the police did not have the authority to do anything to break up COVID-19 parties by persons doing whatever they wanted on their private property, and I had to explain that the powers that people did not think I have, I do have it and I would use it.” Gary Griffith

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.