Daly Bread: 25 years of making excuses: the state repeatedly fails to punish and prevent murder

EPL Infrafred Sauna

Two weeks ago, Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley made a chilling, although realistic, admission about murder in our country and its clear and present danger at all times and in every place.

The prime minister was commenting on the murder and robbery at a Tobago supermarket in which a security guard was killed, reportedly with an assault weapon.

Photo: Another lifeless body heads to the morgue in Trinidad.

He was shocked and distressed. He was reportedly ‘shocked because assault weapons in crime, in tranquil communities like that, will always shock you because you don’t expect it. But they are running around out there, and the job now is to find them, because if you don’t find them, they would do it again.’

The prime minister also acknowledged that ‘we have to be security conscious at all times in every place.’

We should be grateful that, unlike his predecessor, PNM Prime Minister Patrick Manning, he is distressed, rather than merely dismissing a murder as ‘collateral damage’.

But what is there to be shocked about concerning another brutal murder?

In July 1994, in an editorial, the Express newspapers enquired of then Prime Minister Manning what and where was his plan ‘while the carnage of innocent citizens continues’.

One of the earliest columns I wrote about our dysfunctional national security was published in September 2002. I had already examined the link between deprivation and brutal crime, making it plain that deprivation was not merely economic.

Photo: A young man kisses a high powered weapon.

I have repeatedly emphasized that there must be a fundamental change in the socio-economic conditions in disadvantaged communities. Youngsters at risk grow up deprived of affection, frequently abused. They are thrown into an education system that is not relevant to their needs and stigmatises many of them as failures by 11 or 12.

In January 2015, after we had twice changed the parties in government, the murder-ridden conditions under which we were living had not changed. In a column titled The Twilight Zone of National Security, shortly after the death of former PNM Minister of National Security Martin Joseph, I wrote this: “He and all his successors as ministers of national security, including the incumbent, Gary Griffith, are trapped in constitutional and socio-political circumstances that guarantee failure and also make them unable to understand the irrelevance of their office.”

I continued: “… with an entrenched murder rate of more than one per day, and few arrests and successful prosecutions, these ministers live in a twilight zone into which light never dawns. They are doomed forever only to create and repeat excuses why murder abounds and to ignore the impunity that most murderers enjoy.”

The prime minister’s recent remarks are merely sentimental musings. At the risk of repetition of two decades of columns, we need socio-economic policies that go beyond make-work programmes and freeness. These policies must be designed to put disadvantaged communities on a sustainable path of self-improvement and self-esteem.

Photo: CEPEP workers enjoy life outdoors.

The obvious need to meaningfully link social development policy to our performing arts is a continuing government blind spot. I doubt whether last week’s transfer of Mrs Camille Robinson-Regis to the ministry of social development will change the game at that ministry.

Members of this government promised to remove the criminal elements from the make-work programmes. That promise is a sham, and turf war over these programmes will continue to contribute to the 500-plus murders per year.

The police service has no moral authority to blame others for the rampant murders until it can catch the killers, traffickers and thieves. The impunity factor with which murder is committed must be diminished. Showpiece raids, swagger and threats will not accomplish that vital objective.

The job to find the killers is not a new job. It has always been the job of the police to find the killers and that they have failed miserably to do.

There have been 25 years of making excuses for doing neither the policing nor the socio-economic development job.

Photo: Police commissioner Gary Griffith (centre) poses with disgraced ex-Fifa VP Jack Warner (left) and retired Brigadier Carlton Alfonso in a party at his residence on 28 December 2019.
Warner is wanted for corruption in the United States.
(Copyright Trinidad Express)

In the circumstances of such failure and empty utterances, why on earth should we not view with distaste both the PNM and UNC big boys and captains of industry grinning away, all happy together, at a recent party at the residence of the commissioner of police?

They care bout we?

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: Education triple whammy

Two weeks ago, I described conditions in the education system as destructive. I identified what I called the double whammy Read more

Daly Bread: T&T must address destructive education conditions

Both Professor Emeritus Dr Ramesh Deosaran and Darius Figuera, well known criminologist, last week expressed distaste for the Government and Read more

Daly Bread: Saturday morning serenade at the Green Market

Upon arrival at the Green Market in Santa Cruz, two Saturdays ago, I bumped into a professional couple—each highly placed Read more

Daly Bread: Government gaps in call out on crime

My close friends are worried for the safety of commentators on violent crime. In my case, they firmly believe that Read more

Daly Bread: “Firetrucking” courageous and consistent—remembering BC

BC Pires, renowned writer and journalist, recently deceased at age 65, was encouraging when I became a weekly columnist.  Whatever Read more

Noble: Are we all living pipe dreams, like Mahal, while T&T suffers?

Mahal was the walking legend in Trinidad from the 1930s to the early 60s. He pretended to drive a car Read more

About Martin Daly

Martin G Daly SC is a prominent attorney-at-law. He is a former Independent Senator and past president of the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago. He is chairman of the Pat Bishop Foundation and a steelpan music enthusiast.

Check Also

Daly Bread: Education triple whammy

Two weeks ago, I described conditions in the education system as destructive. I identified what …

One comment

  1. Where to start, 57 year young and TT still operating systems and governance that were not meant to benefit us, Massa day done, but his legacy is alive and well and fully supported by those who hold the reigns of power. Nothing highlights it like the Pastor with the stack of cash, while some citizens are struggling to live day to day, the country needs a mind set shift away from at this g Massa, time to create a new vision.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.