Daly Bread: Needing a new Kambule; why T&T Carnival requires a paradigm shift

At the Panorama semi-finals two weeks ago, I became involved in a discussion with Eintou Springer, her daughter Attilah and an official of Pan Trinbago. The discussion turned to how Pan Trinbago spent the taxpayers’ money it received from complicit governments in the past and apparently continues on the same path.

I supported the position of Eintou and Attilah that the persons who benefit most from the largesse are not the authentic participants in the Carnival tradition.

To my delight, it subsequently turned out that another person fully articulated why a lavish budget is not required to support authentic Carnival activities.

Photo: Anderson Marcano (left) fends away a charge by Roger Sanbury during the Carnival 2019 National Stick-fighting Finals at the Arima Velodrome, Arima on 27 February 2019.
(Copyright Allan V Crane/CA-images/Wired868)

In a recent report in the Newsday, Mr Kwasi Robinson described the “lost opportunity in years gone by to be prudent with spending and just to manage Carnival itself.”

Mr Robinson was identified as the local Economic Development Officer at the Tunapuna Corporation, who has oversight over a regional Carnival celebration.

His articulation of the alternative to wasting money was so on point that I am pleased to adopt and recommend it in this Carnival Sunday column—at a time when the usual foolishness about why there must be endless subventions without any adjustments is being spouted:

“When you look at who makes significant money from Carnival, it is not the revellers or the people who make it happen. It is sound-system people, lights, people who rent toilets, tables and chairs.

“What we need now is to re-align our expenditure to make sure that money is in the hands of the masmen, the pan players, the calypsonians, because they are [the people] who provide the content for the Carnival.

“I could do a big sound system with TT$40,000 or I can do some self-powered monitors for TT$5,000 and give three bands TT$5,000 each and I have TT$20,000—and my event is much better than what I would have spent.”

Photo: A partygoer enjoys herself at the Tribe Ice fete at the Queen’s Park Savannah on 5 January 2019.
(Copyright Allan V Crane/CA-Images/Wired868)

For my part, the sound systems are deafening and I have never understood the fixation with tents. Carnival takes place in the dry season, punctuated by rare but stimulating wet me down. Massive festivals abroad—where the weather is much less kind—are held without the use of as many tents for spectators.

The Calypso Fiesta crowd know to use their parasols. Ask Tantie Merle about parasol for cricket when cricket mattered.

It is also very noticeable that the tents are erected two weeks before any event is scheduled. Let’s hope the taxpayers are not paying a daily rate for the rental of those tents. Town say that the tent people pocket strong.

These excessive expenditures illustrate how complicit governments have enabled others, at taxpayers’ expense, to take the Kambule—the Kilongo word for procession—from its roots. Thankfully the Springer family and others point out to us the elements of African origin in Carnival, which owes its birth to the processions of important but frequently neglected ancestors.

It is reported that Machel Montano recently visited the Ministry of Tourism and advised the Ministry that “tradition and technology must be brought together in the interest of advancing the culture.”

Then followed the inevitable press release. In pursuit of a desire to make themselves relevant, the tourism authorities have declared that music and culture can promote tourism. They suddenly wake up or what?

Photo: (From left) Culture Minister Dr Nyan Gadsby-Dolly, Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley and Tourism Minister Randall Mitchell open a homework centre in Carenage.
(Copyright Ministry of Housing)

The press release contained fine words about looking for “definitive ways” to promote our culture and a reference to “tourism offerings, including soca music.”

Soca music did not drop from the sky; it evolved through authentic Carnival traditions. It cannot be successfully linked to a Trinidad and Tobago cultural tourism destination detached from the Carnival activities that dominate the first quarter of the year.

What does “definitive ways” mean?  Everything we need is already on the ground.  It requires genuine recognition, non-partisan funding and, dare I repeat, promotion of the Trinidad and Tobago culture destination as a first quarter festival, and not simply the new Mardi Gras from which many real people are excluded by the re-introduction of colonial ropes around certain bands.

This is the context in which we need a new Kambule, a people’s procession in which authentic Carnival arts are given their rightful place in a re-engineered Carnival calendar.

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: Answers required for accountability in DPP imbroglio

Persons in public life frequently exercise power without accountability. As President Paula-Mae Weekes was recently demitting office, we were reminded Read more

Daly Bread: In the land of Jarndyce—the law is in danger of losing its teeth

I have a friend who I will call Jarndyce, to protect his identity and save him from victimization. His story Read more

Daly Bread: The unease of doing business in T&T—and the difficulty in “getting thru”

The inquiry “yuh get thru?” is commonplace. It means: did you succeed in completing the business or personal transaction you Read more

Daly Bread: Are we seeing a Carnival evolution, or a free-for-all?

The hyped-up Carnival 2023 has concluded, but the lack of changes in the traditional infrastructure and other provisions continue visibly Read more

TUCO president on Road March rules, Fay-Ann’s fourth title and Machel/Patrice

Does soca empress Fay-Ann Lyons-Alvarez now have four Road March titles, on the back of her credit for current hit Read more

Hard Fete rules the road! TUCO tallies for Bunji and Fay-Ann

Soca power couple Ian “Bunji Garlin” Alvarez and Fay-Ann Lyons are the first Road March champions of the post-Covid-19 pandemic Read more

About Martin Daly

Martin Daly
Martin G Daly SC is a prominent attorney-at-law. He is a former Independent Senator and past president of the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago. He is chairman of the Pat Bishop Foundation and a steelpan music enthusiast.

Check Also

Daly Bread: Answers required for accountability in DPP imbroglio

Persons in public life frequently exercise power without accountability. As President Paula-Mae Weekes was recently …

One comment

  1. Warning: Undefined variable $userid in /www/wired868_759/public/wp-content/plugins/user-photo/user-photo.php on line 114

    Daly’s ideas are rarely fleshed out or elaborated with the necessary details, I do however accept the core thesis that those who have captured the bureaucracy of Carnival have benefitted and continued to benefit from the state funding of carnival. Included of course are TUCO, Pan Trinbago , The Carnival Band leaders , the provider of services and so on. That undersubscribed tent build at great expensee will be smashed to smithereens on Ash Wednesday or shortly after only to be rebuilt next Year please God.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.