The Trinidad and Tobago Table Tennis Association (TTTTA) has put itself on a collision course with the Trinidad and Tobago Olympic Committee (TTOC), after defying a ruling by the TTOC’s arbitration panel regarding its team for next week’s Central American and Caribbean (CAC) Games in Barranquilla, Colombia.
Yesterday, a three-member arbitration panel, chaired by sport attorney J Tyrone Marcus, ruled—“after due consideration of all the written and oral evidence, and arguments advanced by the disputants”—that the TTTTA’s selection process for the CAC tournament was “flawed and must be set aside.”
And the panel, which also includes attorneys Stefan Fabien and Christophe Brathwaite, ordered the TTTTA to create a new selection committee to decide on its four male CAC team members. These players were to be informed of their selection by 4pm today, while the arbitration panel vowed to share the grounds for its decision by midnight.
The table tennis body initially put forward a four-member team of Curtis Humphreys, Aaron Wilson, Yuvraaj Dookram and Arun Roopnarine. However, the TTTTA’s selection process was successfully challenged by iconic France-based player Dexter St Louis.
St Louis was represented in arbitration by Canada-based sport attorney Dr Emir Crowne and local attorneys Matthew Gayle and Sheriza Khan while TTTA president Ian Joseph, executive member Merle Baggoo and public relations officer Sherdon Pierre represented the local table tennis body.
Joseph chairs the TTTTA’s selection committee while Baggoo and Pierre are committee members along with general secretary Aleena Edwards and Dave Williams.
The CAC Games’ registration deadline passed on 20 June 2018 and Trinidad and Tobago’s top table tennis players must wait to discover if the relevant international body accepts TTOC president Brian Lewis’ plea for a late team change.
However, Joseph refused to follow the directions of the TTOC’s arbitration panel today and countered that the TTTTA officials were confused by the ruling and did not receive explicit directions on creating a new selection committee.
And, in an unsigned press release this afternoon, the TTTTA stood by its initial selection and challenged the arbitrators to explain their decision:
“Concerning the ruling made by the TTOC’s Panel we had this to say:
- That decision advised is going against the TTTTA’s constitution of a national team Selection Criteria.
- What was flawed—the decision not to include Dexter St Louis or the Selection criteria used?
- How come it was flawed for the men and not the women which we did the same process [for], hence that team should [also] be re-selected?
- How are we selecting the committee to select the players and how are they providing their decision to the panel?”
The TTTTA’s current predicament is its second high profile legal defeat this year. In both instances, St Louis was—figuratively at least—on the other side of the court room.
The High Court ruled in February that the table tennis body had unfairly left St Louis and his step-daughter Rheann Chung out of its 2018 Commonwealth Games team. The decision was upheld by the Appeal Court in March.
St Louis, a two-time Olympian, is 49 while Chung is 32. They are the most accomplished players in Trinidad and Tobago’s table tennis history with, among other accolades, five Caribbean titles each. No other local has won a regional senior title in four decades.
Although a late TTOC intervention ensured that St Louis and Chung represented Trinidad and Tobago at the Australia Games, the substantive case continues with the duo suing the TTTTA for:
“Damages for breach of contract and/or breach of duty; damages for conspiracy and/or unlawful interference; aggravated and/or exemplary damages; interest; costs; [and] such further or other relief as the Court deems just.”
It did not take long for the star players and administrators to be at loggerheads again.
Neither St Louis and Chung were invited to play in a CAC qualifying tournament in February, which subsequently appeared to be used as a factor in determining the players selected for the Colombia tournament.
The TTTTA’s own policy regarding its selection of four male players and four female players for the upcoming tournament has changed over time. At one point, the association suggested—as evidenced in an email trail—that the three male players who competed in the February qualifiers would have automatic spots at the CAC Games with St Louis and Aaron Wilson playing for the sole available spot.
However, other correspondence from the association also suggested that all four berths were up for grabs and would be decided by a trials. St Louis and Chung argued that they were not given sufficient notice to attend the makeshift trials while another invited player, Khalil Asgarali, was unavailable.
The TTTTA then ruled out St Louis—since he did not confirm his attendance for the trials—while Chung was drafted in after Edwards indicated that she would travel to Colombia as a coach rather than a player.
The TTOC arbitration panel ruled that the selection process was flawed and should be redone.
There was further confusion regarding Wilson’s participation. The talented 20 year old, who was Trinidad and Tobago’s best performer at the Commonwealth Games, did not attend the Cuba qualifying tournament.
A table tennis official suggested that Wilson, who is the number one locally ranked player at present, could not raise the money to travel to Cuba. Joseph, according to St Louis and his attorney, Gayle, also told the arbitration panel that “economic factors” led to Wilson’s absence from the qualifiers.
However, after St Louis—via Gayle—urged the TTOC to investigate the TTTTA’s supposed discrimination against poorer players, the table tennis body insisted that Wilson’s absence was due to “personal reasons.”
Lewis told Wired868 that he does have a view on whether team selection should be influenced by the players’ ability to raise money. But, on legal advise, the TTOC president did not share that view, so as to avoid prejudicing the ongoing legal matter.
The TTTTA, in its press release, suggested that St Louis “self-funded” for Anthony Corbin and himself to compete at the 2017 World Table Tennis Championships in Düsseldorf, Germany—in what was presumably a retort to the player. The local body further suggested that it turned down several offers by local players to pay their way to represent the country.
Despite the TTOC arbitration panel’s ruling, the TTTTA suggested that it will stand by its initial decision until further clarification is provided.
Joseph is due to travel to Colombia as team manager. He also travelled to Australia, earlier this year, to fulfil the same role.
(TTTTA press release)
Due to the economic crisis and the absence of subvention since 2016 there has been a struggle for our teams to attend tournaments. However, teams especially juniors are selected earlier than usual to give parents and guardians more time to gather funding. The Association does sponsorship letters and the parents organise several fundraisers throughout the year.
All teams selected are self-funded sadly, and the economic status of players is not an advantage or disadvantage in selecting a team. The best possible team has always been selected then the next step is the uphill task of attaining sponsorship. Within the last year, there were a few occasions where players who had finances were rejected spots on the national team because of not being our top players.
The three male players and four female players that represented us in Cuba at the CAC Qualifiers in February have been the composition of our national team for the last few years. They were selected from a trial held a few weeks before the team departed.
It was not a case of “picking whoever has finances” similar to when Dexter St Louis self-funded himself also registering his friend Anthony Corbin to play in 2017 World Table Tennis Championships held in Düsseldorf, Germany last May. Corbin hasn’t played locally for years and is no way close to the caliber of our national team.
It was decided by the selection committee at that point in time that our top local players would have qualified us in Cuba and didn’t see it necessary for our foreign based players to come. There were only eight women teams registered which meant an automatic selection once we arrived in Cuba. Whereas, the men’s team was ranked 11th with teams we can beat ranked in front of us. The both teams did their job by qualifying for the CAC Games 2018 in Barranquilla, Colombia.
After getting the information about the amount of spot allocated to us by TTOC for the games we had two meetings with them and they suggested we should host an open trials. This seemed to be a logical decision because we have not had the luxury to see the foreign players compete, for at least two years, against our improving young rest of the squad who plays nationally.
Male Invitations were sent to Aaron Wilson, Yuvraaj Dookram, Curtis Humphreys, Arun Roppnarine, Khaleel Asgarali and Dexter St Louis (the latter two are foreign-based professional players).
The women were: Brittany Joseph, Catherine Spicer, Aleena Edwards, Linda Partap-Boodhan and Rheann Chung (foreign based professional player).
The invitation letter clearly stated: “Failure to indicate you availability by the given date will be interpreted as you being unavailable to represent Trinidad and Tobago at this tournament.”
All local players indicated their availability before the stipulated time.
Therefore, it was decided that the four men who were available for the trials were selected also the four women. Aleena Edwards became unavailable as a player which opened up the spot for Rheann Chung.
Selected team for CAC:
Male: Aaron Wilson, Arun Roopnarine, Yuvraaj Dookram, Curtis Humphreys. (Reeza Burke, Coach)
Female: Rheann Chung, Brittany Joseph, Catherine Spicer, Linda Partap-Boodhan. (Aleena Edwards, Coach)
Manager: Ian Joseph
Note: 1) The Trinidad & Tobago Table Tennis Association (TTTTA) does not have a website since 2016.
2) Nowhere in our selection policy states that players must be informed three months in advance.
Concerning the ruling made by the TTOC’s Panel we had this to say:
- That decision advised is going against the TTTTA’s constitution of a national team Selection Criteria.
- What was flawed, the decision not to include Dexter St. Louis or the Selection criteria used?
- How come it was flawed for the men and not the women which we did the same process, hence that team should be re-selected?
- How are we selecting the committee to select the players and how are they providing their decision to the panel?
As of 2pm on Tuesday afternoon, there was no reply from the panel making it difficult to proceed further.