Home / View Point / Guest Columns / Noble: Correcting Education’s woes; beyond ‘prestige schools’ and ‘standardised examinations’

Noble: Correcting Education’s woes; beyond ‘prestige schools’ and ‘standardised examinations’

“For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple and wrong,” — H L Mencken

Last month, Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley reportedly said ‘tough decisions will have to be made to correct the educational imbalances’, as he anticipated ‘an honest and open discussion’ which would lead to ‘certain recommendations… [which] will be far-reaching with respect to implications for who does what’. 

Photo: Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley (centre) and then Minister of Community Development, Culture and the Arts Dr Nyan Gadsby-Dolly at the opening of a community centre in Bagatelle.
(via OPM)

Several commentators have limited themselves to the SEA examination, ignoring the reality that ‘…persistent educational inequality and inequity are systematically suffered by certain groups while others… enjoy educational advantages over them’. Deosaran (2016).

The inequality starts early and builds cumulatively, as noted in a landmark US study (ed Shonkoff and Phillips, 2000).

Every aspect of early human development (from the brain to the capacity for empathy) begins in the prenatal period and extends to the early childhood years. One’s chances for success depends on several factors, not least of which is the relationship with people who could connect you to opportunities. 

Your chances are influenced by the family into which you were born and where you grow up. Some places, due to the presence of mentors and life examples, give children a really good chance. 

We have to discuss these issues in the light of our single mothers and those who struggle financially. What will we do, especially for those with children under the age of six years?

Photo: Young Matura football fans enjoy some 2015/16 National Super League action at the Matura Recreation Ground.
(Courtesy Nicholas Bhajan/Wired868)

Our educationists speak in general terms, seldom identifying specific demographic groups needing special care and attention. Where are the specialist teams, focused on improving literacy and numeracy as a jump off point for the sciences, assigned to school districts? 

The famed PISA (The OECD Programme for International Student Assessment) score is an ‘average’ of all our students’ performances. Often local commentators have reached for this performance as an indication of how well we do. But being an ‘average’ score, the under-performers rebalance the  over-performers. 

One of the best ways to improve our ranking is to shorten the long ‘tail’ of under-performers. We have to identify potential dropouts and deploy a range of activities.

For some, this may mean individualised attention and for others, a new range of options other than traditional academic fare.

These actions will help to level the playing field, reducing the differences between the ‘prestige’ and other schools—be they at the primary or secondary level—eliminating the rush for acceptance into the ‘prestige’ schools. 

Photo: SAGHS students plant a tree during the Plastic Bag Reduction Campaign.

Parents do not really want a specific school as much as they want a school that would give their children the best chance of success. To achieve this, we have to become more selective in the recruitment of teachers and we have to pay them better. 

At present, there is a splendid opportunity to recruit recent graduates to provide special help to those struggling with online classes. We should also build libraries in all our school districts. Reading skills improve with access to books.

All the nations, leading the PISA tests, have a cohesive, compact society. We do not and therefore need to integrate our educational strategy into an overall national forward-thinking strategy. 

We must have a strong sense of fairness and place value on each and every child.  Children cannot learn if they are unsafe or hungry. The potential for greatness must be developed. 

Data should drive action. Why are the children doing poorly? How do we get resources to them? What is going to make them learn? 

Image: A satirical take on university dropouts.

Education is more than accountability and standardised examinations, it is about putting relationships with the children first so that they come along for the journey. The emphasis has to be on building a fairer, more equitable society through education.

About Noble Philip

Noble Philip
Noble Philip, a retired business executive, is trying to interpret Jesus’ relationships with the poor and rich among us. A Seeker, not a Saint.

Check Also

PAHO: Children face significant Covid risk, but countries must do everything ‘to safely reopen schools’

“[…] With each day that children go without in-person schooling, the higher the likelihood that they …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.