W/Cup addict comments: How Holder’s howler compares with Kohli’s handling of his bowlers

EPL Properties Ltd

Assistant coaches are the wretched of the earth; they may be called assistants but they offer little real help. Roddy Estwick is the assistant coach of the West Indies cricket team.

According to Estwick, the West Indies’ 15-run defeat by Australia in last Friday’s crucial fixture, had “nothing to do with the bowlers.”

It is out of the mouth of coaches and captains, says cricket’s good book, that thou hast perfected praise.

Photo: West Indies captain Jason Holder.
(Copyright Yahoo)

So Current West Indies coach Floyd Reifer declined to blame his skipper, Jason Holder.

“We kind of made some mistakes at key points in the game [but] it happens in cricket.” (my emphasis)

KFC Munch Pack

Former West Indies captain Clive Lloyd concurred.

Suggesting that “they simply did not capitalise on the early dismissals,” he called for the team to “look at the mistakes and rectify them” because “with a better analysis of the situation, they could have won that game.” (my emphasis)


Holder was much more specific when he spoke to the media.

“I thought we were well in the game there at the lunch time stage [but there were] just a few irresponsible shots when we probably just needed to tuck it around a little bit more.”

He goes on to cite Steve Smith’s batting deep and the Aussies bowling really well with the old ball.

“It’s a bit disappointing to be losing a game like that,” he ends, “when we’re in full control of the game but these things happen.”

In his immediate public post-game, he had told Michael Slater that he thought the game had turned when Smith was dropped relatively early in his innings. And, he had added, the batsmen had let themselves and the side down.

Photo: Australia cricketers celebrate the dismissal of West Indies batsman Chris Gayle.

Let us all be very clear: this game was not lost by the batsmen. Sure WI would have liked to see them do better towards the end. But the match was lost when WI failed to capitalise on the early dismissals, allowing Australia to recover from 37 for 4 and then 79 for 5 to post 289.

And Holder is right; these things do happen. But there are reasons why they happen. In this case, the reason is that the captain messed up. Batting, bowling or fielding did not lose that game; captaincy did. And Holder must take full responsibility for it.

Get behind Lloyd’s and Reifer’s indirection; it is the captain who failed to make a proper analysis of the situation. It is he who made the mistake at [a] key point in the game and failed to capitalise on the early dismissals.

The batsmen might still have rescued him. But in that case WI would have won, as one former QRC captain advised me during the Carey/Smith partnership, not because of Holder but in spite of him.

And he would be hard-pressed to explain to prove otherwise.

On a cricket team, format notwithstanding, all 11 players need some grasp of geometry to improve their batting, bowling and fielding; boundary and cover fieldsmen ritually use Pythagoras’ theorem to make sure the ball will not get past them.

Photo: West Indies captain Jason Holder (centre) celebrates a wicket during 2019 Cricket World Cup action against Pakistan.

The captain, however, needs more. And in the short format, mastery of not just geometry but of mathematics is an essential element of the captain’s package. He requires genuine command of algebra, the ability to constantly solve for X. And the shorter the format, the greater the need for algebra. Often, one mistake and you’re a goner; you simply can’t pull it back.

In Sunday’s crucial game, India’s Virat Kohli identified Australia’s as Alex Carey’s dropping of Hardik Pandya off the first ball he received. A Facebook fan identified the West Indies’ as Holder’s pulling both pacemen out of the attack after reducing the Aussies to 37 for 4.

“…any reasonable captain would have at least kept on,” he wrote, “either of the two men who were pressurising the Australians.” 

Who dares disagree?

Holder, I fear, has little grasp of algebra. It’s pure arithmetic. Not so Kohli.

India’s pattern on Sunday resembled the WI’s in the earlier game. Jasprit Bumrah only bowled three overs from the Vauxhall End before Kohli pulled him out of the firing line. And Bhuvneshwar was withdrawn at the Pavilion End after only five overs.

But Australia were 48 without loss after 10 overs whereas Holder’s opening bowlers had claimed four wickets within the first eight.

Photo: India captain Virat Kohli (left) has named fast bowler Jasprit Bumrah as his team’s biggest asset in their 2019 World Cup campaign.

In his second over, first-change Pandya was taken for 19 runs. Kohli kept him on for another three; he conceded just 13.

Find me one example of a West Indian bowler leaking more than ten runs in an over in the first powerplay and I’ll show a game in which Holder either did not play or was off the field at that time.

In a crucial six-over spell in mid-innings, Kohli used five different bowlers. When the main spinners had bowled overs #19 and #20, it began to look like rain might bring DLS into play. Kohli turned temporarily to Bumrah. Neither he in over #21 from the Pavilion End nor Yuzvendra Chahal in #22 from the Vauxhall End could break through.

Time, the algebra said, to try to buy a second wicket. For #23, the skipper called on Kedar Jadhav’s low-arm off-spinners. Yadhav conceded 14. That one over was all he got.

So it’s emphatically NOT a formula. The algebra was against him. It had worked for him in the game against South Africa when he bowled four overs for 16 runs.

As for Bumrah, who must be held in reserve for the death, algebra permitting, of course, he was called up for another two-over spell just before the start of the final powerplay and for over #42 from the Pavilion End. Kohli kept three of his overs in the bank. Same for Bhuvneshwar. The pair claimed four of the last six wickets.

So the formula per se, I daresay, was not the problem; it’s the formulaicness, the lack of flexibility that did Holder and WI in…

Photo: West Indies captain Jason Holder (right) congratulates Australia fast bowler Mitchell Starc after the 2019 Cricket World Cup contest.

I want to speculate wildly at a possible cause.

A man of few words, Holder listened as some of the other captains present at the 23 May media session discussed in hushed tones the 21 May death of former Formula One great Niki Lauda a couple days earlier. He overheard—thought he had heard—Kohli say that one formula is great.

And the way the weather in England looking this week, he mistake mighta done throw enough sand in West Indies 2019 rice to last another four years.

WI and we go find out tomorrow when, if the rain stop, we go get a chance to show England who is boss.

More from Wired868
Dr Shallow and Bassarath elected as CWI president and vice-president

Dr Kishore Shallow and Azim Bassarath have been elected to the posts of president and vice-president respectively, of Cricket West Read more

“Greatest honour of my career”, “Dream come true”—Hope and Powell named WI white-ball captains

Wicketkeeper/batter Shai Hope and batting allrounder Rovman Powell will lead the West Indies cricket team in the One-Day International (ODI) Read more

Lara takes “performance mentor” job to “improve game sense” of Windies players

West Indies cricket legend Brian Lara was unveiled today as the Cricket West Indies’ (CWI) new performance mentor with a Read more

Test cricket for white-ball players, fitness consensus, center wicket practice: the CWI’s 34-point Report on T20 W/Cup exit

“[…] It is not in the best interests of West Indies Cricket that our best players play in every global Read more

Dear Editor: Captaining or coaching WI is an impossible job, because the real “bunglers” stay hidden

“[…] No matter how poorly the [West Indies] teams play, there are no consequences for the regional boards because they Read more

Vaneisa: Sir Wes Hall, why we should care about the grand old man

Biographies, autobiographies and memoirs about Caribbean people unwittingly carry the burden of history. So much has gone unrecorded, and academic Read more

About Earl Best

Earl Best
Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970's. He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.

Check Also

Dr Shallow and Bassarath elected as CWI president and vice-president

Dr Kishore Shallow and Azim Bassarath have been elected to the posts of president and …


  1. Jason is still learning… He is an examplary leader. Tactically might be a bit defensive however he’s working with current resources. That game with all the criticisms he would have been subjected to…now be a little bit wiser. What he has done and has stood out as captain, I might be wrong but I don’t think that the great Brian C. Lara accomplished it as a captain. he ha the unenviable task which he has embraced and as a West Indian am still proud of their achievements as it only augurs well for the future of West Indies cricket.

    • Let’s be clear: I have no problem whatever with Holder as Test captain; he has performed well there and has been getting results.

      My point is that he brings to the ODI arena only the skill-set that accounts for his success in the longest form That is why, realistically, WI’s chances of qualifying in this World Cup are slim to none–and I said so even before the start of the competition.

      But we have have miracles before!

  2. Well said, Captaincy is critical, but what I find unfortunate is that Holder dont even think he was the reason WI lost.. Not even sure if he knew why he changed the bowling attack with four wickets down. This is not road cricket where yuh could just ups and give a man a bowl. Apart from this we cannot use Kholi as a comparison because Dhoni usually does most of the field placements and you always see them together trying to come up with a proper strategy. Not sure of the relationship between Holder and Gayle….

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.