Best revisits BC Lara’s Great GOAT Debate: The Don, Sachin T or me?

“A man of genius,” CLR James says, in writing of Garry Sobers, “is what he is, he cannot be something else and remain what he is.”

There is another West Indian left-hander, born a generation after Sobers on May 2, 1969, to whom James’ encomium applies unadjusted. Superlatives abound in appreciations of the batting of Brian Charles Lara. Unsurprisingly. He alone has achieved the feat of claiming, 25 years ago next week, the record for the highest individual Test innings and then, exactly 15 years ago today, reclaiming it.

“The Michael Jordan of cricket,” former POTUS Barack Obama called him.

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago sport icon Brian Lara gives cricket tips to United States president and sport enthusiast Barack Obama.

In a fulsome tribute in 2015, Australia’s Mike Coward called the Prince of Port-of-Spain ‘majestic’ and ‘one of the game’s immortals’.

“A batsman of incredible beauty,” he added, “instinctive and courageous against fast bowling and daring and guileful against spinners.”

Michael Atherton, who captained England at the Antigua Recreation Ground in 1994, pulls no punches.

“In terms of pure aesthetics and a joy that you wanted to watch at the crease,” he says, “I don’t think there has been a more attractive player than Brian Lara.”

An interviewer for Australia’s Back Page TV feature says that Lara is ‘one of the greatest players to ever play the game’.

Espncricinfo dubs the Santa Cruz-born left-hander “the most charismatic cricketer of the modern era.” But they say that epithet must be shared with Australia’s Shane Warne. And they do not pronounce on the question of where he ranks in the great GOAT stakes.

As is his wont, former England all-rounder Ian Botham tackles that issue frontally, declaring BCL to be ‘one of the greatest batsmen of all time’.

Photo: England players give West Indies captain Brian Lara a honour guard as he walks to the crease during the Super-Eight ICC World Cup cricket match at the Kensington Oval in Bridgetown, Barbados on 21 April 2007.
Lara is playing his last international cricket match.
(Copyright AFP 2017/Adrian Dennis)

But for many West Indians, that eight-word assessment, albeit both honest and accurate, is too long; six words are enough: the greatest batsman of all time?

Others the world over demur; they take issue with the question mark. Still others study the stats and reach a conclusion; no need to look beyond the figures. A Test batting average of 99.94 in 80 innings, after all, is an immensely powerful argument—strengthened, of course, by no fewer than 12 Test scores over 200. They agree wholeheartedly with espncricinfo that Australia’s Donald Bradman ‘transcends the game he graced’.

For them, there is no argument. Bradman is, they affirm, “Unquestionably the greatest batsman in the game, arguably the greatest cricketer ever, and one of the finest sportsmen of all time, (…) so far ahead of the competition as to render comparisons meaningless…”


Like West Indians, Indians beg to differ. For them as well, there is no argument. How does one argue with a Test aggregate of 15,921 runs, including 51 centuries and 68 half-centuries? And there is also the small matter of 100 first-class hundreds plus 18,426 ODI runs, with a double-century thrown in for good measure.

By comparison, Lara’s 11,953 Test runs with their paltry 34 centuries and 48 half-centuries look decidedly ordinary—even if you add the 10,000-plus runs he plundered in ODIs.

Therefore, the greatest batsman of all time is indisputably Sachin Ramesh Tendulkar of India.

There is, however, a reason why statistics, lies and damn lies are bedfellows; stats never tell the whole story. Greatness lies, the connoisseurs know, not simply in the accumulation of impressive numbers but also in compiling them in a way that almost carves your name across national borders into cricket’s collective unconscious.

Photo: Former cricket legends Brian Lara (right) and Sachin Tendulkar.
(Copyright AFP 2014/Alessandro Abbonizio)

In Beyond a boundary, James reminds us of William Hazlitt’s definition: “Greatness is great power, producing great effects. It is not enough that a man has great power in himself, he must show it to all the world in a manner that cannot be hid or gainsaid.”

To all those gathered in the ARG on those three memorable April days 25 years ago, there was no hiding or gainsaying the great power of the lissome Lara. Lived experience does not lie.

To see him, at almost 25, in full, majestic flow for 766 minutes, facing 538 balls and scoring 375 runs with 45 fours but not a single six is to be on cricket’s Cloud Nine. Or even higher, in Seventh Heaven. Nothing can erase that memory, nothing, that is, except seeing Lara, at almost 35, in full, majestic flow for 778 minutes, facing 582 balls, scoring 43 fours and four sixes and getting unbeaten to a chanceless 400 runs.

But that double ascent is clearly neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition. Hazlitt adds—although James does not remind us—that “No man is truly great who is great only in his lifetime. The test of greatness is the page of history.”

What James makes clear throughout Boundary but explicitly in ‘What is art?’, is the importance of the eye in arriving at judicious judgements of cricketing talent.

Cricket, he writes, “cannot express the emotions of an age on the nature of the last judgement or the wiping out of a population by bombing. It must repeat. But what it repeats is the original stuff out of which everything visually or otherwise artistic is quarried.”

Photo: Former West Indies batsman Brian Lara flicks to the boundary as Sri Lankan wicketkeeper Kumar Sangakkara looks on.
(Copyright AFP 2014/Sena Vidanagama)

It follows that the biases of the lived experience have to be balanced against the statistical and other arguments in favour of those we have not actually seen.

So it is no accident that the names of South Africa’s Barry Richards, Pakistan’s Javed Miandad, England’s Len Hutton, Jack Hobbs and WG Grace will simply not drop out of the Great GOAT Debate. Bradman’s pre-eminence goes undisputed the world over as is, for the most part, Tendulkar’s in the populous sub-continent. But Lara’s heroics notwithstanding, West Indians of the 21st Century will have to contend with the claims of George Headley and Frank Worrell and Garry Sobers and Viv Richards.

Not for me the large question. I feel competent merely to state, as we celebrate an important anniversary, where I stand on the Lara versus Tendulkar issue and where I think Lara stands on it.

Let me begin, then, with what a highly regarded British commentator has said of the Indian icon.

“Sachin has made batting look easier than any man I have ever watched,” remarks Henry Blofeld. “He is a joy to watch; he doesn’t hit the ball, he caresses it.”

Permit me to add here just a little of what the two contenders have said of each other. According to Coward, Lara has commented that, as a batsman, Tendulkar was the true genius and that he (Lara) was only a mortal. Princely politeness, methinks. Noblesse oblige.

Tendulkar says he envies Lara’s ‘fantastic flair’ whereas the Prince lauds the Little Master as ‘a complete batsman’.

Photo: World cricket legends Sachin Tendulkar (left) and Brian Lara.

And I want to end for today with a rare candid view from a former Indian captain on which of ‘the two greatest batsmen of our generation’ he deems to be the better player.

“I consider [Tendulkar] to be a little bit ahead of Brian,” Sourav Ganguly told a TV interviewer just after the Indian star’s retirement in 2013, “but that’s only because we played for the same team.”

Cricketers often play off the back foot. Coming from that source, however, that is clearly what we may call a substantial back-handed compliment.

More from Wired868
Vaneisa: Spirits of the game; West Indies’ friendly ghosts at the Gabba

“In our eras of greatness, when West Indies took the field, ghostly presences walked with the players, representing commitment to Read more

“He exemplifies spirit of West Indies cricket!” Shamar gets CWI  retainer contract

West Indies fast bowler Shamar Joseph today received the latest reward for his sensational test debut in Australia, as he Read more

Orin: “Extraordinary to watch!” Shamar’s fairytale journey

“[…] After a nearly sleepless night, Shamar Joseph lay on his bed till 11am. The decision to get on the Read more

Dear Editor: Test cricket at its platinum best! WI must believe!

“[…] I always had faith in the West Indies, and we turned up the heat just like the good old Read more

Dear Editor: Windies, wake up! Why do we turn up against England and not Australia?!

“[…] Impatience was our downfall… Kraigg Brathwaite and Tagenarine Chanderpaul have got to have a long hard look at themselves Read more

Early Bird: How England plan to use Pollard to get back on white ball track

The story about Kieron Pollard’s recently signed consultancy contract has not got a lot of traction in the media. But Read more

About Earl Best

Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970's. He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.

Check Also

Vaneisa: Spirits of the game; West Indies’ friendly ghosts at the Gabba

“In our eras of greatness, when West Indies took the field, ghostly presences walked with …


  1. I remember him as a little 18 yr old vs Curtley Ambrose and d crew in Guaracara PK….. he had Curtley scratching his head lol

  2. Brian Lara is d greatest .Messi and Ronaldo tie.

  3. It was achieved on a Monday while the lead up to the 375 was in Sunday while TT was in a great CFU final at the Oval Vs. Martinique.
    As Principal , I arranged for a TV to be in the school for our students to be able to experience the great moment which , I am sure, they appreciated. One fellow principal went to a supervisor to complain and was told that the supervisor expected all principals to do what I had done!!!!!!!!
    Later on Lara’s 400 and a reception in San Fernando , I was honoured to have him stop at my school, Grant Memorial Pres, School, to meet me.
    By the way he played For our country, at age Under 14, before being a rep of the country at cricket!!!!

  4. “It have a little fella in Trinidad, they cyar out him at all.”, – first reference and quote from the ole badjohn Leonard Waithe in the Friday night brandy lime in the Mangrove pan yard, Notting Hill, London, circa 1988.

  5. Brian was balletic. Oh the footwork… either decisively forward, or decisively back. No half stride. Light on his feet. The high backlift, the exaggerated crouch. The only batsman Ive seen pierce a set field as consistently — find the gap — is Virat Kohli.

    if the selectors hadn’t been so conservative, they’d have fast tracked him into the test team after destroying England At Guaracara Park in 1989. And he’d probably be 1000 test runs better off.

    My GOAT. Fight me.

  6. Only Sobers can be compared to Lara,for reference see Sobers vs Lillee and Thompson

  7. Cricket is no longer played at Antigua Recreational Ground – no more memories.

  8. The most talented Batsman I have ever seen, the BC fellah was just class and a blessing to see.

  9. A wonderful memory to relive Cricket’s 0ccasions for the lovers of the great game
    Thanks for a lifetime memory Brian.Alvin

    • What many of these commentators miss about greatness is that consistency and technique is only part of the equation. What none of them every talk about is on their best days what happens.

      I dare say that Lara on his is very best days of 153 n.o., 277, 375 and 213 was better than Tendulkar, Pointing, and arguably Bradman (with the caveat that it was a completely different game than now).

  10. Brian has a record not many realise, that is to break the world record twice…. cheers

    • Usain Bolt has done that too. But then deeper into athletics Sergei Bubka has broken the world record 35 times, breaking his own record 14 times. There are probably many more athletics achievements, particularly with the six minutes reduced from the marathon in the last 30 years.

  11. Lara at his best is better than everyone there ever was or ever will be…but you can’t deny Bradman’s consistency or Tendulkar’s ability to maintain his immaculate standards over so long a career.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.