Dear Editor: Don’t blame WI players for franchise cricket clash; it’s ICC’s fault!


“[…] The issue with players from the West Indies and any non-Big 3 cricket nation (India, Australia and England) having to choose between international and T20 league duty is not a CWI/PCB/NZC/SLC/CSA/ACB/ problem. It is a failure of the ICC’s international calendar fixtures!

“Fifa was able to find a system for global football where club and international fixtures do not clash. The ICC has not. So why are we blaming the players? […]”

The following Letter to the Editor, which responds to commentator Joseph ‘Reds’ Perreira’s unhappiness about players skipping West Indies tours for franchise cricket, was submitted to Wired868 by regional sport journalist Colin Benjamin:

West Indies cricket star Nicholas Pooran blows a kiss to his IPL fans.

Sir Reds, like any cricket legend, has earned the right to say anything on West Indies cricket because of who he is. But as 2025 dawns upon us, it’s a big flaw in the ecosystem of Caribbean cricket discussions that the ultimate straw man argument of attacking players on commitment still exists.

Certain realities need to accepted by everyone:

The issue with players from the West Indies and any non-Big 3 cricket nation (India, Australia and England) having to choose between international and T20 league duty is not a CWI/PCB/NZC/SLC/CSA/ACB/ problem. It is a failure of the ICC’s international calendar fixtures!

West Indies pacer Alzarri Joseph makes a point.

Fifa was able to find a system for global football where club and international fixtures do not clash. The ICC has not. So why are we blaming the players?

The myth that only the West Indies have this problem has been debunked long ago. There are countless examples globally, since the IPL started in 2008.

Just take as example the current World Test Cricket finalist, South Africa, who sent a B team to New Zealand last year and lost while West Indies won that test in Australia.

The NOC (No Objection Certificate) system—which gives cricket boards the right to determine if a player can compete overseas in a franchise competition—needs to be scrapped globally as it is the ultimate restraint of trade mechanism.

West Indies batsman Shimron Hetmyer.
Photo: CWI Media

CWI (Cricket West Indies) under no circumstances should be allowed or encouraged to be like Afghanistan or, most notoriously, the PCB (Pakistan Cricket Board), which ridiculously hauls players from T20 leagues for international duty

CWI, to its credit, already followed England and Australia in offering multi-year contracts—yet players like Sherfane Rutherford, Nicholas Pooran, Shimron Hetmyer, and Kyle Mayers rejected them totally.

So, the issue remains that CWI can’t pay players at Big 3 levels. And it comes full circle back to my first point: the ICC must fix its global calendar!

More from Wired868
1975 CWC: Julien swings Windies past outclassed Sri Lankans

(Part 37.) West Indies too professional. With 14 days to go to the 50th anniversary of the West Indies victory Read more

Dear Editor: WI got bowling tactics wrong in ODIs; give Alzarri the new ball!

“[…] The West Indies tacticians, in their wisdom, chose to give the new ball to Matthew Forde to accompany Jayden Read more

1975 CWC: Windies omit Greenidge for five bowlers, in opener against Sri Lanka

(Part 36.) Down to business. After all that build-up, with historical context, player profiles and a few other bits and Read more

Hosein, Goolie and Chase affected by UK visa issue; CWI blames “administrative challenges”

Veteran spinner Akeal Hosein and rookie batsman Jyd Goolie both look set to miss out on West Indies’ upcoming T20 Read more

1975 CWC: From Ollivierre to Sobers—Fazeer reviews WI’s first 12 England visits

(Part 35.) No unlucky 13. Clive Lloyd’s 1975 Cricket World Cup squad marked the first time that a West Indies Read more

1975 CWC: Does the Caribbean care about Windies history? Does the CWI?!

(Part 34.) Because we forgot. As this 50th anniversary series approaches the actual days of competition at the 1975 World Read more

Check Also

1975 CWC: Julien swings Windies past outclassed Sri Lankans

(Part 37.) West Indies too professional. With 14 days to go to the 50th anniversary …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.