Dear editor: ‘Cockroaches’ slur should be hate crime, penalised by jail—like in UK and Dominica

“[…] The word ‘cockroaches’ was used by both the Nazis and those behind the genocide in Rwanda in 1999.

“[…] Such language used by Ms Ramsaran cannot fall ‘under the guise of freedom of expression’. It feeds a vicious cycle of unrestrained intolerance and incitement to hatred by race…”

The following Letter to the Editor on ex-Ramsaran’s Dairy Products employee Naila Ramsaran’s description of PNM supporters as ‘cockroaches’ was submitted to Wired868 by Ula Nathai-Lutchman, an international criminal lawyer in the UK:

Photo: A mass grave site in Rwanda for Hutus killed during the 1999 genocide.

Ms Naila Ramsaran’s use of the dehumanising word ‘cockroaches’ to describe PNM supporters is reminiscent of anti-Semitic Nazi propaganda.

The word ‘cockroaches’ was used by both the Nazis and those behind the genocide in Rwanda in 1999. The Nazi media described people their masters wanted to eliminate as cockroaches.

The Rwanda radio station RTML incited Hutus against the Tutsi minority, repeatedly describing the latter as ‘cockroaches’—resulting in their genocidal mass slaughter of about one million over the course of 100 days in 1994.

Such language used by Ms Ramsaran cannot fall ‘under the guise of freedom of expression’. It feeds a vicious cycle of unrestrained intolerance and incitement to hatred by race.

It is time for the first piece of major legislation to respect the inviolable dignity of the human person and by extension curbing incitement to hatred by race. I urge the government to take urgent steps to legislate to eliminate this increasingly racial hatred trajectory.

Photo: A racially tinged Facebook post by Naila Ramsaran on 11 August 2020.

In the neighbouring Commonwealth of Dominica for example, it is an offence to incite racial hatred when someone says or does something which is threatening, abusive or insulting on grounds of colour, race or ethnic or national origins and the person either intends to stir up racial hatred or makes it likely that racial hatred will be stirred up (The Nationality and Racial Offences Act, section 6). The offence carries a prison sentence.

Similarly, in the UK, any use of derogatory language towards ethnicity, race carries a penalty of imprisonment.

Furthermore, it is extraordinary and deeply shameful to see the nasty underbelly of racism and such open race-baiting that characterised the recent election.

For general election candidates and supporters, be brave enough to speak out but be aware of the dangers which lurk in the depths of your vocabulary.

History has shown us time and time again where talk of cockroaches can lead and the dangers of demonising ethnic groups by dehumanisation—from the millions of people killed during Nazi persecution and in subsequent genocides in Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia, and Darfur.

Photo: Late Nazi leader, Adolf Hitler, often referred to Jews as ‘rats’.
More from Wired868
St Louis: PNM’s post-election confession betrays T&T’s cyclical governance issues

When in government, the People’s National Movement (PNM) speaks with the certainty of authority—decisions are made, policies defended, and dissent Read more

Devaluation: the good, the bad and the public debt—why T&T needs careful analysis, not noise

“[…] Basic economic theory does not always manifest in practice—in fact, it rarely does. To understand if or by how Read more

Dear Editor: Indarsingh’s appointment as Industrial Court judge should spark national concern

“[…] The Industrial Court wields quasi-constitutional powers in employment matters. It issues binding decisions affecting the rights of workers, unions, and employers. Read more

Dear Editor: It’s disturbing that PM cheers on US claim of extrajudicial killing

“[…] The fact that our Prime Minister would openly applaud extrajudicial killings as a solution to drug trafficking was troubling to Read more

Dear Editor: Jury duty in T&T feels like the apex of indignity

“[…] The morning began with a scene of casual dehumanisation. We were herded like livestock into the entrance of the Read more

Dear Editor: T&T’s reckless unilateral stance on US-Venezuela standoff is a betrayal of Caricom

“[…] The Government’s position, as expounded by the Prime Minister and the Foreign Affairs Minister, is not neutrality by any Read more

Check Also

Dear Editor: Armed police officers is not best answer to curb school violence

“[…] Some teachers have already expressed support for a police presence, noting that officers are …

3 comments

  1. Who was Gary Griffith referring to when he used the term cockroaches?

    • Not the PNM, not politicians, not parliamentarians, the 1%, not the people in Westmoorings, not the People’s Partnership.

      And since cockroach eh have no right before fowl, as the old people say, it cyar be the people who does flock to the popular chicken outlets neither.

      Poor me. I try but I give up.

  2. To me that entire comment about putting contraceptives in water and cockroaches show she might as well believe in eugenics!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.