Home / Volley / Global Football / Retired FIFA referee: T&T should have had a penalty and Costa Rica deserved a red card

Retired FIFA referee: T&T should have had a penalty and Costa Rica deserved a red card

“This very serious offence should, with no doubt, have resulted in a penalty being awarded to the Trinidad and Tobago team and the offending Costa Rica player being shown the red card in keeping with the Laws of the game: Law 12 – ‘Denying a goal or an obvious goalscoring opportunity’.”

Retired FIFA referee and FIFA referees instructor Osmond Downer gives his view on a controversial tug on Trinidad and Tobago forward Jamille Boatswain in the Costa Rica penalty area, during Russia 2018 World Cup qualifying action on 13 June 2017. Costa Rica won 2-1:

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago head coach Dennis Lawrence (centre) exchanges words with the match officials after his team’s 2-1 World Cup qualifying loss against Costa Rica at the National Stadium in San José on 13 June 2017.
(Courtesy Allan V Crane/CA Images/Wired868)

I have received several phone calls during the course of this morning for my opinion concerning an incident that occurred during a very crucial time in the World Cup qualifying game between Costa Rica and Trinidad and Tobago, which was played in San José last night.

This is related to a moment in the 51st minute when Costa Rica led 2-1 but, with Trinidad and Tobago’s speedy front line constantly penetrating the opposing defence, goals looked imminent.

Here was the incident: Trinidad and Tobago attacker Jamille Boatswain, who was approaching with speed from just outside the penalty area in the middle of the field, got past Costa Rica defender Michael Umaña with a clear run towards goal.

Boatswain was followed by Umaña into the penalty area and, in a last ditch effort, the defender grabbed on to his shirt for the whole world to see and pulled him back, which resulted in the forward falling to the ground with the obvious goal scoring opportunity being prevented.

This very serious offence should, with no doubt, have resulted in a penalty being awarded to the Trinidad and Tobago team AND the offending Costa Rica player being shown the red card in keeping with the Laws of the game: Law 12 – “Denying a goal or an obvious goalscoring opportunity.”

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago forward Jamille Boatswain (left) is hauled back by Costa Rica defender Michael Umaña during 2018 World Cup qualifying action at the National Stadium in San José on 13 June 2017.
Costa Rica won 2-1.
(Courtesy Allan V Crane/CA Images/Wired868)

This incident fulfils all the criteria for the offence of “denying an obvious goal scoring opportunity” with the issuing of a red card:

  1. The offence was holding an opponent in the penalty area;
  2. The attacker was moving directly towards the goal;
  3. The distance from the goal was such that in a second or two the attacker would have been in an excellent position to score a goal;
  4. There were no defenders in a position to stop the attempt at the goal—the attacker had already beaten the defender and was then in front of him heading towards the goal;
  5. The attacker was in full control of the ball within playing distance of the ball.

The offence was clear and blatant for the whole world to see. Perhaps referee Yardel Martinez was in a poor position behind the play and not in a proper angle to clearly see the offence—but surely the referee’s assistant was able to see it and should have signalled Martinez about the offence and indicated a penalty and a red card.

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago head coach Dennis Lawrence (right) appeals to the referee’s assistant during 2018 World Cup qualifying action against Costa Rica at the National Stadium in San José on 13 June 2017.
(Courtesy Allan V Crane/CA Images/Wired868)

Of course a penalty and a red card at that stage would have made a world of difference to the result of the game.

In my experience as a FIFA referee and  referee assessor, I have always found the atmosphere in a World Cup game in Costa Rica to be quite intimidating and perhaps the Cuban officials may not have been experienced enough to handle the situation.

Of course—all the same—there are no excuses for the serious defence lapses by the Trinidad and Tobago team that resulted in the two Costa Rica goals.

About Letters to the Editor

Letters to the Editor
Want to share your thoughts with Wired868? Email us at editor@wired868.com. Please keep your blog between 300 to 800 words and be sure to read it over first for typos and punctuation.

Check Also

Stand-off! TTSL say they paid referees in advance; Downer: “We had no contract”

Trinidad and Tobago Football Association (TTFA) Referees’ Committee Board member Osmond Downer is denying that …

25 comments

  1. Peter wait, Peter wait….Cuba going in de fire too!! (Right next to JA)….dey morda!!!

  2. “You certainly can’t blame the Trinidad & Tobago players and coaching staff if they believe that the team’s record in the final round of CONCACAF qualifying should be better than what the standings indicate.

    The Soca Warriors sit last in the six-team table with a 1W-0D-5L record. Head coach Dennis Lawrence has been in charge for the last four games – a win over Panama, a two-goal loss to the United States and single-goal setbacks to Mexico and Costa Rica.

    It is clear that T&T can compete at this level, but it has been challenged offensively, netting in only three of six Hexagonal matches for a total of three goals.”

    http://www.concacaf.com/article/tt-ready-to-persevere-for-world-cup-goal?utm_content=sf89039729&utm_medium=spredfast&utm_source=twitter&utm_campaign=CONCACAF&sf89039729=1

  3. This is the second time this happen , the Jamaicans officials did the same bad decisions with us against Mexico. They should band those officials.

  4. It makes all the difference in any sport and the referees are left with no choice but to check themselves.

  5. That WAS a blatant foul..what is WRONG with these referees/linesmen??

  6. This is the same downer who was principal of gustine and break all them.rules lmfao

  7. Doesn’t matter now nah…cause that ain’t gonna change the outcome or give us any points. On towards the next match and with that performance from the boys last night, things looking up. 4 remaining games…12 points up for grabs. The dream is still alive Warriors.

  8. Here we go again…Last time in Trinidad we had a goal disallowed and that cost us the match..Now we did not get a penalty and…….???????

  9. Coulda shoulder woulda didn’t. I swear they were out to get us.

  10. What does he have to say about yesterday’s ‘goal or no goal’ thread though? Lol

  11. Sorry but the players should have been up in the refs’ faces. They NEED to appeal everything to remind these refs that the home team or the traditionally stronger team should not always get the benefit of the doubt. The players don’t appeal enough and we (fans) certainly don’t appeal enough at the HCS. We’re way too timid when it comes to football.

  12. Earl Best

    Mic dropped!