Dear Editor: Can Shallow and Sammy take WI cricket forward? Then why are they still there?!

“[…] Is this just another day in the office? Do you guys not have standards—pride in yourselves, and pride in West Indies cricket?

“As a West Indian, I will NEVER forget that score…”

The following Letter to the Editor, in the wake of West Indies being bowled out for 27 runs in the third Test against Australia, was submitted to Wired868 by Choy Aping from Trinidad:

Captain Roston Chase (right) was one of seven West Indies batsmen dismissed for duck in the third innings of the third Test against Australia, as the hosts finished all out for 27 runs at Sabina Park in Kingston on 14 July 2025.
Photo: AFP/ Getty Images.

Dr Kishore Nalin Shallow (Cricket West Indies president) and Daren Sammy (West Indies coach), you all have presided over this complete embarrassment of West Indies Cricket: the lowest Test score in our history—20 runs fewer than our previous all-time low of 47—and the second lowest total in Test cricket history.

What is motivating y’all to stay in y’all jobs??

Why, 24 hours later, haven’t we seen or heard either of you all throwing in the towel? And neither Floyd Reifer (assistant coach, batting) and Roston Chase (team captain)?

CWI president Dr Kishore Shallow (left) and vice-president Azim Bassarath.
(via CWI Media.)

Is this just another day in the office? Do you guys not have standards—pride in yourselves, and pride in West Indies cricket?

As a West Indian, I will NEVER forget that score. (As a matter of fact, I am still aggrieved by being 47 all out against England!)

For the rest of our life, these embarrassments will live with West Indians.

Why have none of you guys thrown in the towel yet?? Do you want or expecting the board to sack you guys so you can be compensated for causing us this humiliation?? Are there not honor in men anymore??

Australia players Travis Head (second from right) and Pat Cummins (far right) see off the West Indies tailenders to seal the third Test on the third day of play at Sabina Park in Kingston, Jamaica on 14 July 2025.
Photo: Randy Brooks/ AFP.

Are we all going to just sit by and act like nothing happened, and just turn up for work tomorrow?

Are y’all really gonna drag the flag through all that mud, bai??

With standards like this, the refusal of the powers that be to resign shows that we are being led by persons who can sit below the white line on the road.

West Indies head coach Daren Sammy (centre, foreground) speaks to his team during the Cricket World Cup Qualifying tournament in Harare, Zimbabwe.
(Copyright ICC/ Getty.)

Do you really still think you are the ones who can take West Indies cricket forward?!

More from Wired868
Dear Editor: West Indies Cricket is dead—even with Shai in squad, this is Hopeless

“[…] Being humiliated is nothing new to West Indians born mid-1980s and later. But this 27 all out feels different—this Read more

Dear Editor: Why not rechristen the ‘Soca Warriors’ as ‘Feteballers’?

“[…] Nobody could force Selwyn Melville; it is his intellectual property. The game is bigger than everybody, so let’s just Read more

Dear Editor: You could pick who you want as coach and captain—WI problems run deep

“[…] You could pick who you want at this point in time. You could pick whatever coach, he could come Read more

‘Progress rarely straightforward’; CWI call ‘emergency meeting’ after WI bowled out for 27

“[…] Progress is rarely straightforward… We have already seen encouraging signs, particularly with the ball… Now is the time to Read more

Wiaan who? Joy and concern in West Indies after South African captain’s Lara decision

Cricket connoisseurs had little doubt. If, in the last 15 years,  anybody was going to break Brian Lara’s 400 not Read more

Dear Editor: How to build fitter, smarter and more resilient athletes

“[…] One of the most common causes of injury in the preseason is the sudden increase in training intensity. Coaches Read more

Check Also

Dear Editor: West Indies Cricket is dead—even with Shai in squad, this is Hopeless

“[…] Being humiliated is nothing new to West Indians born mid-1980s and later. But this …

One comment

  1. I agree that heads should roll. I also think though that it goes way beyond the question of who can/should/could take West Indies cricket forward. The situation is dire enough at this time to suggest a total overhaul/revamp/reconstruction (whichever is more appropriate) of our entire (men/women) cricketing infrastructure. Whatever currently exist isn’t providing the outcomes that fans desire and therefore some serious questions need to be asked and meaningful solutions needed at this point.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.