Daly Bread: Dear Kamla, 2025—can we shift from “blame and shame” to empathetic governance?

Dear Kamla,

Fifteen years ago, at the time of your first election as prime minister of Trinidad and Tobago (PM), I greeted you in a column published on 13 June 2010, in which I explained why I may take the liberty of addressing you in familiar terms.

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar.
Photo: Sunil Lalla.

Let me begin on this second occasion of your election as prime minister by unreservedly congratulating you and the United National Congress (UNC).

My 23 years of service as a weekly columnist in this newspaper provides a ready historical perspective from which to greet you, and one that is enhanced by the footnotes to my columns that are contained in the two volumes of The Daly Commentaries.

In my column last week, I did not intend to be short on congratulations. Perhaps you and many others would understand why it was important to nail down the responsibility of former prime minister Dr Keith Rowley for the disastrous performance of the People’s National Movement (PNM), the UNC’s rival, in the 2025 General Elections.

Then Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley (right) and his successor Stuart Young.
Photo: OPM.

Ironically, in my column of June 2010, I had suggested when Rowley became leader of the PNM that he “formally commit the PNM to the eradication of the use of contempt, personal attack and bombastic spectacle as tools of political speech”.

It is for that reason that, while expressly welcoming you back as prime minister last week, I chose to highlight my gratitude that you struck several conciliatory notes in your remarks immediately after you were sworn in.

The UNC and PNM remain essentially tribally-based parties that can collect cross-over voters from time to time, particularly when things are going exceptionally badly for us.

Supporters at a UNC meeting in Moruga/ Tableland during the 2025 General Election.
Photo: UNC.

If you maintain your conciliatory stance, it will give the UNC prospects of becoming a broader-based national party because people are hurting and might put aside visceral feelings, once they receive the empathy that you have promised.

In my column of June 2010, I also thanked you for your conduct at that time, which brought some “restoration of civility in the conduct of public affairs”.

Unfortunately, it already appears that you will have your work cut out to restrain members of your government from falling immediately back into the old blame and shame game, as typified by their theatrical initiation last week of a back and forth about the alleged poor state of Whitehall and the prime minister’s official residence.

Minister of Energy and Entergy Industries Dr Roodal Moonilal (left) and Minister of Public Utilities and Minister in the Office of the Prime Minister Barry Padarath during the 2025 General Election campaign.
Photo: UNC.

Perhaps they were releasing a smokescreen for something else.

I am growing weary of sometimes being a seer man. But without a fundamental increase in accountability, instead of “blame and shame”, I am not optimistic that things will improve over the next six months—the initial time frame within which you, Kamla, promised that we “will live in a safer and happier Trinidad and Tobago”.

Moreover, in another column published on 5 December 2010, entitled Only Six Months, I was compelled after completion of six months in your first term to express concern that we were going “to bump along the same old rutted roads”—after six months of indecision and focus on replacing state enterprise board members culminated in a public quarrel, which emanated from within your government, over a Caribbean Airlines aircraft acquisition decision.

UNC Senator Anil Roberts whips up supporters during their 2025 General Election campaign.
(via UNC.)

Can we please avoid replacing boorish sets of directors with other sets equally “udecottish” in manner?

Whether the UNC won by default because the PNM vote plummeted by 102,000, or because you regained some of our trust, or a mixture of both, do not falter dear Kamla in proceeding promptly, but empathetically, with the measures needed to curb violent crime and to relieve the distress of those socio-economic groups that the Rowley-led PNM deserted.

Our future peace and stability depend on such an approach.

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar.
Photo: UNC.

Meanwhile, Pennelope “Penny” Beckles, PNM MP for Arima, was sworn in last week as leader of the Opposition. She too struck a conciliatory tone but was also immediately let down when defeated MP for San Fernando West, Faris Al Rawi, lost it outside President’s House and gave a six-month political forecast, which included “terror, torture and persecution”.

Let’s be clear that nothing will change for the better and there is no chance of peace in Trinidad and Tobago, if we do not take hatred of opponents out of our politics.

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: Are Padarath and Kamla in sync? And what to make of PNM Changemakers?

Since her return from Opposition to the office of prime minister, Kamla Persad-Bissessar (Kamla) has been putting great emphasis on Read more

Noble: The Testy Mrs Kamla Persad-Bissessar—and the tale of the Penal-Debe Campus

Over the past few weeks, Kitchener’s 1961 calypso Take yuh meat out of meh rice kept ringing in my ears. Read more

Dear Editor: The high social cost of abandoning community programmes when gov’ts change

“[…] Governments come and go, and with them their pet projects, regardless of whether those initiatives were making a difference. Read more

Daly Bread: Slipping self-restraint—can our gov’ts go beyond finger pointing?

Amanda Gorman, aged 27, is a poet, writer and activist.  She was the first US national youth poet laureate.  She Read more

A bacchanal foretold: Has new Govt worsened CoP crisis?

“[…] If my contract has ended, how can I be sent on any binding vacation leave that extends beyond the Read more

Daly Bread: Change or exchange? Gov’t must address CJ, SEA, panyard model and economic diversification

Our changes of government frequently receive a verdict of “no change only exchange”. The current apparent dead end in the Read more

Check Also

Daly Bread: Are Padarath and Kamla in sync? And what to make of PNM Changemakers?

Since her return from Opposition to the office of prime minister, Kamla Persad-Bissessar (Kamla) has …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.