Noble: Cutting down our youth in their bloom; the murderous Fyzabad four won’t be the last

The killing of the four Fyzabad youths narrated on the soundtrack of the sad stories of their parents is depressing. These young criminals were in their early 20s.

But while we scratch our collective heads, we should recall that these are not the first children involved in murders. In 1993, Prisons Commissioner Michael Hercules was shot in the chest three times when he refused to hand over the keys to his car to two masked shooters. Hercules killed the 21-year-old bandit, but the 19-year-old survived.

Photo: A young man kisses a high powered weapon.

The very next year, Chuck Attin was 15 years old when together with an accomplice, he killed two women in Westmoorings.

According to newspaper reports, 8,000 persons, including the then Prime Minister, attended Hercules’ funeral. On both occasions, there were loud cries for the death penalty.

But 29 years after, in 2022, the killings are multiplying, and the age of the offenders remains shockingly low. Our collective voices have turned to mourn rather than anger. Frustration is rife. Why do we continue to lose our young men as victims and perpetrators of crime? Why is nothing changing?

Since the infamous Parliamentary spat between Dr Morgan Job and Dr Keith Rowley about the political ability to handle crime, we have become more partisan and unable to deal with the roots of crime. We keep looking for a Messiah. At least Dr Job fingered poor schooling as a contributory factor.  

Photo: A tense scene in a Trinidad and Tobago school.

The gun is now the weapon of choice. Before 2000, less than a third of the murders were gun-related. By 2006, it had more than doubled (74%)—comparable to our Latin American neighbours. More than half (59%) of the victims of fatal firearm assaults were males aged 15 – 34 years.

A UK longitudinal study running over 40 years (Farrington, 2001) supports that a life of crime starts at 14 (when the parents lose influence) and ends around 23 (when romantic interests emerge). These times of maximum acceleration and deceleration in prevalence draw attention to periods in male lives when significant life changes may be occurring that influence offending.

The study explains why the Fyzabad four would be on the same mission. No different from what obtains in Laventille or elsewhere.

“[…] Co-offenders tended to be similar in age, gender and race […] and lived close to their addresses and the locations of the offences…”

Photo: A young man shows off his firearm.

Significantly, it described the issue of older boys leading younger ones into crime: a pattern evident locally.

“[…] About one-third of the most persistent offenders continually offended with less criminally experienced co-offenders, and hence appeared to be repeatedly recruiting others into a life of crime…”

We often read in the local papers about the failure of the single mother in raising sons. This perspective does not consider the household structures applicable here where other relatives pitch in to discipline and raise children. The longitudinal study posits that spousal conflict significantly influences juvenile delinquency. The quarrels and violence are disruptive to child nurturing. 

This viewpoint has been supported in personal interviews I have done in the nation’s prisons. The idea of “staying for the children’s sake” and sacrificing the children for the money a stepfather brings is very harmful.

Often the young men learn violence as a way of solving problems or find themselves being put out of their homes “for peace sake”. This removal is complicated in violent neighbourhoods since everyone is seen as a threat.

Photo: An inmate at a juvenile detention centre.
(Copyright India Opines)

Professor Selwyn Ryan’s Task Force (2013) delivered a masterful dissertation on crime and young people. Prophetically, it explained the story of one of the Fyzabad youths: “the educational and financial success achieved by the parents (who sacrificed tremendously) of these Indo-Trinbagonian youth had created a generation of overly indulged young people.”

The report also estimated that only 10% to 20% of Laventille posed a crime problem. Crime is everywhere. Several young incarcerated men have described the initial ‘thrill’ of holding a gun. 

With little regard for the recommendations of the Ryan report, the Government turbo-charged the LifeSport programme. In May 2014, an Express exclusive revealed that when the latter programme began in 2012, it was allocated TT$6.6M.

Before the programme was stopped, it jumped to TT$113,502,273M. An increase of almost TT$106.9M! For context, Guardian Holdings Limited made $106M in 2013! No joke.

Photo: UNC Senator Anil Roberts was minister of sport at the time of the controversial LifeSport programme.
(Copyright Office of the Parliament 2022)

That exclusive fingered one East group as the primary beneficiary. Reportedly, threats to the Permanent Secretary caused him to flee the country.

In a contemporaneous telling comment, Gary Griffith, the then national security minister, said: “If political parties worked with groups to help them mobilise during election campaigns, that is not my business. It is not an illegal act. 

“My focus is on gangs and specific gang leaders who have access to state contracts and use their profit not to enhance their community and reduce crime but to use the profit to fuel crime via the importation of illegal drugs and weapons and using naive youths to do their dirty work, upon which they become casualties.” (Express, 19 May 2014) 

In 2019, Mr Griffith and Mr Roodal Moonilal belatedly confirmed the existence of a hitherto unknown ‘top secret’ 2014 report that warned of the link between criminal activity, government contracts and suspected gang leaders. 

Photo: Former police commissioner Gary Griffith (left) poses with controversial businessman Sheron Sukhdeo.
Sukhdeo was murdered in 2018.

However, in 2013, at the opening of the Duncan Street police post, the sitting Prime Minister, Mr Moonilal and Mr Griffith would not confirm the identity of the contractor involved. Acting Police Commissioner Stephen Williams did.

Since March 2007, a UN/World Bank report told us that our crime situation is exacerbated by political patronage, whereby some communities are the beneficiaries of poverty alleviation projects which the community drug supplier often controls.

That episode illustrates. No party is immune.

Deosaran and Chadee (1997) reported: “No ghetto youth has the connections and the resources to import the amount of guns and drugs […] on the streets. But most importantly, crimes committed by persons from the ghetto are sensationalised, overemphasised, and whole communities stigmatised, while crimes committed by members of the elite are ignored, not investigated and not subject to prosecution.”

Photo: Marvel Comic’s Crime Kingpin.

Good legal representation, time and money tip the scale.

Shades of Brad Boyce! It took Justice Herbert Volney 15 years to admit that he made a wrong decision. Consider what it took for the Volney confession to be aired. But the pain remains that of the less advantaged

This month in the wake of the La Romaine murders, a ‘security expert’ suggested that our customs officers turn a blind eye to gun importation. If the priest could play, who is me? Who pays the officers to be blind? No poor boy can pass that kind of money. But he could rent the gun from those who have it. Power by the hour!

Since 2015, the wealthiest 1% has owned more than the rest of the world’s 99%. In a recent US report, the top 1% has a third of the wealth while the bottom 50% has 2%.

The Panama Papers tell us that the wealthy and politically connected put our money beyond our reach.

Image: Change is gonna come?
(Copyright Kal)


On the other hand, Singing Sandra and Christophe Grant captured the plight of the demoralised:

“Most nights with sad tales are crowded/Their days with dark clouds are shrouded/ They don’t smile and they never will,/Only vultures get their fill/ Empty promises is what they hear/No running water from year to year…”

Where is the political will to stop the rot? The condition of the schools in the depressed areas and the long waits in the public hospitals tell a compelling story of institutionalised neglect.

Where is the professional support to counsel and guide parents? How do we disrupt the money trail? Can we strengthen the community elders?

Time to stop the carnage of our youths.

More from Wired868
Noble: Messy Massy and Mr Warner

During the massive rebranding exercise, Tony Deyal wryly commented: “Neal and Massy announced it was Massy and proved to be Read more

Noble: The problem with Dr Paul Richards’ grilling of Police Commissioner

“The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting.” Milan Kundera, a Czech and French novelist, Read more

Noble: The Gangster and the Gentleman—an East Port of Spain bandit tale

MENDOZA: I am a brigand. I live by robbing the rich. TANNER: (promptly) I am a gentleman. I live by Read more

Noble: When money became a problem—how T&T wasted three “oil booms”

In September 1973, we, as a nation, were blessed with a bonanza from new offshore discoveries and a sharp rise Read more

Noble: How educational inequity is incompatible with a just society

“[…] This feeling of always being uneducated influenced me when I became prime minister. There were always about 6,000 children Read more

Daly Bread: Criminals ducking the lack of political will

A New Year traditionally renews feelings of hope. Realism may dash hope so commentators feel pressured not to write gloomily Read more

About Noble Philip

Noble Philip, a retired business executive, is trying to interpret Jesus’ relationships with the poor and rich among us. A Seeker, not a Saint.

Check Also

Noble: Messy Massy and Mr Warner

During the massive rebranding exercise, Tony Deyal wryly commented: “Neal and Massy announced it was …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.