Noble: How TTPS raids in Arouca and Lady Chancellor differed; and what it says about our society

Mary Elizabeth Chancellor, the wife of our seventh governor, Sir John, gave her name to the road we now call Chancellor Hill. Sir John was the one who assented to the Shouter Baptist Prohibition Ordinance because ‘a Shouter meeting would make the neighbourhood where it took place unfit for residential occupation’!

Does the event of last week now make that prestigious neighbourhood unfit? What does that situation say about us, as a nation?

Photo: Riot police interact with patrons at Carnival 2019 Wet Fete- “Jamnation” at O2 Park, Chagaramas on 24 February 2019.
(Copyright Allan V Crane/CA-images/Wired868)

In Parliament, MP Maxie Cuffie bemoaned his neighbourhood’s impotence in abating the noise from what he termed a ‘brothel’. He complained that they could not get the inhabitants to keep quiet. Ensconced in the exclusive neighbourhood, the guesthouse uses a sign to advertise room availability and rates. Are they trying to attract Chancellor Hill walkers? Or is the sign a ruse?

Our nation has a brazen open secret: tainted money buys property protected by the silence of upscale neighbourhoods, where the upstanding cringing citizens do not call 482-GARY but concentrate on manicuring their greenery. Money rules in our country and is disrespectful to the rest of us. The widening disparity is evident even in the choicest neighbourhoods and definitely on our crowded streets where chariots contemptuously push aside mere mortals.

From newspaper reports, the treatment here differed from the Arouca raid. There were no breathless interviews. The pictures then were intended to shame the pastor, but the pictures here did not shame the responsible men. Driving high-end vehicles appears to excuse you from being photographed while simultaneously inducing public respect.

The lesson for vulnerable women is that having sex, or the suspicion of so doing, entitles others to invade your privacy, making you worthy of public scrutiny. The press uncritically reported on their particulars but not an identifying word was said about the untouchable ‘businessmen’.

Men in high places, including parliament and boardrooms, can act with impunity, knowing well that their political and legal friends will protect them. Shaming and humiliation are guaranteed for women since they are still Eve—the reputed cause of man’s downfall.

Photo: The women arrested at a police raid in Lady Chancellor were mostly Venezuelan citizens.
(Copyright Stabroeknews)

Why do the police always leak unedited pictures of the women in these raids? Why are the women always lined up in their undressed state, but we never see the men in that condition? Different strokes for poor people, especially when they are women? Or it is immoral policing?

Was the 14-year-old minor wandering around the place like a lost child, or was she found in a compromising position with a man? The latter is likely given the known proclivities of men in similar circumstances. Yet no man is to appear before the courts for this.

Was the police commissioner acknowledging corruption when he had to keep the raid a secret from other police officers? Do different rules govern policing the rich versus the poor?

This episode shows that we, as a nation, have lost our collective voice to protect the poor and dispossessed. The same Venezuelans, for whom we agitated to get permits, are shrugged off. The church kept silent about the root cause of oppression of those seeking our care. It chose not to lead the conversation about this situation. This is not about whether or not we should legalise prostitution. This is about how we care for the least among us and, therefore, how we speak to powerful men.

We are an ‘equal-opportunity’ disrespectful people to all those who cannot help themselves or who cannot do better. Largely, we collectively shrugged at the cruelty. Others can disenfranchise those who are not ‘us’. They have no rights for which we should defend.

Photo: Venezuelan families flee a country in crisis.
(Copyright Fox News)

Sadly, this story of our nation was foretold in Gibbon’s 1776 magnificent book, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Volume 4. We are rotting from the head down.

We choose not to share with each other on the journey to make the place a better one, but we take advantage of all who are weak and helpless.

More from Wired868
Noble: Youth Lost: an avoidable tragedy writ large, with dire societal consequences

What is teenage life if not fun as we explore new boundaries? You meet new secondary school friends and, with Read more

Noble: The problem with vilifying Christine Kangaloo; and how it makes us poorer

Over the last two weeks, we have witnessed an unceasing commentary on Ms Christine Kangaloo’s supposed lack of fitness for Read more

Noble: Our Presidential Journey, and lessons from T&T’s history

“That men do not learn very much from the lessons of history is the most important of all the lessons Read more

MSJ: New year, old politricks—Dr Rowley’s New Year message is classic misdirection

“[…] The difference between 31st December and 1st January is but a change in date… as we see the old Read more

Daly Bread: Indifference to killing and distress—without realism, honesty and empathy, “talks” will get us nowhere

Put plainly and simply, it is not possible to maintain the socio-economic status quo and at the same time expect Read more

Noble: Believe for 2023; finding joy in gloom

Straight out of the gates, on 2 January 2023, the news hit like a bucket of cold water. As though Read more

About Noble Philip

Noble Philip
Noble Philip, a retired business executive, is trying to interpret Jesus’ relationships with the poor and rich among us. A Seeker, not a Saint.

Check Also

Noble: Youth Lost: an avoidable tragedy writ large, with dire societal consequences

What is teenage life if not fun as we explore new boundaries? You meet new …


  1. Poor research. The men’s pictures from the Lady Chancellor raid are available online.

    • Noble Philip

      The unedited version? The point being made here is that the unedited photos of the women were available. The print media obscured their faces. There are no unedited pictures of the men except for the two relatives post the raid. I would be happy to be corrected. Show the evidence. I have in my possession two photos of the women in unedited form. Thank you. I will wait.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.