Carty does it against IRL, Pooran loses it in IPL—what will it mean for West Indies?

You can be forgiven for thinking that the player who helped the regional team best Ireland by 197 runs in Sunday’s third ODI was Nicholas Pooran.

Truth be told, when you hear that a current West Indian batsman hit eight sixes and 15 fours in a 142-ball innings of 170 to give the Maroon Men a big win and a 1-1 draw in the three-match series—the name that comes immediately to mind is emphatically not Keacy Carty.

West Indies batsman Keacy Carty celebrates a century against Ireland.
Photo: Getty Images.

That remains true even when you know the relevant facts. In the first match, West Indies surrendered meekly to the hosts, losing by the convincing margin of 124 runs before rain ruined the second one. Regrettably.

A Carty century had powered the now Shai Hope-led side to a daunting 352 for 8.

In the Indian Premier League, in the meantime, things were not exactly going swimmingly for the eight West Indians on franchise books.

For virtually the first half of the 2025 season, star batsman Pooran led the League in four performance categories: Most Runs (orange cap), Super Striker, Most Sixes and Most Valuable Player.

Lucknow Super Giants batsman Nicholas Pooran on the go.
(via Probatsman.)

And yet, disappointingly, he has not been able to lead the Lucknow Super Giants into the all-important playoffs.

But there is a straw at which we drowning West Indian supporters can clutch; you’ll probably need a magnifying glass to see it: the prolific six-hitting left-hander did play a part in shaping the final line-up of the four-team, four-match, end-of-season knockout mini-tournament.

When he was on top of his form and on top of the list of orange cap contenders, LSG were riding high. They got to ten points with as many as six games left, winning five of their first eight games.

But after they lost to Delhi Capitals by eight wickets in Round 9, they seemed to lose their way.

Shardul Thakur has been LSG’s most reliable bowler in IPL 2025.
Photo: AFP/ Getty Images.

Mumbai Indians, Punjab Kings and Sunrisers Hyderabad all got the better of them in the three rounds that followed, leaving them on ten points from 12 matches.

And out of the playoffs!

Table-toppers GT were on 18 points, their playoffs place secure. Victory would ensure a Qualifier 1 place for them. But Mitchell Marsh and Pooran had other plans.

When the left-hander strolled out to the middle to join the Australian Mitchell Marsh on 91 for 1 after nine overs in Match 64 last Thursday, the die was already cast. Only pride to play for.

West Indies cricket star Nicholas Pooran blows a kiss to his LSG fans.

When the two were finally separated, LSG’s total had already crossed 200. Marsh had gone on the rampage, amassing 117 off 64 balls.

For once the junior partner, Pooran contributed only 56 off his 27 balls. But it was, along with his 45 run out versus SRH in Match 61 on May 19, only his second substantial knock in six innings.

In pursuit of 236 for the win, GT got 38 off 22 balls from Sherfane Rutherford. In vain.

Gujarat Titans batsman Sherfane Rutherford shows what he can do in an IPL clash with Dehli Capitals at Ahmedabad on 19 April 2025.
Photo: Associated Press.

Shubman Gill’s team’s points tally remained an accessible 18.

Surely RCB, on 17 and next up against back-markers SRH, would leapfrog them.

Ha!

Romario Shepherd grabbed two scalps and two catches in SRH’s 231 for 6. Coming in at number six in the 16th over, however, he could not reproduce his swing-for-the-hills heroics of early May.

RCB batsman Romario Shepherd on the go in the IPL 2025 season.

His golden duck marked the beginning of the end, RCB collapsing from 174 for 4 to 189 all out.

So, GT stuck on 18, RCB a point behind, tied with PBKS for second. Would the Kings  accelerate into the lead with a win over the back-pedalling DC?

They did not. But it was worth noting that, despite the top-of-the-table versus bottom-of-the-table match-ups, for the third successive day, the top three placings remained unchanged.

The Punjab Kings have been a rejuvenated force in the 2025 IPL season.
Photo: Associated Press.

And what Pooran and Mitchell Marsh started continued into a fourth day.

On Sunday, table-proppers Chennai Super Kings amassed 230 for 5. GT could muster only 147 in reply, Rutherford making a four-ball duck.

So they remained in the lead on 18 points from their complement of 14 games. But the chasing three all had one match left!

The good news for Gill was that the last game for both third-placed PBKS and fourth-placed MI was the same, Monday’s Match 69. Only the winner of that game could equal or surpass 18 points and match or overhaul GT’s 0.254 NRR.

Corbin Bosch does the job in the field for Mumbai Indians during the 2025 IPL season.
Photo: BCCI.

Defeat meant a place in the Eliminator.

PBKS won. They beat a lacklustre MI by 7 wkts to move to the top of the table. Gill and company now had one foot in Thursday’s Qualifier 1 and one in Friday’s Eliminator.

Like the West Indian support, they were doubtless hoping Pooran would find his early season form in Tuesday’s Match 70, GT versus RCB. That would have helped keep RCB on 17. But it did not happen.

Skipper Rishabh Pant got a long-awaited century. But 228, no easy target, proved not to be beyond RCB.

RCB star Josh Hazelwood.
Photo: Getty Images.

Pooran perished off the penultimate ball, trying to power Shepherd over midwicket. His 13 contained no boundaries.

If he is to win the Most Sixes award, his 40 maximums will have to suffice. And he’s no longer in the running for any other award.

So GT ended up pitted against MI in the Friday Eliminator and RCB who, remember, have never won an IPL final, will take on the Kings in Thursday’s Qualifier 1.

West Indies teammates Shimron Hetmyer (left) and Andre Russell share a light moment at Kolkata on 4 May 2025 during the IPL season.
Photo: AFP/ Getty Images.

That means that, of the West Indians, only Rutherford and Shepherd remain in the fray.

How many Maroon eyes will still be trained on the IPL? Won’t our gaze shift to the three ODIs which—starting Thursday in Edgbaston—pit Hope’s cock-a-hoop troops against an uncertain England under new white-ball captain Harry Brook?

Will the newbie find a way to keep the laid-back 28-year-old in-form Sint Maarten batsman quiet? Or will Hope take the pressure off him by delivering big-time as he has so often done in the 50-over format?

West Indies limited overs captain Shai Hope (right) and Keacy Carty.
Photo: CWI Media.

And what about Shimron Hetmyer? In IPL 2025, his 13 innings yielded fifty once and 25-plus only twice more. What, if anything, does his inclusion in the squad for England tell us about the state of our cricket?

The questions abound. The answers, it seems reasonable to hope, will further sweeten the post-Carty taste now in West Indian mouths.

More from Wired868
Vaneisa: How number 27 blew away West Indies cricket; the answer, my friend…

There didn’t seem to be much point in writing about the ignominious end to the Test series between West Indies Read more

Dear Editor: West Indies Cricket is dead—even with Shai in squad, this is Hopeless

“[…] Being humiliated is nothing new to West Indians born mid-1980s and later. But this 27 all out feels different—this Read more

Dear Editor: You could pick who you want as coach and captain—WI problems run deep

“[…] You could pick who you want at this point in time. You could pick whatever coach, he could come Read more

Dear Editor: Can Shallow and Sammy take WI cricket forward? Then why are they still there?!

“[…] Is this just another day in the office? Do you guys not have standards—pride in yourselves, and pride in Read more

‘Progress rarely straightforward’; CWI call ‘emergency meeting’ after WI bowled out for 27

“[…] Progress is rarely straightforward… We have already seen encouraging signs, particularly with the ball… Now is the time to Read more

Wiaan who? Joy and concern in West Indies after South African captain’s Lara decision

Cricket connoisseurs had little doubt. If, in the last 15 years,  anybody was going to break Brian Lara’s 400 not Read more

Check Also

Vaneisa: How number 27 blew away West Indies cricket; the answer, my friend…

There didn’t seem to be much point in writing about the ignominious end to the …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.