Best: Why Windies should NOT bowl DreRuss at death; and lingering selection questions

Bitter experience is the best teacher. I know. Ever since Jason Holder’s West Indians unaccountably turned the tables on England at Headingley in 2017, I hate the taste of Brylcreem.

And yet, here we go: I will eat my hat if Rovman Powell’s West Indies do not emerge victorious in the five-match T20I series against England which ends at the Brian Lara Cricket Academy in Tarouba on Thursday.

Photo: Rovman Powell is saluted by spectators at Kensington Oval after he became the third West Indies player to score a century in T20I cricket on 26 January 2022.
Powell scored 107 runs.
(Copyright CWI Media)

The margin? Doh try dat! I not goin there. But I am willing to bet a bottle of Johnny Walker Blue against a bottle of Blue Waters that the home side will bounce back from that completely demotivating cutarse in Grenada last week.

It takes some doing to make 223 runs in a T20 game and lose. It takes some doing to hit 16 sixes in a single T20 innings and lose. It takes some doing to have 20-plus runs to play with at the start of the last over of a T20 game and lose.


Harry Brook is not a 36-year-old past-his-best Moeen Ali. He is not a big, strong Carlos Brathwaite either; he is a seriously talented batsman.

So it took some doing to imagine that lightning would strike in the same place on Saturday as on Thursday. And to imagine that if there were deliveries there for the taking, Brook or Phil Salt or whoever the English batsman on strike happened to be would again miss out and fail to take advantage.

West Indies bowler Andre Russell (right) celebrates the wicket of Liam Livingstsone during the ongoing T20I series.
Photo: Associated Press

Hindsight? Yes. But not in the sense in which people are likely to mean it. It’s hindsight in the sense that we should have learned from what we saw towards the end of Game 2.

With 31 needed off the last two overs, Jason Holder produced a miserly over #19, leaving the recalled Andre Russell—man-of-the-match in game 1, no less—all of 28 runs to play with.

But ask Nicholas Pooran who had the best seat in the house to make the assessment. The two consecutive deliveries that Moeen missed in over #20 could oh so easily have yielded 12 runs. And WI won by 10!

I don’t think the way Pooran threw his head back after Moeen’s misses was merely because he thought the batsman could have got an edge. He could have middle it!

Then West Indies captain Nicholas Pooran (left) has a word with Rovman Powell during the CG United ODI Series against India in July 2022.
(Copyright Daniel Prentice/ Wired868)

But either the former skipper forgot all about it in the euphoria of Thursday’s win. Or he failed to remind the current skipper of it after England had progressed to 107 without loss after 10 overs.

He should have said to Powell: “Skip, I hope you not leaving DreRuss for the death.” It’s what I said out loud to myself at the break.


I was in no doubt that Salt, the in-form opener, was in assault mode and his skipper at the other end was carving up the bowling more like a butcher than a Buttler.

England batsman Phil Salt.

The game was arguably lost between overs #10 and #15. Hosein conceded 10 from the tenth over, following Gudakesh Motie’s miserly five in the ninth. That was the moment, I thought, to slip in a Russell over. Instead, Powell used up Motie’s third. It cost four runs.

Some will argue that scoreboard pressure after that parsimonious over earned Buttler’s scalp for Russell. In the event, he allowed the new batsman just one run off the last four balls. Perhaps. But it left the all-rounder with two of the last eight to bowl and Motie with just one.

Which Powell opts to use up immediately. Unwisely, I thought. Seven to go, Motie and Hosein bowled out. More importantly, the unthreatening Russell has two.

West Indies spinner Gudakesh Motie (right) bowls while India batsman Shubman Gill looks on during the first ODI against India at the Queens Park Oval on 22 July 2022.
(Copyright Daniel Prentice/ Wired868)

With Livingstone, the new batsman on strike, the skipper calls up Holder instead of Russell, whose two completed overs have brought him one for 14 at this stage.

In the next three overs, Holder (#14), Alzarri Joseph (#15) and Russell (#16) each give up a single six, leaving England still needing almost three runs per ball off the last four. Two sixes in Joseph’s second-last over reduce the deficit to 51 but that is still a tough ask.

The key question for Powell at this stage is who bowls #19. Holder was sooooooo good in the second match. But Powell makes the right decision. He chooses Joseph.

West Indies pacer Alzarri Joseph races in to bowl during an ODI match against India at the Queen’s Park Oval on 22 July 2022.
Photo: Daniel Prentice/ Wired868

The secondary question is this: Holder or Russell at the death? In my view, the question should have been Holder or Motie?

Now it is entirely possible that, bowling #20 with five men on the boundary, Motie is given the same harsh treatment meted out to Russell. After all, off his first over, the last one in the powerplay, Salt and Buttler had taken 18, including two sixes and a four.

On the evidence, it would be a major surprise. How often is he taken for consecutive sixes? Multiple sixes?

England batters Phil Salt (centre) and Harry Brook celebrate a dramatic win over West Indies in the third T20I affair.
At right is West Indies bowler Andre Russell.
Photo: Getty Images

So if the finger-spinner is given 20-plus runs to defend in Tarouba today or Thursday and fails so to do, I would not enjoy my hair-seasoned meal. But I would not feel hard done by.

However, if, in either game, Pooran allows Powell again to save the 35-year-old recalled allrounder for last. I shall pull every last strand of my hair out.

And if, once this series is done and dusted, we shall have to turn sharpen the focus on Messrs Desmond Haynes, Roland Butcher and Daren Sammy.

West Indies head selector Sir Desmond Haynes.
(Copyright SW Londoner)

Despite all that has been said about age over the last month, for Games 4 and 5, they just called up the soon-to-be-35-year-old Johnson Charles. Hardly a stellar performer with a bright future ahead of him.

Should we then be surprised if they extend to the long-serving, injury-prone veteran whose effective age far exceeds his calendar age an invitation to continue

More from Wired868
WI summon Charles and Oshane for T20Is; Hetmyer cut and Alzarri rested

Thirty-four year-old batsman Johnson Charles has been recalled to the West Indies T20 International team for the last two outings Read more

To boycott or not to boycott? Boo, not bravo, to I-Sports’ birdbrained idea!

“People are like animals,” a long-running promo for the two weekly I-Sports programmes asserts, “and sometimes they need to be Read more

Bravo and Boycott: They’re both not playing; WI must resist insularity

As if West Indies cricket does not already have enough problems, what with our failure to qualify for the last Read more

Orwell’s take on Maxwell’s incredible no-foot batting, Cummins’ wotlissness and West Indian purblindness

The spirit of George Orwell lay heavy over Mumbai’s Wankhede Stadium on Tuesday evening after favourites Australia got past underdogs Read more

Lawrence: The right and wrong way to develop WI batsmen, judging Phil Simmons, and the Da Silva example

“[…] The Guyana Cricket Board in conjunction with the Government of Guyana has had the foresight to acquire the services Read more

Pooran, Holder and Mayers decline WI contracts; CWI announces 2023-24 list

Cricket West Indies (CWI) today confirmed their list of centrally contracted men’s and women’s players for the 2023-24 season, based Read more

About Earl Best

Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970's. He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.

Check Also

Best: Berry wide of mark for praising WI style, yet blasting Lara

History, we West Indians are acutely aware, is written for the most part by the …

One comment

  1. The captain believes in his compatriot. Remember what he said at the start of the series, in welcoming him back. No doubt the man is suited to T20 cricket but even with his talent he has limitations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.