Noble: When chickens come home—why Ryan Report should be mandatory reading

We all know the idiom “chickens come home to roost”, which means the consequences of wrongdoing always catches up with the wrongdoer. In the past two weeks, this expression has materialised in our country.

The new spate of crime witnessed is the fruit of our actions over several decades. Passions are now the master of reasoning.

A forensic investigator at a crime scene.

As we feverishly share and forward each message of evil doing, we should consider the difference between fear and risk. Perceived risk induces fear more than actual victimisation. Fear is an emotional response, while risk is a cognitive assessment of one’s environment. Risk is a more realistic assessment of social reality.

Experiences influence fear and are perceptually enhanced by forces like the rumour mill and the mass media (Chadee, 2003). This distinction is critical to appreciate, given the emailed bomb threat and the multiple chain group chats.

The Minister of National Security and the Police Service missed the point relative to the bomb threat in dismissing the event as being created by a “miscreant” and their interpretation of it as a hoax.

Inciting widespread fear and vulnerability represent the terrorists’ most important objective. Such events frighten the population into distrusting the government and creating political dissatisfaction or panic people into desiring more draconian policies (Breckenbridge and Maguen, 2006).

A police officer investigates a bomb scare in downtown POS on 18 October 2021.
(via TTPS)

Consider the 2004 Madrid bombing that possibly changed the election results (Montalavo, 2011). The use of the Dark Net, as confirmed by the Police, fits the terrorist narrative (Malik, 2018).

We should note that The Geneva Declaration on Terrorism (1987) states that “the distinguishing feature of terrorism is fear, and this fear is stimulated by threats of indiscriminate and horrifying forms of violence directed against ordinary people everywhere.”

Did not the event fit this description? This ghastly action that affected hundreds of children and frightened mothers is a natural progression of our nation’s polarisation and lack of care for our children.

We have a long history of child neglect, and this callous act that traumatised our children came from some twisted anti-social mind.

Spectators at the Morvant Recreation Ground look on as Morvant Caledonia United host San Juan Jabloteh in Pro League action at the Morvant Recreation Ground on 16 October 2016.
(Courtesy Sean Morrison/ Wired868)

The role of the media in creating an atmosphere of fear should not be ignored. The trope “if it bleeds, it leads” is true, more so because of the thirst for clicks and likes.

In our politically charged atmosphere, a clear political bias is often demonstrated in our local media. How do we explain that a meeting chaired by the National Security Minister and two senior police officers, also residents of the area, is tucked on an inside page, but the unfounded ideological rant of two pundits hits the front page?

The meetings were held three days apart! The media’s undeclared political bias continues to blindside and agitate.

The racist image of “urban youth” with “de mother have 14 and 15 children to mind” springs from a well that threatened our Independence talks at Malborough House and was voiced by a Member of Parliament in a 2004 debate over land use.

Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Dr Eric Williams (standing) addresses the opening session of the Independence Conference at Marlborough House, London on 28 May 1962.
The talks lasted about two weeks and resulted in Independence for Trinidad and Tobago.
(Copyright AP Photo/ Staff/ Laurence Harris)

At Malborough House, there was an argument that views of the Indian Association of Trinidad should be incorporated into the Constitution. The allegation was that Indians were discriminated against, a “wrong” that they argued could only be resolved via proportional representation.

There is no empirical evidence to support this image promoted in Aranguez. However, black men have been smeared in local newspapers since the publication of Thomas Carlyle’s racist rant.

Carlyle’s “Occasional Discourse on the Nigger Question” in which he described emancipated people in the British colonies as belonging to an idle, inferior race whom God created to be servants to those “who are born wiser than you, that are born lords of you—servants to the whites” was published in February 1850.

Neo-nazis protest the removal of a statute to late Confederate leader Robert E Lee in Charlottesville.
(Copyright ABC.net.au)

The politically-driven land use changes in the “bread basket” of the nation made us more food-insecure when the Aranguez farmers sold the agricultural land to industrialists. At this point, the culture and values of a formerly tightly-knit community were challenged.

No evidence supports the opinion that East Indians are more victimised (Chadee, 2003; Seepersad and Wortley, 2017). The authors of the latter publication—the groundbreaking effort to examine ethnicity—acknowledge that racial prejudices can trigger more reporting (Shah and Pease, 1992).

They also recognised the establishment of the Crime And Problem Analysis Unit of the TTPS, which collects crime data from every police station. Prejudices persist even as crime is a part of the Aranguez community.

In 2004, Darius Figuera, a criminologist familiar with the cocaine trade (2004), noted:

Late notorious drug dealer Nankissoon Boodram, better known as Dole Chadee.

The El Socorro/Aranguez developed as a result of its proximity to the Caroni Swamp and its use as a trafficking route. Illicit drugs under the cover of the Caroni Swamp were stored and entered from this area into the East-West Corridor.

“Specific Indo-Trinbagonian businessmen in the area funded this trade, and Naim ‘Nyah’ Ali and Teddy ‘Mice’ Khan were simply the frontmen, the visible public fall guys for the secret financiers.

The much disputed Scott Report traced the links between these men and their alliances in other parts of the county. The Venezuela connection was alive and reported managed by one Adella Moses. The tentacles reached into the Commissioner’s office, and some say into Parliament.

The urban youths were the young victims and the “barrel children” at the time and in junior secondary schools. Their mothers were scratching out a living in a foreign land.

Boys playing in a guava tree.

Mala Jokhan identified the lonely pain: “while children received material goods in barrel shipments and money through wire transfers, they often experienced an emotional deficit—a care drain—as a result of the separation.”

Is there not a link between this breakdown in families and the introduction of cocaine by the kingpins?

We accepted Police Commissioner Randolph Burroughs, not knowing the drug network and a slew of non-Africans who collaborated with him. We have long closed our eyes to wrongdoing for the sake of money. We never questioned blatant money laundering, and here we are now!

The chickens have come home to roost.

In the 2013 Ryan Report, Indira Rampersad argued that the “notion that young black males alone constitute at-risk youths is erroneous”. This argument now echoes in the April 2022 Randy Seepersad’s lament:

Late Unruly gang member Abdul “Krysis” Wakeel.

“We know that things are getting harder and harder in the country. The Covid pandemic did not do us any favours in terms of the economic hardships. People are without jobs; jobs are very scarce. They go to university, they do their CAPE, they come out with very good grades, and they cannot get a job.

“When that type of hopelessness starts to spread to the wider society, it creates a strain. We are seeing it across the board; I know students who graduate with First Class Honours degrees and cannot get a job.

“The literature will tell you that economic deprivation is something that will lead a country into the abyss when it comes to crime.”

The crime scene is changing and may even change for the worse.

Carlos Bar in the Aranguez area is famous for the 2008 killing of Merlin “Cudjoe” Allamby, who was lured there by the murder of his two East Indian friends, Raffick “Puna” Mohammed and his common-law wife Rosanna Seemungal.

A forensic pathologist at a crime scene.

Mohammed, uncle of Shazard “Teddy Mice” Khan, lived in Chaguanas. Crime knows no skin colour nor respects any community. But we stubbornly refuse to admit it.

Our country is a minor player in the global drug trade. Our climbing homicide rate is caused by increasingly violent gangs fighting over various criminal economies (InsightCrime.org).

Our geographic location restores us as an ideal transhipment point for cocaine between Guyana, Venezuela, and Europe. As it was under Burroughs, so it continues today.

Shabby schools and undernourished youth only provide fodder. We have never seriously fought this scourge.

Who were the African supporters abusing Pundit Donny Samlal in the United National Congress leadership forum? Were they urban youth?

Former Commissioner of Police Randolph Burroughs was fingered for corruption in the Scott Drug Report.

All our leaders should be mandated to read the Ryan Report. We may not be able to resurrect Dana Seetahal, but we may be able to save another person. We, as citizens, must resist police commissioners like Randolph Burroughs.

Our country needs justice, not extra-judicial vengeance. We should determine to remove the scales of partisan ideology from our eyes. Then and only then will we have a hope to avoid hell on earth.

More from Wired868
Noble: What auditor general impasse says about the quality of our leaders

The ongoing saga of the auditor general and the understatement of the country’s revenue reveal the quality of our leaders. Read more

Demming: What criteria were used to measure Erla’s performance?

When Erla Harewood-Christopher assumed the role of acting commissioner of police in December 2022 following the vacation of her predecessor, Read more

Noble: Minding our business; how Massy’s performance affects everyone

Every child of a certain age would have grown up with a parent who taught them, “Drunk or sober, mind Read more

Noble: Lack of integrity scares me—does Mr Harford think crooks wouldn’t jook him?

“Look for three things in a person: intelligence, energy and integrity. If they don’t have the last one, don’t even Read more

Noble: This is Madness! Sparrow warned about slaughter of our young

On Friday 5 April, the Express headline screamed, “Things you see in movies”. Little did the writer know that more Read more

Daly Bread: Government extends blame game while crime rampages on

For some weeks this column had been focused on the good, the bad and the ugly of Carnival and its Read more

Check Also

Noble: What auditor general impasse says about the quality of our leaders

The ongoing saga of the auditor general and the understatement of the country’s revenue reveal …

2 comments

  1. No sugar coating here, as usual factual and to the point. A great history lesson for those too young to recall and a reminder to those older dishonest, deceitful ones who experience convenient memory loss. Well done also Dr David Mohammed in your attempts to enlighten persons re. The Aranguez and environs crime situation and its history. Until we start being honest and remove the hypocrisy that surrounds crime/criminality and deal with it in an equitable manner. Not where the law only punishes one type of people while the jefes go on there merry way accumulating wealth and at same time wreaking havoc and mayhem across local communities. Politicizing crime/sitting on our hands will ensure this spate of crime continues well into our future.

    • Salacious B. Crumb

      As usual another shite piece from Noble. Possession of a pen makes not a writer.

      Apologist disguised in long prose.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.