Daly Bread: Sunlight and disinfectant; it neither killed Covid nor revealed party financiers

Louis D Brandeis was a well known Justice of the US Supreme Court. In 1913, three years before his appointment, while an outspoken advocate for financial and government transparency as a means of curbing corruption, he wrote a piece in Harper’s Weekly magazine in support of the regulation of banks.

In it he made the statement: ‘Sunlight is the best disinfectant’.

Photo: The best disinfectant?

More than one hundred years later, sunlight and disinfectant have again become linked, but the facts behind the current links between them are so bizarre that one might apply the popular response: ‘you just couldn’t make this stuff up’.

In literal mode, the presidents of two of the largest countries of the world have promoted the idea of an anti-malarial drug and ultra-violet light as treatment for Covid-19. Ultra violet light is disseminated by the rays of the sun.

Here at home, our Leader of the Opposition, unwisely and petulant at the government’s initial success in containing Covid, repeated that ‘sunlight will kill Covid’.

But laugh and cry live in the same yard. While many were still laughing at these ramblings, an example was revealed in this newspaper last week of how badly we are disadvantaged in our practice of democracy by this government’s failure to implement the metaphor linking sunlight and disinfectant—in this case to the issue of campaign finance.

In May this year, the prime minister came on strong in the Parliament with news that a bill was being brought forward to meet his party’s commitment to campaign finance reform, promised years before. This was a belated bill. It went to Select Committee but did not make it out of Committee and into law.

Photo: Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley.
(via OPM)

The Parliament was dissolved in order to have the General Election 2020 within the required constitutional deadline.

This was not a fault of the PNM 2015-2020 administration alone. The preceding UNC-dominated People’s Partnership Government of 2010 to 2015 also failed to deliver campaign finance reform.

It is these types of essential but broken promises on each side that leave many wondering whether, on election day next week, to decide out of frustration: ‘none of the above’.

Now here is last week’s revelation of how our democracy is hurt by the slackness in campaign finance reform—one major object of which is to place an obligation on financiers to make public disclosure of their donations to political parties and candidates.

Denyse Renne of the Trinidad Express newspaper is one of our admirable journalists pulling things out into the sunlight, even though they get pressure fuh so.

Last Monday she wrote a story entitled Evidence is Weak concerning a police investigation into allegations of kickbacks paid to persons in public life, related to the award of two State controlled contracts.

Photo: UNC supporters on the campaign trail in Moruga.
(via UNC)

Renne’s story, based on access to a letter passing between investigators and leading counsel, reports that the letter states there is only circumstantial evidence regarding the allegations of kickback.

It continues:

‘Investigators believe that money paid through advertising agencies to the former regime were inducements to secure construction contracts. However, investigators have hit a snag with this focus in the investigations since there is nothing illegal about political contributions, if the source of funds is legitimate. 

‘The onus is on investigators to prove such funds going towards campaign financing were obtained through fraud, deception or some other illegality’.

Whatever the alleged legal snags, the point is that the voting public should be able to know from disclosure under campaign finance laws who, among contractors and all others, made campaign finance donations over the last 10 years to those forming the past two administrations. That is the kind of information that would benefit us by exposure to the metaphorical sunlight for disinfecting.

Both major parties have curiously deprived us of that sunlight.

Photo: Then Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar (left) shakes hands with her successor, Dr Keith Rowley, en route to Nelson Mandela’s funeral in South Africa.
(Courtesy News.Gov.TT)

Meanwhile, sunlight has not killed Covid. We must have our Elections on time, but we have to deal with Covid’s ominous new spread.

It is vital therefore that the Elections and Boundaries Commission puts out clear guidelines informing us of any additional, but voluntary, step we are to be encouraged to take in the voting process as a result of  the spread of the disease.

More from Wired868
Noble: Our Presidential Journey, and lessons from T&T’s history

“That men do not learn very much from the lessons of history is the most important of all the lessons Read more

Noble: Considering the PDP’s collapse, the PNM Convention’s shuffle, and Volney’s passing

What a week! The events that tumbled over each other added to the exhaustion and frustration of the long road Read more

Noble: How the cookie (nation) crumbles—Vincent, Vishesh and the cost of T&T’s failing institutions

The presentation and discussion of a national budget usually focus on competing ideas about the future of a country. The Read more

Daly Bread: Buoyed by stale or tarnished Opposition, PNM is relentlessly insulting the public

A regular reader, who messages me occasionally, opened a WhatsApp exchange about last week’s Budget debate in the House of Read more

Noble: What empty Budget chatter reveals about T&T’s future and leadership

“Words are the clothes thoughts wear” — Samuel Beckett, Irish writer. The Budget debate and its fallout sent me scurrying Read more

Daly Bread: Can T&T go on this way—despite fractures with opposition parties?

Having over a long period described the issues confronting us and analysed where they would lead if left unattended, it Read more

About Martin Daly

Martin Daly
Martin G Daly SC is a prominent attorney-at-law. He is a former Independent Senator and past president of the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago. He is chairman of the Pat Bishop Foundation and a steelpan music enthusiast.

Check Also

Noble: Our Presidential Journey, and lessons from T&T’s history

“That men do not learn very much from the lessons of history is the most …


  1. Interesting. Whenever scandal of corruption hits the UNC specifically, the talking heads as well as the mockery of fith estate in TT, SPREADS it to the PNM. However, when scandal hits the PNM…it’s the PNM! Trinidad’s democracy limps, because of it’s unwillingness to hold the UNC and Kamla in particular, to the same unabashed unflinching criticism of the PNM! It’s one-sided, dishonest, and showcases Trinidad’s glass staircased ethnic hierarchy.

    Kamla has been cuddled and babied from day one!

    • Rumour has it that, although she’s no longer breast-feeding, she’s still on the bottle.

      Might that explain why she’s still being cuddled and babied?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.