St Joseph, Moruga/Tableland, Chaguanas East… Rishi considers 2020’s marginal seats

As we go through five weeks of intense political campaigning, in the lead up to the 10 August General Election, expect to hear the word ‘marginal’ used a lot—be it ‘marginal seat’, ‘marginal constituency’ and, the perennial favourite, ‘key marginal’.

‘Marginals’ are a vital part of our electoral landscape, as they are where the outcome of political campaigns are decided and often attract disproportionate attention and funding, as elections draw nigh.

Photo: Minister of Health and St Joseph MP Terrence Deyalsingh.
(Copyright Office of the Parliament)

In general terms, a marginal seat is one that is held by the incumbent with a small majority—as compared to a ‘safe seats’, which generally stay with the same political party election after election.

The safety of a seat is usually ranked in terms of the victor’s winning margin of votes over the second placed candidate as a percentage of all valid votes cast, rather than the absolute number they won by.

Using data from the 2015 general election, the largest majority win was in the constituency of Laventille West with a majority of 89.42% of the votes to the PNM candidate, Fitzgerald Hinds.

By contrast, the most marginal or closest seat in the last election was in Moruga/Tableland where the PNM candidate, Lovell Francis, won by a majority of 2.53% or 533 votes.

“One of the key issues that has arisen in […] general election campaign has been the question of deciding which constituencies may be considered marginal and which ones are not,” said Dr Hamid Ghany. “There are many ways in which a constituency may be deemed to be marginal that can range from emotion to scientific calculation.”

Photo: UNC Senator and Point-a-Pierre MP David Lee.
(Copyright Office of the Parliament)

In 2002, Ghany designed a formula for the calculation of the outer limit of marginality. The inner limit of marginality will always be zero; but the outer limit is a moving target from election to election.

Utilising his formula and applying it to the 2015 election results, constituencies won by a margin of 3,400 votes or less represent (based on the data) marginal constituencies.

As a result, the following are the marginal constituencies for the 2020 general elections:

  • Barataria/San Juan (540);
  • Chaguanas East (1,424);
  • Cumuto/Manzanilla (3,179);
  • La Horquetta/Talparo (2,822);
  • Mayaro (2,894);
  • Moruga/Tableland (533);
  • Pointe-a-Pierre (1,506);
  • San Fernando West (3,310);
  • St Joseph (1,633).
Photo: (From left) Then Sports Minister Darryl Smith, House Speaker Esmond Forde, Agriculture Minister Clarence Rambharat and then TTFA president David John-Williams share a light moment during the TTFA’s sod turning ceremony at the National Cycling Velodrome, Couva.
Forde and Rambharat will contest the seats of Tunapuna and Chaguanas East respectively.
(Copyright Allan V Crane/CA-Images/Wired868)

An outlier to keep an eye on is Tunapuna (3,615).

Of those constituencies mentioned above, I believe the most critical to watch are:

  • Barataria/San Juan;
  • Chaguanas East;
  • Moruga/Tableland;
  • Pointe-a-Pierre;
  • St Joseph.

It is interesting to note that, of those marginal seats, Terrence Deyalsingh (St Joseph) and David Lee (Pointe-a-Pierre) are the only incumbent MPs who are returning to the polls, while the rest are new candidates.

Tobago would also be interesting, as Watson Duke, the Tobago House of Assembly (THA) minority leader, attempts to rally support behind his vision for Tobago self-determination. If he captures one or both of the Tobago seats, it may well be a game changer.

Photo: THA minority leader and PSA union boss Watson Duke.
(via Islandmix)

Another key factor for this campaign may be the current Covid-19 regulations. For most politicians, the campaign season offers a rare chance to get up close and personal with the public, as they try to persuade people to vote them into office.

Online political rallies, physically distanced door-knocking sessions, and fist bumps instead of handshakes would have been unthinkable a few months ago. But this is what candidates would have to get used to, as the clock ticks down to 10 August.

More from Wired868
Dear Editor: Despite “Santa Clausing”, Panday’s legacy is same as other PMs

“[…] Yes, Basdeo Panday was much kinder to certain individuals and organisations than PNM ever was or will be, but Read more

Dear Editor: To Basdeo “Silver Fox” Panday—his positives outweigh the negatives

Trade unionist, actor, attorney at law, politician and Trinbagonian legend, Basdeo Panday has passed. He was well known for his Read more

Dr Gopeesingh: Panday was a trailblazer and probably T&T’s greatest patriot

“[…] Basdeo Panday’s life itself is a story of incredible greatness and inspirational heroism—a poor, rural, Indo-Trinidadian boy, consigned to Read more

Daly Bread: Government gaps in call out on crime

My close friends are worried for the safety of commentators on violent crime. In my case, they firmly believe that Read more

Daly Bread: Who they fooling? Crime isn’t priority for PNM or UNC

A reader, who enjoys the historical perspective contained in many of these columns, asked me recently whether there is a Read more

Daly Bread: Violent crime retrospective; mamaguy from Gov’t and Opposition

In a column published 20 years ago, in mid-May 2003, I described the subject of crime as priority numbers one, Read more

About Rishi Maharaj

Rishi Maharaj is the CEO of Disclosure Today. He holds a BSc. and MSc. in Government from UWI and has over 10 years work experience in Trinidad and Tobago's public sector. He is also a certified member of the Canadian Institute of Access and Privacy Professionals.

Check Also

Dear Editor: Despite “Santa Clausing”, Panday’s legacy is same as other PMs

“[…] Yes, Basdeo Panday was much kinder to certain individuals and organisations than PNM ever …

One comment

  1. Why not consider San Fernando West as a marginal. Considering results of the last local government elections, the closure of Petrotrin and the general displeasure on the ground with the performance of the MP.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.