WI retooling? Holder finds only Allen key in bid to put spanner in Bangladesh works

EPL Properties Ltd

“A man who took a wicket,” Richie asked, as West Indies captain Jason Holder summoned Fabian Allen to bowl over number 20 in Friday’s Tri-Nation Series final against Bangladesh, “to give himself a bowling average of 168 could be the key to Windies winning this?”

“Crazy!!” he responded to his own question without deigning to answer.

I empathised. Seated in the comfort of my own home watching Tiger Woods’ PGA struggles on TV and following the cricket online, I had much the same thought, expressed rather more succinctly: “Wtf?”

Photo: West Indies all-rounder Fabian Allen in action for the St Kitts and Nevis Patriots.
(Copyright USA Cricket/Getty)

When Richie’s comment appeared on espncricinfo’s live commentary, West Indies were in pursuit of 210 for victory—the favourites had reached 165 for 5 with five of the DLS-dictated 24 overs left. In the event, Allen conceded a single off every ball to bring his overall figures to a very decent 3-0-12-1.

“Brilliant!” was my thought. “We get away!”

KFC Munch Pack

“Brilliant!” must have been Holder’s thought. “He did it! They couldn’t get him away!”

But I only deduced that after Kemar Roach went for 12 runs in over number 21, his fifth, and Holder again called Allen up to bowl over number 22. The equation then read 27 required from 18 balls.

I never doubted for a second that the skipper would have taken matters into his own hands and bowled his fifth. At that stage, a wicket would have been heaven-sent and, more than most, Holder had recently been able to have his prayers answered.


He opted for Allen. Mosaddek Hossain sent balls one, two and four heavenwards and ball three to third man. Allen’s final figures read 4-0-37-1.

I know. This was an ODI and hindsight is Twenty20 vision. But I swear my heart sank when I saw the spinner with ball in hand.

I wished Dwayne Bravo were back as captain. Or around to offer advice. Seems I’ve got my wish. Bravo the Elder and Kieron Pollard, a new report says, are now included in the World Cup reserves. And Bravo the Younger remains—at least for the moment—in the 15.

When, at the fall of Shai Hope’s wicket, I saw him appear on the screen, that was another moment when I wished Bravo the Older’s advice was available to Holder.

Photo: TKR captain Dwayne Bravo (centre) gestures to his teammates during 2018 CPL Eliminator action against SKNP at the Brian Lara Academy in Tarouba on 14 September 2018.
(Copyright Allan V Crane/CA-Images/Wired868)

Rain, remember, had interrupted the WI momentum at 131 without loss after 20.1 overs. At the resumption, with the game reduced to a 24-over-per-side affair, Hope left at 144. Almost 23 overs bowled. Enter Holder? Enter Ashley Nurse? Enter Jonathan Carter, someone willing to throw bat at ball from the outset? Someone with a special strike rate, who could maximise the returns from the eight balls left in the innings?

Nah! Holder is a Test captain. Enter Darren Bravo, whose last five innings have yielded 40 runs off 63 balls, including four single-digit scores.

Bravo contributed three off three.

There is, of course, a case for including DJ Bravo in the 15. even in the field, which is the left-hander’s best area so far, he certainly is still a better performer than the mediocre Allen. The case is compellingly made, I submit, in an espncricinfo story headlined “Who needs data when you have Dhoni?” And I am not certain that it is not what the selectors were reaching for in naming Chis Gayle vice-captain. I think they chose the wrong man.

The 39-year-old who will ride off into ODI sunset at the end of this World Cup has certainly earned his place in the squad; he is very likely to be the opener when WI take the field for their first encounter against Pakistan on May 31. He repeated recently that he knows it is his responsibility as a senior player “to support the captain and everyone else in the team” and that he is “happy and willing to put my hand up for West Indies cricket.”

Skipper Holder has confirmed that Gayle is a major contributor in the dressing-room so it seems unnecessary, almost wasteful, to put an official stamp on such seniority and authority.

Photo: West Indies batsman Chris Gayle (centre) hits out against the Pakistan bowling during their 2015 Cricket World Cup Group B match in Christchurch on 21 February 2015.
(Copyright AFP 2017/William West)

Former WI Under-19 captain Shimron Hetmyer, on the other hand, is just 22 and has repeatedly demonstrated a tendency to either forget or ignore the importance of the WI, not I maxim. Furthermore, even if, with Dave Cameron’s ouster, there is no longer the threat of the baton for those who succeed in breaking through at IPL level, might it not be advisable to dangle the captaincy carrot before him now?

Ricky Skerritt’s new selectors, alas, are not of that view, preferring sentimentality to pragmatism and forward planning. So what will they do with the World Cup squad?

The Tri-Nation pre-World Cup series was always going to be a yardstick for determining who does and who does not measure up. And so, after examining the age-old issue of form and class, the new Cameron-free panel must do the obvious thing and adjust the original squad.

It’s not just prestige and bragging rights involved; the material incentives for winning are not unattractive, especially for the cash-strapped CWI.

Teams failing to qualify for the semis will pocket a consolation US$100,000 each to go with US$40,000 earned for every win in the nine-match-per-side league stage. The losing semi-finalists go home with US$800,000 each. The eventual winners earn US$4 million of the US$10 million at stake in the tournament, the runners-up getting half that.

I want to wait and see what fine-tuning (in terms of the final 15) the selectors will do to enhance WI chances of success. I don’t see how, sentimental or not, they dare exclude Sunil Ambris. Nor can they avoid as Curtly Ambrose has just pointed out, seeking somehow to improve Holder’s (death-)bowling options.

Photo: West Indies fast bowler Kemar Roach.
(Courtesy Westindiescricket)

Whatever the composition of the final 15, the skipper is going to have his work cut out for him. Ireland showed that he has a bunch of players who can deliver victory on their day. What WI need is leadership that can inspire them to win on any day. Today.

Can Holder provide that? Despite the fulsome praise heaped on him from many quarters, it’s often his leadership that’s lauded, not his captaincy. So will he able, by word and deed, to captain his ODI team to be more than the sum of its parts?

Suffice it to say that he does not strike me as capable of producing, as the World Cup situation is not unlikely to demand, an “And, Wes, if you bowl a no-ball now, you’ll never be able to go back to Barbados.”

More from Wired868
“Greatest honour of my career”, “Dream come true”—Hope and Powell named WI white-ball captains

Wicketkeeper/batter Shai Hope and batting allrounder Rovman Powell will lead the West Indies cricket team in the One-Day International (ODI) Read more

Lara takes “performance mentor” job to “improve game sense” of Windies players

West Indies cricket legend Brian Lara was unveiled today as the Cricket West Indies’ (CWI) new performance mentor with a Read more

Test cricket for white-ball players, fitness consensus, center wicket practice: the CWI’s 34-point Report on T20 W/Cup exit

“[…] It is not in the best interests of West Indies Cricket that our best players play in every global Read more

Dear Editor: Captaining or coaching WI is an impossible job, because the real “bunglers” stay hidden

“[…] No matter how poorly the [West Indies] teams play, there are no consequences for the regional boards because they Read more

Vaneisa: Sir Wes Hall, why we should care about the grand old man

Biographies, autobiographies and memoirs about Caribbean people unwittingly carry the burden of history. So much has gone unrecorded, and academic Read more

CWI gives Academy coach, Coley, interim WI post for Zimbabwe, S/Africa tours

The Cricket West Indies (CWI) today appointed CWI Academy head coach Andre Coley as interim head coach of the West Read more

About Earl Best

Earl Best
Earl Best taught cricket, French, football and Spanish at QRC for many years and has written consistently for the Tapia and the Trinidad and Tobago Review since the 1970's. He is also a former sports editor at the Trinidad Guardian and the Trinidad Express and is now a senior lecturer in Journalism at COSTAATT.

Check Also

“Greatest honour of my career”, “Dream come true”—Hope and Powell named WI white-ball captains

Wicketkeeper/batter Shai Hope and batting allrounder Rovman Powell will lead the West Indies cricket team …


  1. I really hope good sense prevail and allow Bravo , Pollard, Keemo Paul and Pierre for Braithwaite, Thomas, Nurse..

  2. Well said. Agree with all your points. Dj Bravo is definitly being missed

  3. Warning: Undefined variable $userid in /www/wired868_759/public/wp-content/plugins/user-photo/user-photo.php on line 114

    Best is on the ball…
    If we go with the original 15, then eskimos would have to sell ice..

  4. But what about Sunil Marine, is his bowling action so suspect that he must be left out of the WC squad? Without bowlers like him in the team, we do not stand a ghost of a chance!

  5. Jimmy Adams was very clear, that there I’ll be no change to the team selected barring injury.
    Has his position been changed by directive?
    I do hope so. Fabian Allen May be a good option in the years ahead if he develops. But picking on potential in a World CUP is not on. Brathwaite was clearly a mistake. Our fielding in Ireland was very poor. Replacing these two with Bravo & Pollard, will provide the experience needed in a tournament like this, and lift our fielding 100%? This will also help Holder with the field placing, bowler choices and other technical aspects. The two of them Gayle & Russell know the other team players very well.

    • Bruce Aanensen Pollard has been out of form for some time with both bat and ball. Bravo on the other hand, once healthy, is a definite option for strong consideration.. just my 2 cents

  6. Sheldon Waithe

    Excellent points raised Earl. The warm up matches have shown that a side needs to score 350 in an ODI to be competitive nowadays. Can Windies do that for at least 6 matches in the first stage? Also, can they then restrict the opposition to less than 350? We have the ammunition for the former but I fear for our ability in the latter. Let’s see what the final 15 looks like.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.