Home / View Point / Guest Columns / Suffer the children: Turbulence and threats; under-fire director Noel tries to tighten reins

Suffer the children: Turbulence and threats; under-fire director Noel tries to tighten reins

At the end of two turbulent years of existence, the Children’s Authority was shaken by the launch of an investigation into the questionable decision taken by Director Safiya Noel to “adopt” without observing the normal protocols a teenage boy who had been assigned to the Authority’s care.

SHEILA RAMPERSAD continues her look at what the Authority has so far been able to achieve.

Part 1 was published on Sunday 28 May and Part Three will be published on Thursday 1 June.

Photo: A scene from the famous Charles Dickens novel, Oliver Twist.

The frequency of staff changes at the Children’s Authority is frustrating children’s homes.

“The people at the Authority we interface with change often and there are always lots of new people,” said one children’s home manager. “We are never sure of their social work qualifications.”

“People keep calling for information that we have already submitted,” she continued. “We are asked to submit care plans and other documents. We do that and a year later someone else calls asking for the same documents. When I submit care plans, I expect someone would read them, assess them, identify the children who need further assessment, psychological care, etc., and assign case workers to them.”

“That is not what happens,” she concluded. “Something has to be wrong.”

A prominent children’s home shared with this reporter the following list of challenges they face with the Authority: frequent changes of staff, social workers often do not conduct the required follow-up on clients they place in the home, appointments are often cancelled at short notice, other appointments are demanded today for today, lengthy delays in completing assessments, lack of critical documentation on children, difficulty contacting social officers, failure to carry out some services such as school transfers, and homes having to arrange transportation for children when appointments are made for sessions at the Authority’s Wrightson Road office.

A ministry official said the Authority sometimes refuses to transport children because they “have no Bus Route pass.”

Photo: Schoolgirls at a children’s home in Haiti.

Asked about these complaints, Director Safiya Noel said in a 20 February interview: “The issue of turnover is one of the contributing factors. Others are insufficient staff. We have 1500 cases and eight team members to do follow-ups; there is no way they can do it. Staff doesn’t increase; as we lose, we replace. We don’t have enough staff on the ground.”

Most of the Authority’s staff is concentrated in administrative areas such as Registry, Legal Department, Foster Care and Adoption, Accounting and Finance and IT. Seventeen people are in the Investigation Unit, seven in Emergency Response, eight in Child and Family Unit and nine in Licensing and Monitoring.

In addition to discontent among staff and at children’s homes, the Authority has had a steamy relationship with its line ministry across two administrations, first the People’s Partnership and now the People’s National Movement (PNM).

Former minister Clifton de Coteau let out an exasperated sigh at the mention of the Authority when contacted for an interview late last year. Asked for his assessment of the Authority given that it was operationalised during his tenure, he said: “They were living up in the clouds; they don’t want to face reality about doing things and they want everything in perfect condition before they do anything.”

He added that, while the Authority was “killing us with statistics,” he was doubtful about their level of execution.

Current minister Ayanna Webster-Roy, whose ministry initiated an independent investigation into the decision of the Authority’s director to relocate a teenage ward of the state from the Authority’s child support centre to her home, declined to be interviewed for the purposes of this report. But sources say Webster-Roy has a turbulent relationship with the Authority, which continuously resists her oversight role.

Photo: Minister of State in the Office of the Prime Minister (Gender and Child Affairs) Ayanna Webster-Roy.
(Copyright News.gov.tt)

“The CATT and the former minister did not have a cordial relationship,” said a well-placed source. “That has continued. The antagonism must end. There still seems to be this perception that it is the Ministry vs them and they (the Authority) are not realising that everyone has to work together. They are working against governments and key stakeholders.”

The antagonistic relationship is believed to have moved the Ministry to invoke Section 21 of the Children’s Authority Act to issue reporting guidelines to the Children’s Authority. Responding to questions from Independent Senator Paul Richards on 26 April, Minister of State in the Office of the Prime Minister Stuart Young revealed that a document entitled, “General guidelines to oversee the relationship between the Office of the Prime Minister (Gender and Child Affairs) and the Children’s Authority of Trinidad and Tobago” had been sent to the Authority in May 2016.

Those guidelines, he said, outlined the reporting relationship between both entities and specified that the Authority must provide to the OPM monthly board minutes, monthly reports on financial disbursements, a register showing the names and ages of children who qualify for monthly upkeep, and financial contributions received from external bodies or institutions.

He said that, for community residences, the Authority is required each quarter to submit a list of licensed community residences, a list of community residences awaiting licensing or renewal of licence, a list of community residences whose licences have been cancelled and the reasons for this, and documents supporting the payment of financial support to the children under care at the community residences.

Photo: Minister in the Ministry of the Attorney General and Legal Affairs and Office of the Prime Minister Stuart Young.
(Courtesy IRCP.Gov.TT)

He said the Authority is also required to provide the Minister with a copy of its annual report detailing its activities over the financial year and inform him/her of its plan for public campaigns and proposed public statements.

Furthermore, Young said, from time to time, the Minister may also request special reports from the board on specific matters and can convene meetings with the board as required.

Given the generally problematic relationship with its stakeholders, this reporter asked Noel whether the Authority has any mechanism for evaluating its relationships with stakeholders.

‘“We do not have a system that is fully built,” she admitted. “That framework never came off the ground. This is something we have to treat with. We have had a number of stakeholder meetings and always this feeling of the Authority being rigid—I have heard that. But when you hear the examples they give, some we can treat with and some not.

“But to hear that, after 20 months of operation, the Children’s Authority is still perceived as being rigid, it is something we have to look at; we definitely have to look at it.”

A request for an interview, emailed to Senior Counsel Stephanie Daly, longest serving chairman of the Authority, on 9 May, has not so far provoked a response.

Photo: Former Children’s Authority director Sharifa Ali-Abdullah.

While it is true that numerous conflicts between the Authority and its line ministry have developed over time, sources say the relationship did not get off to the smoothest start in 2015. As part of the compensation package for then director Sharifa Ali-Abdullah, the Authority requested the motor vehicle allowance given to public officials as well as a luxury Audi vehicle.

Then Minister de Coteau refused to grant the request, suggesting instead a four-wheel drive vehicle on the basis that that would better accord with the needs of someone who he thought needed to drive all over the country. After negotiation, however, the Authority received the Audi.

This reporter has confirmed that the Audi remains in the Authority’s fleet and was up to last Thursday being utilised by the current director.

The term of the Board of Management of the Children’s Authority, which was led by Stephanie Daly, SC, expired on April 1 and replacements have since been named. Hazel Thompson-Ahye is the only member who has been retained on the new board while Noel is an ex-officio member. The other members were Reaaz Dabiedeen, Dr Joanne Paul, Vidya Rampersad, Angela Iloo, Anna-Maria Mora, Dhanesh Maraj, Shannen Marie Russell and Derek Forrester.

Members of previous boards complained that matters that were supposed to come before them often did not. One former board member complained of feeling like an intruder; another said they did not see relevant information and correspondence.

Photo: Children’s Authority director Safiya Noel.

“We were supposed to be aware of policy and help in shaping policy but that was not the case,” said one former board member. “Reports were laid in Parliament that some of us never saw. Information was privileged.”

Another echoed de Coteau’s criticism that the Authority’s role is not only to provide statistics.

“The Children’s Authority’s claim to fame should not be statistics alone. They are there to protect children and advocate for the rights of children generally, regardless of who they upset; they shouldn’t be tiptoeing around issues they consider sensitive.”

Among the “sensitive” issues in which the Authority refused to intervene was publication of photographs of Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi’s children posing with high-powered firearms.

Former board members note also that memoranda of agreement between the Authority and other agencies to establish roles, protocols and who does what are still outstanding. To date the Authority has signed no MOU with any of its partner agencies.

“I have to re-engage each stakeholder to find out why we have no MOUs,” said Noel. “My understanding is the bureaucracy in other agencies (is responsible for the delay).”

The major partner agency with which the Authority has failed to sign an MOU is the Police Service, which is where the Child Protection Unit (CPU) is lodged.

Photo: Children at an orphanage in India.

Editor’s Note: Wired868 will carry the third and final part of Sheila Rampersad’s series reviewing the operations of the Trinidad and Tobago Children’s Authority on Thursday 1 June.

Click HERE to read Part One.

About Sheila Rampersad

Sheila Rampersad
Dr Sheila Rampersad is a member of the current MATT executive and the Women Working for Social Progress. She is a veteran columnist.

Check Also

Ex-Defence Force chief: I know nothing about any death threats to Faris! AG’s integrity under question

In a Trinidad Guardian article published on 12 October 2016, Attorney General Faris Al-Rawi claimed …

19 comments

  1. Averil, I take feedback from different people all the time. My response here really wasn’t made in a vacuum but carries over from other “lively” conversations I was having with Chloe at the same time.
    Still I tried to explain Wired868’s position as best as I can. It is easy to become a little testy on social media when you are on conversing with people all the time, as we are all human.
    It is not my intention to be unprofessional. I am sorry if it came across that way and I will continue to try my best to avoid that, even as I try to interact with dozens of readers.

  2. Lasana is actually correct. Using local children could be a legal minefield and that is why online other media companies like the BBC or CNN use generic photos where children are in silhouette or unable to be identified as actually belonging to the place being written about.

  3. Averil St Clair-Celestain Thank you.

  4. Take criticism of an article with grace. I doubt the person meant any harm Lasana Liburd. A thank you for the feedback would be more professional.

  5. No problem. We don’t assign photographers to take photos for columns just yet. Only to do sport photos. We are a growing company but quite small and we focus most of our resources on sport at present.

  6. This is what I mean by creating institutions with no clear lines of management and authority. Political interference and people not knowing exactly what is expected of them and who to report to? when will we get it right ? At the end of the day, its the kids who continue to suffer with no end in sight, but millions spent to date.

  7. Not getting into a spat
    Just an observation. Sure you could have checked a home in T&T.There ar e quite a few.

  8. I’m not sure if I’m getting this right. The CA is in a position where it must request information from homes that it cannot act on, send reports to the OPM about financials, public campaigns and statements that I assume rings very hollow in the face of lack of resources and policies to act and don’t seem to be consulted for meaningful change. Yet they must deal with line ministers who fear death from statistics and who declare that THEY, the CA, have no interest in cooperative efforts. Meanwhile children suffer? What’s wrong with having expectations up in the clouds? Bring the “reality” to new heights and take some responsibility. The children ain’t living long enough to have the luxury to fear death from statistics.

  9. Why do you use the children of Haiti who look very Happy as an example?

    • An example of what? We just were short of images from a children’s home. So we used some from other countries.
      Personally, I’m glad she seems happy.

    • Lasana Liburd . Reminds me of some foreign press using library shots to collect donations. Next time try locals.

    • How about if I used a photo of your son or daughter? Would you have thought that appropriate?
      I’d rather not use local pictures of children unless they are from a home. But thanks for your kind advice. I take it that is the only thing that stood out for you from this story.

  10. This behaviour is what we don’t need and more statistics that really serve no purpose, but to give some penpusher a wage: “He said the Authority is also required to provide the Minister with a copy of its annual report detailing its activities over the financial year and inform him/her of its plan for public campaigns and proposed public statements.

    Furthermore, Young said, from time to time, the Minister may also request special reports from the board on specific matters and can convene meetings with the board as required.”

  11. These people fuh real! Everything sounds so disconnected. No one seems to be in control, nobody is being held accountable, little or no love for the children, my heart bleeds.

  12. What struck me most was the ‘guidelines’ issued by the Minister in the OPM. Those aren’t guidelines, but dictats.

  13. We have no children in Trinidad. Just access to children in Haiti and India?
    OK. How ironic. How poignant and telling.

    Apart from that, the whole of this article is of conflict. Kind of amusing. One may wonder how and why.
    When people come to do a job, how is it that the whole thing, from day one to time click, be embroiled in personal conflicts?

    If for no other reason, its cause they not there for the stated mission. Ego, position, place, stature. But not mission.

    Which gets me to my root thought. This authority nor the society is about compassion. Perhaps no where is. But it ain’t rocket science why or how this is a failure.

    Folk prefer to sit in an office, drive an Audi, rather than feed or bathe, dress a child, make sure they have decency in housing, safety from predators, or hug a child.

    I also note that point of wondering of social workers’ training and qualifications. Across the board, we have a crisis of education, talent and competence. Something we rarely admit, and yet to face.

    Its tough. If I were taxed to find the cadre of people here to do take care and succour these children, I would fail too.