Daly Bread: Making sport with our money—state enterprise system remains “fertile ground for mismanagement”

In these weekly columns I have pursued certain matters that the leaders whom we elect by means of general elections are simply not willing to confront.

Unhelpfully, many other significant leaderships in the nation are generally content only to mouth platitudes about ‘partnering’ and ‘welcoming’ as they sway with the breeze of periodic changes of the party in power.

Kamla Persad-Bissessar addresses a crowd at the start of campaigning for the 2025 general election.
Photo: UNC.

In the mainstream media, there are of course commentators, including regular authors of letters to the editor, who are willing to bat on the sticky wickets of intimidation, victimisation, ostracism or hypocritical ‘encouragement’. Reference is made later to the impact of social media.

One of the matters that I have repeatedly pursued is the peril of the state enterprise system. For decades, political office holders of both main parties have had the state enterprise sector available to them under their unrestrained and largely unaccountable control.

This permits them, when in government, to make sport with our money.

Two weeks ago, the insightful Justice Ricky Rahim delivered a judgment concerning breaches of duty by the directors of the Sport Company of Trinidad and Tobago (SporTT).

The judgment contained the latest revelations of the misuse of a state enterprise.  A certain company received from SporTT a sole-select (that is a suck eye) award of a contract worth $34 million in connection with the now infamous LifeSport programme.

The directors of SporTT simply carried out the instructions of a minister of government and awarded the contract without any exercise of care and reasonable oversight of their own.

Photo: Former Sport Minister Anil Roberts (centre), ex-SPORTT Company CEO John Mollenthiel (left) and ex-SPORTT chairman Sebastien Paddington were key figures in the controversial Life Sport fiasco.
(Copyright SPORTT.)

These revelations featured in strongly worded editorials in the mainstream media.  I yield only briefly to the temptation to say I told you so.

Perhaps there will now be pressure to re-examine how pernicious the state enterprise system is and to recognise more fully the extent of the critical failures to implement oversight reform.

So many of the state enterprises which make decisions involving public money have been established by incorporation as private companies under the Companies Act.

Image: Afra Raymond.

Nevertheless, whatever the formalities observed to elect directors in accordance with that Act and the sanctity of their duties, as described by Justice Rahim, the directors are appointed by the government and are subject to its whim.

With respect, the expectation that state enterprise directors will be more prudent than ‘yes men’, is not in accordance with reality.

It is a reality well expressed by a letter to the editor of the Trinidad Express newspaper on Tuesday last by Anthony Bennett of San Fernando, who described the state enterprise culture as one in which “accountability becomes a casualty”.

Mr Bennett continued: “This culture of passive obedience on boards, whether due to fear, favour, or political allegiance, creates a fertile ground for mismanagement.”

The exposure in these columns of state enterprises being under the thumb of the party in power goes back to 2002.

There were two occasions in June this year when I returned to the subject in light of the mass departure and different appointments of directors as a consequence of a change of government. I proposed the strengthening of the oversight function of the Public Accounts (Enterprises) Committee of Parliament under sections 119 (5)-(8) of the Constitution.

Together we aspire…
Photo: Chevaughn Christopher/ CA-images/ Wired868.

As indicated, I close by acknowledging the almost overwhelming, but frequently questionable, presence of social media in the formation of public opinion.

A Pew Research Center report of 6 December 2022 of “a survey of 19 advanced economies” concluded as follows:

“Most think that social media has made it easier to manipulate and divide people but also say it informs and raises awareness” and that “overall most believe that it has had a positive impact on democracy”.

The report identifies “most” as follows: “Across the countries polled, a median of 57% say social media has been more of a good thing for their democracy with 35% per cent saying it has been a bad thing.”

The United States was reportedly an outlier in that “just 34% of US adults think that social media has been good for democracy, while 64% say that it has had a bad impact”.

Meanwhile, despite whatever is posted, blogged or written, millions of public funds are lost through the state enterprise sector and the public utilities for which there is no real accountability.

More from Wired868
Daly Bread: Crunch time! Can UNC Gov’t transform T&T from “get-away” place for criminals?

In the recent past, governments both of the United National Congress (UNC) and of the Peoples National Movement (PNM) have Read more

Daly Bread: T&T must avoid ‘democratic backsliding’, in face of a three-fifths majority

Against the background of recent attacks on the Independent senators, I outlined last week the two constraints on three-fifths special Read more

Noble: Is this the road to growth? Can T&T put country before party?

On 4 April 2025, then Caricom head Mia Mottley, in discussing the global crises as they impacted the Caribbean, said: Read more

Daly Bread: The justification for ‘Independent’ senators and special majority constraints

Several readers have pressed me to say how I felt on the merits of the Prime Minister’s Pension (Amendment) Bill, Read more

Daly Bread: A time to stand firm—Independent senators must stay true to conscience

I have re-examined the long-standing perils of our manipulable state enterprise system, focusing last week on how inadequately prepared we Read more

Daly Bread: Crumbled oversight function continues to haunt state enterprises

Last Sunday, I traced the perils of having the state enterprises unrestrained by diligent and timely oversight by the constitutionally Read more

Check Also

Daly Bread: Crunch time! Can UNC Gov’t transform T&T from “get-away” place for criminals?

In the recent past, governments both of the United National Congress (UNC) and of the …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.