Daly Bread: Change or exchange? Gov’t must address CJ, SEA, panyard model and economic diversification

Our changes of government frequently receive a verdict of “no change only exchange”. The current apparent dead end in the search for a gas supply to revive certain of our petrochemical industries is illustrative of the peril of governments having no appetite for fundamental reform.

Added to all the unimaginative attempts at diversification of the economy, the recently voted out Dr Keith Rowley/Stuart Young-led People’s National Movement (PNM) government and its satellites enjoyed the status quo with borrowed money and at our expense.

Former Prime Minister Stuart Young (right) and his predecessor Dr Keith Rowley.
(Photo: OPM.)

With the simpering support of some elements in the private sector, in the face of hostility between the US and Venezuela and US sanctions against Venezuela, they clung in an almost maniacal manner to the belief that we would obtain the necessary gas supply from neighbouring Venezuela.

Sadly, the PNM’s delusions about Venezuela led the newly elected United National Congress (UNC) Government, hopeful of an alternative gas supply from Guyana, into a firm rebuff last week from Guyana vice-president Bharath Jagdeo, who stated that Guyana’s gas was to be used for Guyanese projects.

Among the leading subjects of this column regarding unaddressed problems have been our porous borders, the deficient examination of what passes through our legal ports and the uncritical maintenance of the state enterprise system, which is a questionable source of juicy contracts and wasteful expenditure.

The status quo regarding the Chief Justice is also troubling given the two substantial losses before the Privy Council (PC) suffered by the Chief Justice and the Judicial and Legal Service Commission, (the JLSC), which the CJ chairs.

Between November 2017 and January 2018 there were media reports making allegations against the CJ.

The CJ failed in his attempt to obtain an injunction to prevent the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago (LATT) from proceeding with its proposed inquiry into whether to make a request of the PM to act under section 137 of the Constitution and advise the President of the Republic to initiate a formal inquiry into the CJ’s conduct.

(From left) Chief Justice Ivor Archie, President Christine Kangaloo, her husband Kerwyn Garcia SC and then Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley.
(Copyright Office of the President.)

After the CJ lost in the PC, the matter ended when the then Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley announced that he would not accede to any such request of LATT.

More recently, in dealing with the fiasco of the appointment of Marcia Ayers-Caesar as a High Court judge, the PC found that it was no part of the JLSC’s role (nor the role of the Chief Justice), to seek to procure the removal of the judge by other means, such as resignation.

The PC held that Ayers-Caesar had been unlawfully pressured to resign in circumvention of the constitutional safeguards laid down in section 137.

Chief Justice Iver Archie (left) and then Judge Marcia Ayers-Caesar.

Can we be comfortable with nothing coming out of the Ayers-Caesar findings?

I raise this matter stimulated by my disappointment that LATT may have unwisely opened itself to claims that it was not evenly holding the balance concerning proper conduct.

LATT issued a heavy-handed media release rebuking Israel Khan SC for his theatrical, well-publicised protest in support of his call for the CJ to be investigated—when he used a hammer to smash a framed picture of the CJ, in his own property and in his private office.

Students unwind after taking the 2023 Secondary Entrance Assessment (SEA) exams.
Photo: Ministry of Education.

Also high on my list is the failure to deal with the huge negatives of the Secondary Entrance Assessment (SEA).

Many children who do not pass the examination with marks that entitle them to be placed in the “better” schools become vulnerable to immersion in gang and gun violence, as lack of equal opportunity and frustration eats away at them.

Related to the failure to reform the education system is the indifference to investment in the panyards as places of learning and nurture.

The San Juan East Side Symphony perform at the Pan Trinbago Single Pan Band finals on 14 December 2024.
Photo: Pan Trinbago.

It matters not to me when my phrase panyard model is used without attribution, either to me or the late Lloyd Best, or there is no acknowledgment that the successful separation of the medium and big band Panorama finals followed my advocacy for “prime bands in prime time”.

I now look forward to the new Minister of Culture exploring with her Cabinet colleagues what the pan manufacturing sector can contribute to the diversification of the economy.

Will the UNC Government avoid a verdict of “only exchange”? Can it find the necessary self-restraint so that rationality and not bitter partisanship guides reform?

More from Wired868
Dear Editor: Congrats to Jack Warner—but what does his extradition success mean for T&T?

“[…] On 23 September, Justice Karen Reid ruled that the extradition process against him was flawed and has permanently stopped Read more

Dear Editor: Who is paying Roger Alexander’s legal bills? The public deserves transparency

“[…] When a sitting minister hires some of the most expensive lawyers in the country, the public has a right Read more

Daly Bread: Ambiguity, sovereignty and policy palsy—pondering US’ naval play and NGC’s withdrawal

Last week, in light of the current United States naval presence in Caribbean waters, I posed a question about sovereignty, Read more

Dear Editor: PM had enough time to study PNM mistakes—now give us budget where everybody wins

“[…] Please do not incur excessive debt to fulfil campaign promises or popular votes. Continuous deficit financing and public debt Read more

Daly Bread: Unpolluted performance—why events like Pan On D Ave matter

My last topic was the cancellation of the Independence Day military parade, which was yet another issue over which there Read more

St Louis: PNM’s post-election confession betrays T&T’s cyclical governance issues

When in government, the People’s National Movement (PNM) speaks with the certainty of authority—decisions are made, policies defended, and dissent Read more

Check Also

Dear Editor: Congrats to Jack Warner—but what does his extradition success mean for T&T?

“[…] On 23 September, Justice Karen Reid ruled that the extradition process against him was …

One comment

  1. Daly still with this pan yard nonsense? Age bringing dotage?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.