Home / View Point / Taking a long, hard look: Daly explains why courts can’t save us without better policing

Taking a long, hard look: Daly explains why courts can’t save us without better policing

I suppose one can admire the zeal with which the Attorney General, Mr Faris Al Rawi, pursues his causes in the Parliament. Likewise, members of the Opposition have made a number of valid points concerning legislation brought before the Parliament recently.

It would of course be more palatable if both sides could lower the hostility level and temper the blame game.

Photo: Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley (right) and Opposition Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar SC. (Copyright Stabroek News)
Photo: Trinidad and Tobago Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley (right) and Opposition Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar SC.
(Copyright Stabroek News)

The abolition of preliminary enquiries is long overdue but I am not so sure about the method chosen. The new legislation may place too much on the Director of Public Prosecutions—both in terms of concentration of power and work load.

The volume of material that the police must provide to the DPP is formidable and there is no guarantee that any fewer applications for judicial review will be directed at the DPP than are now directed at Magisterial proceedings.

Now the Government is moving towards criminal trials by a Judge alone if an accused agrees and the Opposition is pointing to the performance of the Judiciary as the proverbial elephant in the room.

Lawyers are not likely to advise their clients to take that option. If so, the legislation will be a mirage in the current desert of crime fighting.

Underlying all of this is an attempt to appease frustration at the level of crime, particularly murder committed with near certain impunity and at the slow pace of criminal trials. Crime is an issue that could make a Government lose an election. If passed, there will be three years before the next election to assess the value of the much touted legislation.

I fear for all of us that one root cause of the problem, which is poor policing, is not being tackled. A related root cause is some of the unsavoury interlocking connections which I described last Sunday.

Photo: Acting Commissioner of Police Stephen Williams. (Copyright Trinidad Guardian)
Photo: Acting Commissioner of Police Stephen Williams.
(Copyright Trinidad Guardian)

Taking shortcuts in the administration of justice process, of which curtailment of bail was an offensive example, is not an answer to these problems. If these root causes remain, the single judge who has to try a serious criminal case, may feel as vulnerable as the rest of us including witnesses who have to appear in Court.

If there is no law and order, witnesses are expendable regardless of whether they appear before a jury or a single judge. What is needed is a long hard look at our current lawless situation.

Both Constitutional and legislative provisions assume a certain level of good order and good governance, including competent policing, which we have not had for two decades.

I wrote last Sunday about the conflicts of interest that pervert governance and almost every form of public procurement and State based provision of services, social safety nets and infrastructure.

I asserted: “That is why we cannot make any progress in the fight against violent crime, particularly murder. The interlocking connections between institutions that are supposed to work for the public good and persons or organisations that pervert the course of the public good are too well known to explain again at any length.”

Photo: Murdered WPC Nyasha Joseph.
Photo: Murdered WPC Nyasha Joseph.

The point must be made that both major political parties have attempted to govern with these connections in their faces and sadly have pandered to them.  In these circumstances, the blame game in crime would be laughable if it is we were not literally losing many, many lives while it is being played.

A relevant example of the lack of good governance turned up last week in the form of disclosures about credit card fraud in Caribbean Airlines, in the order of TT$3.25M annually, which until now seems to have elicited little more than a shrug from the airline’s management.

It must be acknowledged that these parliamentary committees before whom public officials have to appear are a measure that works, at least to the extent of exposing grave deficiencies in governance that would otherwise be hidden.

What is required, by analogy to matters arising from minutes of a previous meeting, is scheduled follow-up sessions specifically for testimony regarding what was done about a problem revealed before the Committee or a least a written report if there are too many meetings for Parliamentarians to handle.

The exchanges, in Parliament and outside, have become more vicious than when I posed this question in May 2013: “Can our politicians stop devoting their energies to personal destruction of each other?”

I stated then “They lose and the country loses more when these scandals are let loose and linger and there is no finite end or closure. We need to restore the credibility of our constitutional institutions as a matter of urgency.”

Photo: A candle light vigil for a murder victim.
Photo: A candle light vigil for a murder victim.

Since then many more citizens have been murdered with impunity. It is legitimate to ask whether these warring politicians genuinely have our interests at the top of their agenda.

When will they take a good hard look at our now near desperate situation and begin with the police service?

About Martin Daly

Martin Daly
Martin G Daly SC is a prominent attorney-at-law. He is a former Independent Senator and past president of the Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago. He is chairman of the Pat Bishop Foundation, a board member of The Little Carib Theatre and Folkhouse and a steelpan music enthusiast.

Check Also

kamla-and-keith-rowley-stabroek-news-ftr

Can Government weather the coming storm? Best fires one at the PNM

Time was when, if yuh neighbour house on fire, yuh used to throw water on …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

21 comments

  1. Stop the corruption in this country and crime will lessen I’m sure about . You can’t stop domestic or sexually deemed crimes or a fight that resulted in a murder but their are some murders that are fueled by corruption , example URP wars , turf wars , drug wars . And all this is caused for the greed of money

  2. Big and baby steps are required. The level of crime has gotten so deep that we’ve to operate at all stages. However Operation…..Ground Zero is need urgently NOW.

    • What’s Operation Ground Zero?

    • Going into the high risk areas and reaching out to the at risk persons and their families. Getting to understand the reasons for all the anger and hate that will motivate these persons to view killing or maiming others as the only option.

    • The same way during election they have foot soldiers knocking on every door to check for votes. Why can’t they do the same to identify families that have have at risk children?

    • How do you identify at risk though? Also what if–as I believe to be the case–the root cause of crime does NOT occur in the areas with higher murder rates?

    • I believe that the police are very much aware of where things are going down. For example you will hear that this person is known to the police or this is a known drug den etc. So I am asking that they take the fight to ground zero where most police officers know where that exist.

    • I also continue to ask that there must be a sustained joint security patrol in hot areas and in highly used areas like taxi stands and all cities and towns.

    • I agree with what you are saying Joan Riley , no one is addressing the various root causes of this crime epidemic . We all know about the creation of “police states” and I’m wondering if increasing patrols in some communities would change anything . Most of these areas are the most patrolled and crime is still escalating . It does however legitimize the killing of ‘criminals’ by police . Giving priority to the areas with criminal activity will directly affect the root .

    • Nigel Reyes I hear you. I’m not giving up on my country. The ideas I’m expressing is to keep the fire burning that we must continue to seek out and reduce this scourge.I’m sure there are data from research that can be implemented to curb this free flow of criminality. I live in faith.

  3. Try a shakeup of the TTPS top brass and see if that may start to shine a light in this darkness .

  4. My only problem here is that some of us are thinking that The DPP will be burdened with much work. Correct me if I am wrong, the DPP although having the final responsibility or decision in matters indictable has a staff of qualified lawyers who will do the leg work for his final decision.

  5. But change across the board needs to happen.

  6. Earl Best

    The Guardian, of course, had, in its Saturday edition, a proper obituary, written by Raymond Ramcharitar. You have to wonder if, were he employed elsewhere than in the Sabga empire, that would have happened.

  7. Earl Best

    I read this in the Express earlier today, one of several very good columns in that paper. In fact, I want to suggest that Pages 12-15 are essential reading for people with a genuine interest in what is happening in T&T.

    But, of course, there is all the stuff about Walcott, which leaves you in no doubt about how reactive, how myopic, how immensely superficial the daily newspapers really are.